AdventAI

It is the misfortune of the Antinomian, that the very texts to which he is obliged to appeal to sustain his theory, are the very ones which condemn it. The reason is obvious. If a man sets out to prove the abolition of the law, he must refer to texts which speak of the law; for no others are relevant to the question. But on the subject of the law, the testimony of the Scriptures is not yea and nay, but yea and amen; and all their testimony relative to that law which the Antinomian wishes to show is done away, proves that it is immutable and perpetual.

No passage is oftener appealed to, perhaps, to prove that the ten commandments have been abolished, than the one referred to at the head of this article; but there is scarcely one which is easier of explanation, or which shows more positively that that law has not been abolished, but that a person is just as amenable to it after conversion as before. The passage reads as follows:—

“Know ye not, brethren (for I speak to them that know the law), how that the law hath dominion over a man as long as he liveth? For the woman which hath a husband is bound by the law to her husband so long as he liveth; but if the husband be dead, she is loosed from the law of her husband. So then if, while her husband liveth, she be married to another man, she shall be called an adulteress: but if her husband be dead, she is free from that law; so that she is no adulteress, though she be married to another man. Wherefore, my brethren, ye also are become dead to the law by the body of Christ; that ye should be married to another, even to him who is raised from the dead, that we should bring forth fruit unto God. For when we were in the flesh, the motions of sins which were by the law, did work in our members to bring forth fruit unto death. But now we are delivered from the law, that being dead [or, as the margin reads, which is the literal Greek, ‘we being dead to that’] wherein we were held; that we should serve in newness of spirit, and not in the oldness of the letter.”

The question to be decided on this scripture is, Does it, or does it not, teach the abolition of the ten commandments? Some say that it does; we say that it does not; and we cheerfully undertake to answer the query of a correspondent upon the point.

Let it ever be borne in mind that if the ten commandments have been abolished at all, they were abolished at the cross—abolished when there was a change of dispensation from the Mosaic to the Christian, and abolished because of this change. Therefore those who claim that this scripture was written to show the abolition of the moral law, must apply it to the time when the dispensations changed, and must find in the reasons given why we are released from the law, a correspondence to the circumstances of the case. Let any man try to do this, and see what a senseless hodge-podge it will produce.

Verse 1 (Rom. 7) would be, “The law hath dominion over a man as long as the dispensation lasts.” Paul says, “as long as he liveth.” Then the dispensation must last as long as the man lives; for the law does not lose its dominion over him till then.

Verse 2. The life of the husband measures the length of time the woman is bound to him. But, according to this view, she is bound as long as the dispensation lasts; for not till then does the law release her; so the first husband dies when the dispensation dies. What, then, was the first husband?

Verse 3 would show, on this ground, that if any one attempted to become a Christian before the old dispensation ended, it would be adultery. Wonderful instruction that would be for Paul to give, away down in A. D. 60, would it not? But it is unnecessary to point out the nonsense of such a view further.

The least care in reading the passage will show to any one that Paul is speaking simply of two conditions occupied at different times respectively by the same individual; and these conditions are (1) a state of sin, and (2) a state of righteousness: the first when the person is “in the flesh” (verse 5), and the second when he is married to Christ. Verse 4.

In chapter 6 Paul speaks of the converted man, and contrasts his state with what it was before he was converted. Then in the first six verses of chapter 7, he illustrates the subject by the figure under consideration. He takes for his illustration a woman who has a husband, and shows how she may lawfully change her relation and become the wife of another man. There are four parties concerned in the transaction: 1. The woman; 2. The first husband; 3. The law; and, 4. The second husband. Now what parties undergo a change, and what is the change they undergo, before the woman can be released legally from the first husband and united with the second? For this is the end to be reached; and the whole transaction illustrates the conversion of the sinner.

The only party that changes is the husband to whom the woman is first married. He dies; and then the marriage law which held her to that man as her husband while he lived, no longer holds her as the wife of that man; for a dead man cannot be the husband of a living woman. Now the woman is free to change her relation. She unites with a second husband; and now the law steps right in again to regulate this second relation and govern her conduct therein, just as it regulated her first relation, and governed her in that. It will be seen that there are three parties on the stage of action, but only three, at any one time. First, it is (1) the woman, (2) the law, and (3) the first husband; and while this relation exists, she has nothing to do with the second husband; he does not come into the account at all. Secondly, the first husband dies, and the woman unites with another man; then it is (1) the woman, (2) the law, and (3) the second husband; and she has nothing to do with the first.

We have said that this figure illustrates the conversion of the sinner. We shall see how it does this by considering what is represented by each of the parties introduced in the illustration. We know that this is the subject to which Paul’s figures apply; for as the result of the transaction the person becomes united to Christ; and that is conversion. In conversion we have four parties: 1st. The individual, represented by the woman; 2d. Something to which the individual is united before conversion, represented by the first husband; 3d. The law of God which determines the individual’s character, represented by the law of marriage; 4th. Something to which the individual is united in conversion, represented by the second husband.

