AdventAI

DIVISIONS VS. VISIONS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 24., June 14, 1887

As promised last week, we now offer a few thoughts upon this point. The vital question in determining the nature of any belief, movement, or practice, is, What is its tendency? Does it lead to good results or evil? “By their fruits ye shall know them.” If the results are bad, the practice or belief is bad; if good, it is not to be condemned. Even if it may not seem to have a good foundation in reason, if no evil results come from it, it can be set down, at worst, as only a harmless kind of hallucination; and if some prize it, and think they derive good and comfort from it, why not let them enjoy it in peace?

We have read labored articles against the visions of Mrs. E. G. White, in which the writers, after trying to make out in them errors, inconsistencies, and contradictions, when coming to the real question of the tendency or results, were obliged to content themselves with this one charge: that “they divide churches, and alienate Christians from each other.”

The charge of division, in itself considered, amounts to nothing. Division is the result of the conflict between truth and error everywhere. Probably the Sabbath truth has done more of this kind of work than any other portion of our faith; and Christ himself said that he came not to send peace on earth but a sword. When division comes in consequence of the conflicting claims of truth and error, who is to blame for it? and who is responsible for it? No right-minded person will say that it is he who adheres to the truth. When truth is presented, all ought to receive it; and if they should do so there would be no division and no alienation. These evils, then, arise from the refusal of some to do their duty.

When divisions come on account of the visions, who is to blame and responsible? those who receive them, or those who reject them? If all ought to receive them, the trouble lies with those who will not; if those who do receive them can do so without detriment to themselves or any one else, then certainly others have no reason to imbibe such a spirit of opposition against them as not to allow such persons to do so in peace, but draw off and make division on account of it. In this case the responsibility is still with them. But they say the visions cause division and alienation, and so should be rejected. But who has made the division?—They themselves, by drawing off on account of them. Thus they make the divisions, and then swallow themselves by charging these divisions upon the visions, as the reason why they make them.

SOME THINGS WE KNOW.

1. We know of a good many churches which are not divided by the visions, and a good many Christian hearts that are not alienated by them. If it is their nature to make divisions and sow discord, why are not these effects seen in every church instead of only a few isolated cases?

2. Though some may now be, as they claim, engaged in opposition against them without any motive, as noticed last week, we know that opposition began on the part of those whose wrongs it was necessary to reprove, and whose fanaticism it was necessary to restrain; and it began simply because such wrongs and fanaticism came under censure.

3. We know that those who have at any time seen fit to draw off from the body have been very largely in the minority. If this feature of our faith is so apparently an evil, how does it happen that all wisdom and discernment were the property of the few instead of the many? And on what grounds do these set themselves up as a standard for the rest, saying, Because we cannot receive the visions, therefore no one ought to receive them?

4. We know that the fathers of the various secessions that have taken place from first to last, have after a time broken down in their work, and given up their movement, some going to Universalism, some to Spiritualism, some to the world, the flesh, and the Devil, so that their work has had to fall into other hands. Can any one harmonize these facts with the idea that these moves are the work of God? It is not the way he has done in any past age of the world; and we may be sure he will not perform his closing work in any such disgraceful manner.

5. The cause of the Third Angel’s Message, with its doctrine of spiritual gifts, though not advancing as fast as we would have been glad to see it, has nevertheless made steady progress. And while we have nothing over which to boast, we have much cause for encouragement and hope. Our work never presented a broader front, a deeper foundation, a more progressive spirit, more financial strength, and a brighter outlook, than it presents to-day. But how is it with this work of opposition which has been waged ostensibly against the visions, and through them to the message itself. There have been times when it could show more talent and more strength than it can show to-day. This was notably the case, when, after the Michigan fiasco, the disaffection broke out afresh in Iowa in 1865, under Snook, Brinkerhoof, Shortridge, and Co. Our people then numbered in Iowa less than 300. For the earliest enumeration we have was in 1867, and the figures then stood only 390. That Conference now has a membership of 1,550. The total number of S. D. Adventists in all the Conferences was then, 4,320. The present number is over 24,000. We have not the data from which to speak definitely concerning the other class, who are engaged in this opposition to the visions; but we doubt if in all this time they can show an increase of three hundred. But we are told that increase in numbers does not prove anything, and Mohammedanism and Mormonism are cited as proof. But such a comparison is not legitimate. Those huge systems of iniquity which pander to the low and sensual passions, and the most flattering superstitions of men, are no criterion by which to judge of the progress of any of the truths of the gospel, which do not flatter men but condemn them; which call upon them for self-denial, instead of promising them all self-indulgence. We think our work will compare well with that of any of the evangelical denominations in the same number of years from its beginning. For instance, Methodism during its first forty years, did not make the progress that our work has made in that time. We refer to this matter simply with reference to this one point; namely, the claim is made on the part of the opposition we are considering, that their move in drawing off and opposing this message, is the work of God, and that this is a system of delusion, oppression, and error, which the Lord is not with. If this be so, they have to explain how it is that their work has maintained only an uncertain precarious existence, in shifting hands, while this, with its closer tests and higher standard, has been steadily onward. From the decision of Gamaliel we believe no one has ever yet taken any appeal, that any work which rests only upon the counsel of men will come to nought, but that which has the authority of God behind it cannot be overthrown.

