AdventAI

QUESTIONS ON THE SANCTUARY.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 24., June 14, 1887

The following queries are sometimes raised as objections to the views we hold on the subject of the Sanctuary. We ask the candid attention of the reader to the thoughts presented and the scriptures quoted in consideration of them, believing that they not only remove all ground of difficulty, but furnish the strongest evidence that the position we hold is correct. That position, in brief, is this: 1. That the sanctuary and priesthood of the Mosaic dispensation represented in shadow the sanctuary and priesthood of the present or Christian dispensation (Heb. 8:5); 2. That this Sanctuary and priesthood are in heaven, resembling the former as nearly as heavenly things may resemble the earthly (Heb. 9:23, 24); 3. That the ministry of Christ, our great high priest, in the heavenly Sanctuary is composed of two great divisions, as in the type; first, in the first apartment, or holy place, and, secondly, in the second apartment, or most holy place; 4. That the beginning of his ministry in the second apartment is marked by the great prophetic period of 2,300 days (Dan. 8:14), and began when those days ended in 1844; 5. That the ministry he is now performing in the second apartment of the heavenly temple, is “the atonement” (Lev. 16:17), the “cleansing of the Sanctuary” (Dan. 8:14), the “investigative Judgment” (Dan. 7:10), the “finishing of the mystery of God” (Rev. 10:7; 11:15, 19), which will complete Christ’s work as priest, consummate the plan of salvation, terminate human probation, decide every case for eternity, and bring Christ to his throne of eternal dominion.

These propositions once established are absolutelyp. 377 decisive as touching all questions of prophecy relative to the second coming of Christ, and all questions of duty touching our obligation to the law of God. It becomes us, then, to examine with care the foundations upon which they rest, and candidly consider whatever may seem to any as objections to these positions. This we are happy to do. The following points are among those that first occur for examination:—

“1. Heb. 10:20 calls the vail his flesh. Rev. 1:20 explains that the seven candlesticks are symbols of the seven churches. Now if the Sanctuary in heaven is literal and according to the one built by Moses, why this explanation?”

We answer by saying that we do not understand Heb. 10:20 to call the vail his flesh. The verse reads: “By a new and living way, which he hath consecrated for us, through the vail, that is to say, his flesh.” What is the subject upon which Paul treats in this verse? It is the “new and living way” which Christ hath consecrated for us. Through what does this way lead?—Through the vail. And what is this way which he has provided for us?—It is his flesh. Paul’s declaration is that Christ’s flesh is, not the vail, but the new and living way through the vail. And the meaning evidently is that it is by the flesh of Christ, or, in other words, by the offering which he has provided in the sacrifice of himself, that we are able to enter by faith through the vail into the Sanctuary above for the forgiveness of our sins. This is simple and plain. But with the view that his flesh is the vail, the text would be both confused and imperfect; for then we should find Paul speaking of a way through Christ’s flesh which would be an incomprehensible idea; and, secondly, we should find him introducing the subject of a new and living way, and then leaving it without telling us what that way is, or to what it leads. That is neither like Paul, nor the Holy Spirit by which he wrote.

In reference to the candlestick, we think it an entire mistake to regard the seven candlesticks of Rev. 1:12, 13, as the antitype of the candlestick of the sanctuary; for, first, these are seven distinct and separate candlesticks, or “lamp stands,” as the word here signifies; but the sanctuary candlestick was only one, with seven branches. Secondly, one like the Son of man was seen walking in the midst of the seven candlesticks; but the high priest never climbed up among the seven branches of the one candlestick of the sanctuary, nor walked around in the midst of them. They therefore have no connection with each other. The seven candlesticks are simply introduced as symbols of the seven churches. When we inquire for the antitype of the sanctuary candlestick, we find it in the seven lamps of fire which John saw before the throne. Rev. 4:5.

A second difficulty which sometimes arises, is the following:—

“Heb. 10:12, says, He ‘sat down [past tense] on the right hand of God,’ which must have been in the most holy place. Now if Christ entered the most holy place on his ascension (as these texts plainly imply), the view you hold of the sanctuary and 2,300 days is shaken to the foundation.”

In reply to the objection, we answer that we entirely disagree with the conclusion that the expression “at the right hand of God,” always means in the most holy place. Stephen said (Acts 7:56), that he saw heaven opened, and Jesus standing on the right hand of God. Was this the most holy place? That apartment of the Sanctuary was not opened, nor anything seen there, according to the evidence of the Scriptures, till the seventh trumpet commenced to sound, near the end. Rev. 11:19. Again, our Lord himself said, (Matt. 26:64), “Hereafter shall ye see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.” Is he in the most holy place when he is coming in the clouds of heaven? Yet he is, in that very act, “sitting on the right hand of power,” or, which is obviously the same thing, sitting at the right hand of God. These texts show that this expression, “at the right hand of God,” simply denotes the position Christ holds in relation to God, as the second in exaltation, power, and glory.

