ANSWERS BY G. W. MORSE.
371.—POWER OF THE CHURCH TO REMIT SINS.
How can John 20: 23, Matt. 16: 19, and 2 Cor. 2: 10 be explained so as not to admit the Catholic view of the forgiveness of sin?
J. M. H.
In many cases Bible language can better be understood if all the circumstances under which it was uttered are taken into consideration. The texts referred to in John and Matthew contain the Saviour’s instructions relative to the privileges and powers that the Christian church should be entitled to from that time forward. For thousands of years previous to the time that Christ spoke the words of the texts, the people of God had been accustomed to the ceremonial or typical system of sacrifices and offerings for sin. They had been accustomed to confess their sins at the place where the priest ministered. The priest received them, made the necessary offering in the first apartment of the sanctuary, or in the court adjacent (according to the nature of the sin), and on the yearly day of atonement he performed the prescribed work in the second apartment, whereby the sins that had been lodged in the first apartment during the year were placed upon the head of the scapegoat and effectually disposed of, so far as the individuals who had committed them were concerned. Thus the method of confessing sins and obtaining pardon for them had been one that could be easily comprehended. While it was true that genuine heart work was necessary on the part of the transgressors, yet there was much in the system of outward, tangible, visible ceremony. Christ was preparing the way for the entire abolition of that ceremonial system, and that the change from the old to the new might not be too sudden or too great, he prepared the minds of his disciples somewhat by the teaching under consideration. By those statements with regard to the power of his true church on earth, to “bind” and “loose,” “remit” and “retain,” he suggested that in some particulars and to a certain extent, the work of the priests would be superseded by the organized church, acting, of course, in perfect harmony with the Holy Spirit. It is not to be supposed for a moment, that any action of the church would be sanctioned in heaven that is otherwise than right, and dictated by the Holy Spirit. The important truth designed to be taught by Christ as he spoke those words, was that the actions, proceedings, and work of his true church on earth would be recognized in heaven.
It is nowhere intimated that under the old dispensation the power or right to forgive sins was vested in any other being than God, and there is no probability that any of the people looked elsewhere for forgiveness. See Ex. 32: 32; 34: 6, 7; Num. 14: 17, 19, 20; Ps. 32: 1, 2, 5, and many other scriptures of similar import. There is no intimation that previous to the time that Christ spoke the words under consideration, the people of God had supposed that they were to confess their sins to the priests as priests. One item in the work of a priest on the day of atonement was to make an atonement for himself. Lev. 16: 11. The liability of the priest to sin was also provided for in other ways. See Lev. 4: 3. The people were taught that the priests were the chosen servants of the Lord, to act important parts connected with the worship of God, and in ministering to the spiritual welfare of the people. If the priests were importuned by the people, it was not with the idea that they had power to forgive sin, but that they would perform such service in behalf of the suppliant as was within their province as priests.
The conclusion seems reasonable that as the ceremonial system of worship was about to be done away with, and a different system introduced, Christ should thus prepare the way for it by laying down general principles as he did at this time, with regard to the privileges and prerogatives of the organized church under the new dispensation. In view of what has already been said relative to the work of the priests under the old dispensation, there was no liability that those who heard Christ’s words would thereby conclude that he designed to delegate to the church any authority to grant final and effectual pardon for sin. As the priests were God’s highest authority on earth, under the old dispensation, so Christ taught that the organized church would be his highest authority on earth under the new dispensation. As the priests were liable to err, so is the church, and nothing resembling infallibility is suggested.
In 2 Cor. 2: 10 Paul evidently has reference to the case of such a person described in verse 5—one who had “caused grief.” By the words, “To whom ye forgive anything, I forgive also,” he evidently means to say that he was willing to concur in any forgiveness that they might grant to any who had thus caused trial. No reference is had to the ultimate and final forgiveness of sin, such as God alone has the prerogative to grant.