AdventAI

CONDEMNED BY THEIR OWN WORDS.

By W. A. Blakely

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 32., August 9, 1887

“By thy words thou shalt be justified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned.” With great propriety National Reform (so called) might be likened to what is generally known as a “cure all;” i. e., it professes to be a cure for all the ailments and weaknesses of human government; but in reality its effect can never be otherwise than to bring the government to which it is applied to a worse condition than that in which it was before. In fact, they profess that if we return to God as directed by the National Reform Association, it will shield us from divine judgments on the nation (like the Catholic Christianity in South American Republics!—Statesman, Dec. 11, 1884) and we shall have blessings insured to this nation heretofore unknown! In other words, an amendment to the National Constitution which will make the most bigoted hypocrites (i. e., the Pharisaical office-seekers who will parade their eminent piety before the world) the best men to fill our offices of trust, will be a grand victory for Christianity! But this will be the effect, and that they themselves are aware of it, the following, from a speech of one of their vice-presidents, will show:—

There is no more persistent man alive than the typical representative American office-seeker. Of that class, the most of those who have not yet found whether they are for Christ or not, or who are openly decrying this movement, are ready to be its firm friends as soon as they acquire wisdom to discern the signs of the times, and are assured of its speedy success. They may pull back now at the hind axle, or notch the wheels of the car of progress; but when they see it move, they will quickly jump in to get front seats, and avow that they always thought it was a good thing, etc.—Rev. Audley Brown, D. D., in Pittsburg National Convention of 1874.

These Religious Amendmentists are “all things to all men” with a vengeance. This idea was aptly stated by a writer in the American Sentinel, a monthly journal published on the science of government, of August, 1886. He said:—

They appeal to church people in behalf of religion; to moralists, in behalf of morality; to the temperance people, in behalf of temperance; and to laboring people, in behalf of a day of rest for working-men. Railroad accidents are by them held up as evidence of the displeasure of God toward the railway companies for running their trains on Sunday. Cyclones and floods are represented as the judgments of God upon the nation for its wickedness in refusing to make the decalogue (as expounded by the National Reform party) the fundamental law of the land! In short, they appeal to any and every motive to compass their ends.

The truth of this is manifest when statements made under different circumstances or with different objects in view, are contrasted. Hon. Felix R. Brunot, who has been at the head of this movement for nearly twenty years, on taking the chair in the Fifth National Convention of the National Reform Association, held in Pittsburg, Pa., Feb. 1, 1874, said:—

The Sixth Article of the Constitution declares that, “no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States,” and the First Amendment in the Constitution provides that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” We have not proposed to change these. We deem them essential, in connection with the amendment we ask, to the preservation of religious liberty, and with it, an effective guard against “a union of Church and State.”

If the statement is true, and it unquestionably is, that the Sixth Article of the Constitution and the First Amendment are essential to the preservation of religious liberty, then any movement which proposes “to change these,” is directly opposed to religious liberty. And, notwithstanding President Brunot’s disavowal of any such purpose, there cannot be a reasonable doubt that this is exactly what National Reformers propose to do. Then let us look at National Reform in this light. Rev. W. J. Coleman, one of the leading public lecturers of the association, says:—

The first sentence of Article 1 of Amendments reads, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” This would be made consistent with the proposed amendment by substituting the words “a church” for “religion,” making it read, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of a church.” This is what the Reform Association believes should be the rule in a rightly constituted State. There should be religion but no church.”—Christian Statesman, Nov. 1, 1886.

In view of these facts, then, it is obvious that the National Reform Association is opposed to religious liberty; and instead of favoring the present form of the First Amendment, they are working to have it changed; and hence, according to their own words, they are opening the way for a union of Church and State. But, to go farther, Prof. C. A. Blanchard, in the Pittsburg National Convention, said:—

Constitutional laws punish for false money, weights, and measures, and of course Congress establishes a standard for money, weight, and measure. So Congress must establish a standard of religion, or admit anything called religion. [And then after that] enforce upon all that come among us the laws of Christian morality.—Christian Statesman, Oct. 2, 1884.

So they not only want to open the way for the union of Church and State, but they themselves want to unite them; and, in order to do it, they “will gladly join hands” with the Roman Catholic Church “whenever they [the Catholics] are willing to co-operate in resisting the progress of political atheism” (i. e., opposition to the National Reform theory of government). As further evidence, we give the language of Prof. Sloane, D. D., used in the Cincinnati National Reform Convention in 1872:—

Every government, by equitable laws, is a government of God; a republic thus governed is of him, through the people, and is as truly and really a theocracy as the commonwealth of Israel.

