AdventAI

A SEPARATE SECT.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 32., August 9, 1887

The Michigan Christian Advocate indorses a sentiment expressed by one of its correspondents, that the Seventh-day Adventist denomination “holds no distinctive truth whatever upon which to build a separate sect.” There is no force to this statement unless it is to be understood to mean that we are so near like other Christian bodies that there is no occasion for us to maintain a separate organization. If this is its meaning, then, judged by their own standard, we are not so terrible a people after all; we are not such rank heretics as some would have us believe. If we are so near like them that there is no reason for us to exist as a distinctive body, theoretically we must be in their eyes a pretty good sort of people. Then why all this racket in the land over Seventh-day Adventists? why do pulpits thunder and papers flutter from one end of the country to the other, warning people against the “miry pool,” the “deadly heresy,” the “Godless materialism” of Seventh-day Adventism?

But if the idea is that we hold “no distinctive truth whatever upon which to build a separate sect,” because the distinctive doctrines upon which we do rest our denominational existence are not truths but errors, that is begging the whole question; for that is the very point to be proved. Moreover, this is only what any denomination might say of any other; for of course each denomination believes it is right and all others, on the points of difference between them, are wrong. For instance, the Baptists have built up a denomination on the doctrine of immersion; but the Methodists might, on this ground, say of them that they have “no distinctive truth whatever upon which to build a separate sect,” for the Methodists hold that sprinkling or pouring is baptism, and that, while immersion may, under some circumstances, be allowed if the candidate is strenuous about it, yet it is not required, and certainly should not cause the formation of a new sect.

Therefore taken in its first sense it relieves us from doctrinal censure; taken in its second, it applies to all other denominations as fully as to ourselves.