But we are plainly told who the second husband is: “That ye should be married to another, even to him who is raised from the dead;” that is, Christ. This furnishes a key to the solution of the main question in the exposition of this scripture, that question being, What constitutes the first husband? for there must be some correspondence between the two. We could not properly say that one thing constituted one husband, and another thing, intrinsically and constitutionally different, constituted the other husband; as, for instance, to say that Christ is the second husband, and a “dispensation” or a “law” was the first husband; for this would be confounding things different, and mixing metaphors in a most appalling manner.

What change, then, is wrought in the sinner when he puts on Christ? What does he have that he did not have, or different from what he had, before? Answer: He has the spiritual mind (Rom. 8: 6, 7); Christ within, the hope of glory (Col. 1: 27); a “new man” of righteousness and holiness (Eph. 4: 24; Col. 3: 10); and a portion of the divine nature. 2 Pet. 1: 4. This, then, is the new husband to which he becomes united by conversion. And what did he have corresponding to this before conversion? He had the carnal mind, to which he was subject (Rom. 8: 5-7); the “old man” with its deceitful lusts (Eph. 4: 22); he was partaker of the nature of the prince of this world (John 8: 44); and was a child of disobedience. Col. 3: 6. Here, then, is the first husband—the old man of sin, the carnal mind, the unregenerate nature. This must die, be put off, be crucified, and then the sinner can be united to Christ, or put on the new man. See texts already quoted.

With this view, how consistent and forcible is the illustration which the apostle uses! But if we try to make the first husband the law, in what inconsistency and confusion does the whole subject at once become involved! But if the first husband is not the law,p. 441 then this scripture does not teach the abolition of the law, for it is the first husband only that dies and disappears from the scene.

In the illustration from beginning to end, it is nowhere intimated that the law ceases to exist or that any change takes place therein. How absurd to say that when the man dies the law of marriage is annulled; or that when a sinner is converted the law of God is abolished!

It remains to examine two expressions in which some difficulty is supposed to lie. These are verse 4: “Wherefore my brethren, ye also are become dead to the law;” and verse 6: “But now we are delivered from the law, that being dead wherein we were held.” Taking the last expression first, it has already been shown that “we” are the ones who die, the Greek word being the nominative plural masculine participle, apothanontes, and the literal rendering of the whole passage being “we having died [to that] in which we were held.” But how does this death deliver us from the law? and in what sense are we delivered from it? To which the apostle’s illustration itself replies: It is in the same sense that the woman is released from the “law of her husband,” after that husband is dead. Verse 3. She is released simply from the relation she had formerly sustained to that man, not from obligation to obey the law in any and all particulars in which it might apply to her circumstances. It no longer holds her as a married woman; for her husband being dead, she is not such. But the moment she marries again, the law is there to hold her to the new relation and regulate her conduct therein.

We ask the reader to discriminate carefully between being absolutely and only relatively “dead to the law.” In the illustration the man dies and is absolutely dead to the law. The woman is also in a certain sense dead to the law, but it is only relatively; she is dead to that relation, and to the law in so far as it regulated it. But when she revives the relation by being married again, then she is just as much alive to the law as she was before her first husband died.

So with the penitent believer: The old man of sin actually dies. This brings the person into a condition of death to the law relatively. He is dead to the relation he formerly sustained to the man of sin, as that is now dead; and he is dead to the law only in so far as the law pointed out that relation and held him in a state of guilt and condemnation. He is free from that condemnation as the carnal mind has been taken away, and he is released from the guilt of sin. He now unites with Christ; he enters into a new relation as a follower of truth and righteousness; but the law is right there to regulate this new relation, by detecting any deviation from the profession of righteousness which he has taken upon himself and the vows of obedience which he has made.

In the illustration the woman, after the first husband dies, may remain an indefinite length of time before taking another husband, or may take none at all. But not so with the sinner in his moral relationships. In his case one change is contiguous to the other; the putting off of the old man is the putting on of the new; the death of the first husband is the acceptance of the second; the release from “the law of sin and death” (Rom. 8: 2) is the beginning of the operation of “the law of the spirit of life in Christ Jesus.” There is not a moment, therefore, in which a person is dead to the law except in this relative sense; for the moment he dies to it in one relation, he becomes alive to it in another. The moment it ceases to condemn him as a sinner, it approves him as a righteous man.

There could be no marriage without a law to regulate marriage. So there could be on the part of the sinner no unholy union with sin, nor a turning away from that to be united with Christ and maintain a holy relation with him, unless there was some law to regulate these relations. As “by the law is the knowledge of sin” (Rom. 3: 20), so by the law is the revelation of righteousness. How utterly, therefore, do they fail to comprehend the apostle’s reasoning, who try to use certain relations he mentions, as proof of the abolition of that law upon which those relations themselves depend!

—He that blows the coals in quarrels he has nothing to do with, has no right to complain if the sparks fly in his face.—Franklin.