So their real idea is to have a government of God, or Christ, through the people (i. e., through National Reformers); and, of course, they will say that if it was right for Israel to enforce the true religion then it is right for us to do it.

And, as has been quoted before, President Brunot said that they deemed the Sixth Article of the Constitution, which forbids any religious test as a qualification for office, as essential, in connection with their proposed amendment, “to the preservation of religious liberty.” Yet the following year the Christian Statesman, in speaking of certain national officials (among them Vice-President Colfax) who had arrived in the national capital on Sunday trains some time before, made the following comments (italics theirs):—

Not one of these men who thus violated the Sabbath is fit to hold official position in a Christian nation. . . . Give us in the National Constitution the simple acknowledgment of the law of God as the supreme law of nations, and all the results indicated in this note will ultimately be secured. Let no one say that the movement does not contemplate sufficiently practical ends.

Then, after they have obtained “the simple acknowledgment of the law of God as the supreme law” of this nation, what next? Simply this: In the same memorial in which they asked for that “acknowledgment,” they said:—

And further: that such changes with respect to the oath of office, slavery, and all other matters should be introduced into the body of the Constitution as may be necessary to give effect to these amendments in the Preamble.—Memorial to Congress.

Then, of course, as fines and imprisonments fail to make all observe Sunday, severer punishments will be resorted to. Then, finally, they will say: If it was right for Israel to punish by death the breaking of the Sabbath, it is right for us. No one thinks that this is what they now intend to do; but, as Edward Gibbon, the eminent historian, says:—

It is incumbent on the authors of persecution previously to reflect whether they are determined to support it in the last extreme. They excite the flame which they strive to extinguish; and it soon becomes necessary to chastise the contumacy, as well as the crime, of the offender. The fine which he is unable or unwilling to discharge, exposes his person to the severities of the law; and his contempt of lighter penalties suggests the use and propriety of capital punishment.—Decline and Fall, chap. 37, par. 23.

Again, in the Pittsburg National Reform Convention, President Brunot said:—p. 503

No State can rightly attempt to compel the consciences of its citizens with a particular religion, and, as we believe, no particular religion can rightly attempt to use the State to compel men’s consciences to its belief.

And Rev. M. A. Gault, in his “Clashing Voices,” in the Christian Statesman, Sept. 9, 1886, says:—

It is outside the province of human government to supervise the thoughts and opinions of any one.

These statements can only be regarded as condemning their own work; for in an editorial of the Christian Statesman, of Oct. 2, 1884, we find these words:—

Give all men to understand that this is a Christian nation; and that, believing that without Christianity we perish, we must maintain by all right means our Christian character. Inscribe this character on our Constitution. . . . Enforce [i. e., “execute with vigor.”—Webster] upon all that come among us the laws of [what National Reformers consider as] Christian morality.

It makes no difference what they believe, force upon them these laws! It may be that there are some Christians who have conscientious scruples in regard to obeying some of these laws; it makes no difference; “enforce upon all the laws of Christian morality.” There may also be some who think that tradition—not the Bible—is the authority for the law, and hence they cannot consistently obey it, “the Bible, and the Bible alone,” being their authority; but it makes no difference, “enforce upon all the laws of [what the churches call] Christian morality.” The reason I say “the churches,” is because that is National Reform doctrine. Rev. J. C. K. Milligan, a vice-president and leading member of the association, said:—

The churches and the pulpits have much to do with shaping and forming opinions on all moral questions, and with interpretations of Scripture on moral and civil, as well as on theological and ecclesiastical points; and it is probable that in the almost universal gathering of our citizens about these, the chief discussions and the final decision of most points will be developed there.—Christian Statesman.

Of course they would make laws that would be in accordance with the consciences of all; for “no State can rightly attempt to compel the consciences of its citizens with a particular religion,” and, “it is outside the province of human government to supervise the thoughts and opinions of any one.” Now for the guarantee of liberty of conscience. It comes from no less authority than Rev. John Calvin Knox Milligan himself, who says:—

There certainly is no class of citizens more intelligent, patriotic, and trustworthy than the leaders and teachers in our churches.

As an illustration of the above, just look at the legislation of Rome, of which Lord Macaulay wrote: “It is impossible to deny that the polity of the Church of Rome is the very masterpiece of human wisdom;” then, again, at the patriotism of the Jesuit, and the trustworthiness of the pope! So will this National Reform be; for they are very desirous of uniting with this same power in establishing this order of things in the United States. See Christian Statesman of Aug. 31, 1881, and of Dec. 11, 1884.

