Dr. Leonard W. Bacon, in his sermon on John 10:16, “Other sheep I have, which are not of this fold,” etc., says:—
“The world of men is so great, and the fold is so small, and within the fold are so many who are not of the Lord’s own sheep, that we cling to this word of his, spoken in that dreadful age when the world was at its worst, that he has other sheep besides those that are visibly his own; and we wonder whether from among those sordid, foul, depraved communities of which Paul writes to the Romans, there were not many, even then, who, without law, were doing the things contained in the law, and who would be surprised in the Judgment day to find themselves justified and saved by a Saviour of whom they had never heard.”
Having given this statement in regard to the possible salvation of some of the heathen who had never heard the gospel, Dr. Bacon goes on to declare that in Litchfield, Conn., his first pastoral charge, “some of the truest Christians in all the community, humble, diligent, charitable, believing, devoutly spiritual, were outside of the communion of the church.” The doctor evidently thinks that the Litchfield parish was not exceptional in this respect; but that all over Christendom there are many true Christians who are not church-members. This is a somewhat startling statement, and we are not prepared to receive it, even on the ipse dixit of so brilliant a writer as Dr. Bacon.
In the first place, we are not sure that his exegesis of the passage is right. We remember that when Paul was in Corinth, and had as yet made no converts, the Lord said to him, “Speak, and hold not thy peace: . . . for I have much people in this city.” He evidently meant that there were many there who, under Paul’s preaching, would become his people. And so our Saviour may have meant that there were sheep not yet in the fold who would be brought into it. If he referred to the ingathering of the Gentiles through the labors of the apostles, then the passage teaches nothing about outside Christians either in heathendom or Christendom.
But accepting the exegesis, can we believe that what he claims as true at Litchfield is true all over the land—that some of the best Christians are outside of the church? We cannot think so. There may be an exceptional and abnormal case here and there. We ourselves have encountered one or two in an intercourse with Christian churches and communities, of nearly half a century. But the almost universal rule is that the people of God are in the church of God. The sheep are in the shepherd’s fold, and not wandering among the wolves in the wilderness. And in this matter reason confirms observation. We do not see how any intelligent Christian can remain out of the communion of the church, because,—
1. He must know that a position outside of it is antagonistic to it. By claiming to be a Christian and yet refusing to unite with the visible church, he is exerting a silent but persistent influence against the very existence of the church. He is impugning the wisdom of God in instituting the church. If it is not necessary for him, it is not necessary for anybody. If he can live a consistent and acceptable Christian life without it, then everybody else can, and the church ought to be disbanded. It is absurd to say that others need the church when he does not, or that others ought to sustain the church, so that he can stand in its shadow and enjoy its advantages without sharing its responsibilities. Christ said, “He that is not with me is against me.” Those who are with him he gathers into his fold. Those who refuse to be gathered in cannot be considered neutral. The world counts them as with it in opposition to the organized and visible church of Christ. And just so far as they are good people, amiable and benevolent, they encourage others to believe that a profession of religion is unnecessary,—that it is just as well to be out of the church as to be in it.
2. He who claims to be an outside Christian must confess Christ in some way; for this is the condition of Christ’s confession of him before his Father and the angels. But how shall he do it? It must be a public profession—“before men.” Christ has provided a convenient and appropriate way, by uniting with his church and commemorating in it his dying love. But this our outside Christian refuses to do. What then? How will he meet the condition? Will he go and stand on the street corner and proclaim that he is a Christian? Will he put an advertisement of the fact in the daily newspaper? Will he have an inscription placed on his street-door or on his gate-post? Will he wear a badge of discipleship, as the Pharisee wore his phylactery?—No; he will do none of these things. And one of them would be more repugnant to his feelings than a public profession of religion. Every intelligent person who fails to unite with some Christian church knows that he is not confessing Christ before the world, and knows, therefore, that he cannot expect Christ to confess him in the day of Judgment.
3. He who calls himself an outside Christian claims, of course, to love Christ. But Christ says, “If ye love me, keep my commandments.” One of those commandments is, “This do in remembrance of me,”—commemorate my death for you in the memorial supper which I have instituted. Does the outside Christian do this? Does he take the elements into his chamber, and there celebrate the supper? We never heard of one who did this.
We do not believe that any one who refuses to join the church does it. Hence they do not keep the commandments; and hence they do not love him; and hence they cannot be his. No man who studies the New Testament, and is familiar with the teachings of Christ, can fail to see that to be a consistent and acceptable Christian he must unite with some branch of that visible church which Christ instituted, and through which he has carried on his work in the world.
Finally, the outside Christian, if sensible, cannot be sincere; for he knows that his Saviour is the leader of a sacramental host; that he has organized his forces, and is drilling them for the conquest of the world. All who love him must be interested in this contest, and must be willing to enlist under his banner. In a time of war a true patriot does not shoulder his rifle and go alone, but he enlists. He becomes a member of a company that belongs to a regiment. There can be no success in any great conflict without organization, and there can be no organization unless those interested in the cause unite and band themselves together. The man who stands aloof is justly suspected of a want of patriotism. And so the man who refuses to become a soldier of the cross, to put on the uniform of the army of the Lord, to march under the blood-stained banner, may call himself a Christian, but he knows in his heart of hearts that he is a worldling or a coward. He loves the world too well to give it up for Christ. He does not love Christ well enough to deny himself and take up his cross and follow him. We don’t believe in outside Christians. They don’t believe in themselves. They know, or might know if they would, that their position is utterly inconsistent and unreasonable, and that they ought to come manfully into the church, or else admit that they have no real interest in it, or in its Lord.—Obadiah Oldschool, in Interior.