AdventAI

THE UNDERLYING THEORY OF SUNDAY LEGISLATION.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 32., August 9, 1887

The supreme court of the State of Louisiana has recently rendered a decision on the validity of the Sunday law of that State, which the Independent terms “an excellent lucid statement of the theory which underlies all legislation that requires the suspension of ordinary labor on Sunday.” Doubtless many others have thought it the same. This decision runs as follows:—

We take occasion promptly to say that, if the object of the law were to compel the observance of Sunday as a religious institution, we would not hesitate to declare it to be violative of the above constitutional prohibition. It would violate equally the religious liberty of the Christian, the Jew, and the infidel, none of whom can be compelled by law to comply with any merely religious observance, whether it accords with his faith and conscience or not. With rare exceptions the American authorities concur in this view. . . . The statute is to be judged of precisely as if it had selected for the day of rest any day of the week, other than Sunday; and its validity is not to be questioned because in the exercise of a wise discretion it has chosen that day which a majority of the inhabitants of this State, under the sanctions of their religious faith, already voluntarily observe as a day of rest.”

“With rare exceptions,” says this decision, “the American authorities concur in this view.” The court here evidently did not have reference to American ecclesiastical authorities. They do not concur in any such view; far from it. And as they constitute preeminently the power which is pushing this question through, it sounds to us a little like presumption for the civil authorities to put the question in this form. But supposing this to be the true basis upon which this question of Sunday observance rests, it would be no less a violation of religious liberty. Let us see. The Independent, and doubtless the supreme court of Louisiana, believes the ten commandments are still binding. The fourth of these commandments says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work.” So far it does not interfere with the above decision. But this is not all. It says further, “Six days shalt thou labor and do all thy work.” Is the fourth commandment a mere civil regulation? No one will claim this. Here, then, is a guarantee of every man’s liberty, and religious liberty, too, to work six days of every week. Or is the liberty which the great God thus guaranteed not religious liberty? And if God has given to us this right, nay, has even commanded it, where is the human authority which has the right to take it away? The only other way in which we could secure this God-given right would be to conform to the custom of the popular denominations around us—rest on Sunday and work on the six days following; and if this would not be a violation of our liberty of conscience, nothing in the world could be.

The language which follows reminds us that it is an easy thing to make statements of what is right or wrong when it does not touch ourselves, but not so easy to do this impartially when the case is otherwise. “The statute is to be judged of precisely as if it had selected for the day of rest any day of the week, other than Sunday.” Very likely; but it so happened that it did not select any other day of the week, and so the community in general missed the rare opportunity of seeing just how it would have been judged if some other day had been chosen. We think it would have been a spectacle well worth seeing.

The statement that the framers of this statute, in selecting Sunday, exercised a wise discretion, savors slightly of the ludicrous. Truly this must have required the exercise of superhuman wisdom. It was so perplexing and difficult a question that they probably spent many anxious days and sleepless nights in trying to arrive at its solution. But finally, after weighing all the points in favor of each day long and carefully, they decided that the proper day was Sunday! What is more remarkable, too, is that all other framers of similar statutes, of whom the number is legion, have been gifted with this same power of discretion. The statute has no connection with the religious observance of any day, and hence any one of the seven would answer the purpose equally well; yet from such slight data the statute-makers have invariably discovered that the only proper day to select was Sunday.

It is a pity that, for a short time at least, some other day could not be selected, just to see how many of the people of this land really believe such a statute has no bearing upon religious liberty. Let our legislators select, for instance, Saturday, or Monday, or Wednesday, and set to work making statutes to enforce its observance upon the people. The howl of indignation which would resound through the land would open a great many blind eyes on this question, and put a sudden stop to the flow of a vast amount of sophistry from the lips of bigoted adherents of the pagan holiday. L. A. S.