The idea of putting religious legislation in the hands of churches, and then blandly saying that there will be no danger of any one having his rights of conscience infringed upon! Any intelligent man who is at all acquainted with history knows better. But for National Reformers to talk that way is positively ridiculous. For Dr. Jonathan Edwards thus disposes of all opponents to National Reform:—

The atheist is a man who denies the being of a God and a future life. To him, mind and matter are the same, and time is the be-all and end-all of consciousness and of character.

The deist admits God, but denies that he has any such control over human affairs as we call providence, or that he ever manifests himself and his will in a revelation.

The Jew admits God, providence, and revelation, but rejects the entire scheme of gospel redemption by Jesus Christ as sheer imagination, or worse sheer imposture.

The Seventh-day Baptists believe in God and Christianity, and are conjoined with the other members of this class by the accident of differing with the mass of Christians upon the question of what precise day of the week shall be observed as holy.

These all are, for the occasion, and as far as our amendment is concerned, one class. They use the same arguments and the same tactics against us. They must be counted together, which we very much regret, but which we cannot help. The first-named is the leader in the discontent and the outcry—the atheist, to whom nothing is higher or more sacred than man, and nothing survives the tomb. It is his class. Its labors are almost wholly in his interest; its success would be almost wholly his triumph. The rest are adjuncts to him in this contest. They must be named from him; they must be treated as, for this question, one party.

So, then, all statements that they make concerning atheists, infidels, etc., apply to all, even conscientious Christians, who oppose this “reform” movement. “They use the same arguments and . . . tactics” against them; and hence, “they must be named from” and “treated as” the atheist. Then how are “atheists” or “infidels” to be treated? you ask. Says W. J. Coleman, a leading public lecturer:—

The existence of a Christian Constitution would disfranchise every logically consistent infidel.—Christian Statesman, Nov. 1, 1883.

Rev. E. B. Graham, another vice-president, in an address delivered before a National Reform convention, said:—

We might add, in justice, if the opponents of the Bible do not like our Government and its Christian features, let them go to some wild, desolate land; and in the name of the Devil, and for the sake of the Devil, subdue it, and set up a government of their own on infidel and atheistic ideas, and then, if they can stand it, stay there till they die.—Christian Statesman, May 21, 1885.

And then Dr. Jonathan Edwards says:—

Tolerate atheism, sir? There is nothing out of hell that I would not tolerate as soon.

Nevertheless the leading man in the association says that “no State can rightly attempt to compel the conscience of its citizens with a particular religion.” Then it is evident that this association is wrongly attempting to do it; for they are attempting. We state it, too, according to the words of their own president. Now, with the foregoing statements in mind, read the following:—

Resolved, That we re-affirm that this religious amendment, instead of infringing on any individual’s right of conscience, or tending in the least degree to union of Church and State, will afford the fullest security against a corrupting church establishment, and form the strongest safeguard of both the civil and religious liberties of all citizens.—National Reform Convention, Cleveland Ohio.

And now to show that they know that this movement will infringe on the rights of conscience, we quote further from Mr. Coleman:—

If there be any Christian who objects to the proposed amendment on the ground that it might touch the conscience of the infidel, it seems to me it would be in order to inquire whether he himself should not have some conscience in this matter.—Christian Statesman, Nov. 1, 1883.

The rights of conscience never conflict. If a law touches the conscience of an infidel, the power making that law is trespassing beyond its right. It would be a blessing to every government if its citizens only looked at the question in the following light:—

There ought to be room in this world for all the consciences in it, without any encroachment upon the rights of each other; and there would be if all men, in their relations to each other, would be content to exercise their own rights of conscience in a reasonable manner. This would leave every man to determine the religious question for himself, and, as the necessary consequence, relieve every man from all impositions, burdens, taxes, or disabilities arising from the determination of the question by others. Though the rule is a simple one, it is, nevertheless, one of the most difficult things for bigotry to learn. The only way to learn it effectually is not to be a bigot.—Samuel T. Spear, D. D., in Religion and State.

But bigots will be bigots; and you cannot reason them out of it either. And herein is the doctrine of National Reform, bigotry: they imagine that Christians who favor their doctrine or theory of government, are the only ones in the world who should be allowed to be citizens of the United States; and that all others who are now citizens should be disfranchised, and then sent off to some “wild, desolate land,” to “stay there till they die.” And then they think that their “Christian” act will please the Creator to such an extent that he will thenceforth protect this nation from further calamities, judgments, etc., and that they will then enjoy undisturbed serenity! For says Rev. C. E. Walker, in the Christian Nation:—

As a nation we have suffered judgments, and will suffer yet more, far more, unless the people return to God as directed by the National Reform Association!

W. A. BLAKELY.