6. The methods employed by the faction we are considering, in prosecuting their work, and the spirit manifested, are such as fair and honorable men would scorn to follow. Snooking around after our preachers, if they learn that they are having any success, and bringing souls to an observance of the Sabbath, they will immediately endeavor to reach such persons with their pernicious literature, to prejudice them and turn them away from what they are receiving. And if they cannot learn their names, they will send to the postmaster of the place, requesting him to hand their pamphlets to any who have begun to observe the seventh-day. Frequently the request is to hand them to any disaffected S. D. Adventist. For instance, when we had established a mission 12,000 miles away, in Australia, and begun to bring converts to the faith, it was not long before a package of their trash came on, with the request that they be handed to any disaffected S. D. Adventists. Thus they demean themselves to a work which would entitle them to the name of “The Scavenger Party.” In this instance their works fell into the hands of a judicious person, who “placed them where they would do the most good.” Not unfrequently the packages are immediately forwarded to this Office by those who are disgusted with such evidences of duplicity. These men profess to love the Sabbath, and believe that it is an important and essential truth for these last days; yet they know that if the work they are doing, above referred to, shall have any effect at all, it will in nine cases out of ten not only turn them away from the Sabbath and all prophetic truth as well. Apparently they would stand by complacently, and see a person imbibe the most glaring and dangerous errors, if they could only keep him from believing the visions. Such malignity is explainable only on one ground.

But, it may be asked, do you not procure addresses and send out publications?—To be sure, but not simply to tear down. For instance, we present to all we can reach the important truth of the Sabbath. If they accept that, the Sunday question will adjust itself; and so we give them something better than they had before. But we would not spend a dime to dissuade people even from keeping Sunday, if we had nothing better to give them in its place. But if these men can dissuade people from believing the visions, they seem not to care what goes down with them. And what have they to offer in their place?—Nothing; for the voices by which their views are set forth, furnish as complete a Babel as is compatible with the paucity of their numbers.

7. We look over the bodies of people interested in the subjects of the Sabbath and the second coming of Christ, and we are at once struck with a fact which is indeed a remarkable one if the visions are such an element of discord, confusion, and division as their enemies contend. The fact is this: that people who accept the visions constitute the largest united body of Sabbath-keepers or Adventists to be found in the world. By “united,” we mean those who agree in their views, labor for the same objects, are harmonious in their counsels, and co-operate in their methods. Others are largely divided in sentiment, confused in plans, and laboring at cross-purposes. This people, moreover, are doing more to call the attention of the world to the great Bible doctrines of the Sabbath and second coming of Christ, than all other Sabbath-keepers and Adventists combined. Their periodical literature is fourfold more than that of the classes last named, while their book sales exceed those of the others all put together more than tenfold. They are more thoroughly organized, and their methods of labor more completely systematized.

It is not in any boastful spirit that these statements are made. We have only to regret that believers are still so few, and so little is being done. But we refer to them only as they have a bearing on the question before us, of the nature and effect of the visions. Where these are, there is union and progress; where they are not, there is confusion and weakness. Yet we are asked to give up the visions because they divide the brethren and hinder and cripple the work. No; thank you! not until two changes shall occur: first, a change for the worse in our cause, and, secondly, a change for the better in yours.

Of the efforts that are made to find contradictions in the visions, the charge of suppression, etc., we may perhaps speak in future numbers.