But, for the sake of the argument, let us take it in its strictest sense, as there are scriptures (Rev. 3:21; Zech. 6:12, 13) which speak of Christ as actually seated with the Father upon his throne. And this position of course he assumed when he ascended. Still we claim that there is not the least proof in this that when Christ ascended he entered into the most holy place; for God’s throne is not always and immovably in the most holy place. Where is the proof that it is? It will be answered, perhaps, that God is represented as dwelling between the cherubim, which were upon the ark in the most holy place. These expressions are all found in the Old Testament, and have evident reference to the arrangement of the earthly sanctuary. God told Moses that he would meet him from between the two cherubim; and there he manifested his glory. Now suppose that during that period when God communed with mankind through the earthly sanctuary, he ordained to meet them nowhere else but from between the cherubim, would it follow that while in heaven he must be always in that particular place? This conclusion does not seem at all necessary. The law had a shadow, but not the very image of the things.

If it be said that some of these expressions refer to God’s position in heaven, as the prayer of Hezekiah (2 Kings 19:15, 16), then it follows that he does not remain fixed in that place; for he left it to come down and communicate with Moses and the elders of Israel. If Ps. 99:1 be referred to, we answer that that verse evidently refers to the time when the earth is to be moved (margin, stagger), or reel to and fro like a drunkard, as Isaiah has it, at the voice of God. Isa. 24:20; Jer. 25:30; Joel 3:16; Rev. 16:17. And at this time his position is between the cherubim in the most holy place, where the priesthood of our Lord then terminates.

But even here upon the earth, although the general rule was that God would commune with Moses from between the cherubim, if these were the cherubim of the mercy-seat, he did not always confine himself to that position; for he sometimes met Moses at the door of the tabernacle. Ex. 33:9; Num. 12:5; Deut. 31:15.

Finally, the throne of God itself, as it exists in heaven, is a living, moving throne. Read Ezekiel’s sublime description of this in his first and tenth chapters. Over the heads of living creatures of awful majesty, called cherubim, was the likeness of a firmament, and over that the likeness of a throne, and one above upon it, which the prophet calls “the appearance of the likeness of the glory of the Lord.” In chapter ten he calls it “the living creature that” he “saw under the God of Israel.” Beyond all question, the prophet here had a vision of God in his holy temple. He himself calls it “visions of God.” Chap. 1:1. And this wonderful being, full of eyes and the Spirit of God, is represented as moving about with the Lord of Israel, the Almighty; and the glory of the Lord appeared at times at the threshold of the house, or temple, not always in the most holy place.

All these facts and considerations go to show that we are not to conceive of the throne of God as any earthly throne, composed of inert material, but one of awful life and majesty. Nor are we to conceive of it as an immovable structure, but borne up by the living creatures, and in a measure incorporated with them, who have the power to go and return like a flash of lightning. Eze. 1:14. Are not these the cherubim between which God dwells? And were not the cherubim placed upon the mercy-seat to represent the fact that these were the foundation of God’s living throne? Whoever, therefore, builds a theory upon the idea that God’s throne is an immovable structure, and always in the same place, is sure to build an erroneous one.

In John’s first view of the heavenly Sanctuary, he saw the throne of God in the holy place. Rev. 4:1–6. Here John beheld, not heaven opened, but a door opened in heaven. And within the apartment opened before him, he saw a throne circled with the rainbow, and glowing like an emerald. The one seated upon the throne was the Father; for Christ is subsequently introduced as the one who took from his right hand the book sealed with seven seals. And before the throne there were seven lamps of fire, the antitype of the candlestick of the earthly sanctuary, which was placed in the first apartment. John’s field of vision, therefore, in this instance, lies in the first apartment of the heavenly Sanctuary, and he there beholds the throne of God; and he sees the Father, the Son, the four and twenty elders, the four living creatures, and the innumerable company of angels acting together in reference to the salvation of man. Here, then, is positive proof that the first part of Christ’s ministry before his Father was performed in the holy place. We find equal evidence that when the time comes for a change in the ministration from the holy to the most holy place, there is a change in the position of the Father. The opening of the work in the most holy place is undoubtedly described in Dan. 7:9, 10; and there we find this significant language: “I beheld till the thrones were cast down [placed], and the Ancient of days did sit.” The Ancient of days can be none other than God the Father. The expression that he “did sit,” shows that he here took a position which, in this work, he had not before occupied. In other words, he changed his position from the holy to the most holy place. He thus having changed his position, there is room for the fulfillment of verses 13 and 14, which represent Christ with his holy retinue as being brought into his presence to receive his kingdom, glory, and dominion. This certainly did not take place at the time of Christ’s ascension; and there is no place to locate it, without supposing some such movement as is here suggested, on the part of God. These conclusions are necessary; and as they are the only ones which will harmonize all the Scriptures on the point, we may rest with all confidence on their correctness.