BY W. A. BLAKELY.
Under the above heading a writer at Antioch, California, recently contributed some astonishing arguments (?) to the Bible Banner on the Sabbath question. It is strange that there are so many who darken “counsel by words without knowledge.” Yet we find many of these persons “desiring to be teachers of the law, understanding neither what they say nor whereof they affirm.” The following extract from the article to which reference is made is an illustration:—
The trouble with those friends who make the observance of Saturday as the Sabbath a part of the gospel of Jesus Christ, is a failure to recognize the grand distinction between an institution and a law. The Sabbath as an institution existed from creation, and still exists; but the Sabbath as a law, to be enforced by penalty, was confined to the nation of Israel and the period covered by their national existence.
“The Sabbath as a law”! The expression itself is a solecism. Webster, in defining the term “law” as regards morality, says that it is “the rule of action as obligatory on the conscience or moral nature.” How can the Sabbath be the rule itself? It can easily be seen how the Sabbath institution could be sanctified (Gen. 2: 3), i. e., “set apart to a holy or religious use” by a command of God; but to consider the Sabbath as a law is impossible. But he probably means enforced by a law; but that this was the case from the beginning, we show further on.
“The Sabbath as an institution existed from creation, and still exists.” Very true; and an institution cannot be sanctified by the Creator for man unless man is commanded to observe it. All this is embraced in the word “sanctify.” Herein is the law. But how about the penalty when this sacred institution was desecrated? Simply this: When the Israelites left Egypt and were to form a nation by themselves, they must have their laws to govern them as a nation; with these laws there were also penalties for breaking them. The nation being a theocracy, these laws were, of course, given by God, and, besides the other commandments, they embraced the greater portion of the moral law. But all of this moral law was not enforced in the penal code of the Jewish nation—the tenth commandment, for instance. So the penalties of the civil law which was given to Moses subsequently to the law of God, were confined to the Jewish government, and, of course, became obsolete as soon as the Jewish government was overthrown.
But the Sabbath was not a Jewish institution, it having existed from creation, as the article admits, and hence was sanctified over two thousand years before there was a Jew on earth. But the penalty, as we have seen, was given to the Jews as a nation, and to them only; hence, it can properly be called Jewish, and “was confined to the nation of Israel and the period covered by their national existence.”
To illustrate: Suppose that the government of Turkey, as a Mohammedan nation, should be given a system of civil laws embracing most of the ten commandments, the Sabbath among them, the laws being enforced under strict penalties, would that make either the law or the Sabbath Mohammedan?—Certainly not. The ten commandments would still be as binding on the world at large as though such an event had never occurred. If the Turkish government were to be overthrown, would that affect the moral law or the Sabbath of the fourth commandment?—Not in the least. But their system of laws would be obsolete, and, of course, the penalties would be no longer enforced. So it was with the Jewish system of civil laws.
Again: Suppose that the Turkish government should have the ten commandments alone given to them as the rule of morals in their nation, to be enforced by penalties. Then the officers of the government would enforce them as far as it was in their power; but they would be enforcing them as civil law. God is the only one who can punish justly for the transgression of his sacred law. Yet, if this law is given to a nation, and it is then transgressed, the individual transgressing the law is a criminal in the sight of the government, and a sinner in the sight of God. The government then punishes him as a criminal, and God will, when the appointed time comes, punish him for that sin.
It was similar to this in the Jewish nation, the Sabbath being in the moral law, and also being enforced by a penalty in the civil code. Then, when an individual broke the Sabbath, as in Num. 15: 32–36, he committed a sin, or crime, against the government (it being a theocracy, God was at the head), and he was punished by God’s executors in that government; he also committed a sin against the moral law of God, and hence will be punished in the “second death.”
He says further on:—
Had the Sabbath been a moral law from the beginning, it would have been enforced by rigid penalty; for a law cannot exist without a penalty.
Quite true; and so it was. But not one single sin ever meets its penalty in this life; nor did a single transgression of the moral law, during the existence of the Jewish nation, receive its penalty. It is true that persons were punished for a violation of some of the ten commandments; but that was only as they transgressed against the national government. So to-day persons are punished likewise for murder, etc., but that is not the penalty of the moral law; it is the penalty of the civil law. For, in case of a murder, if a person were to repent after the deed was done, he might be hung, but still he would never have to suffer the penalty of the law of God. Christ bore our sins on the cross. Did it never occur to the mind of the writer of that article that “the wages of sin is death,” eternal death, and that “sin is the transgression of the law”? God has appointed a time in which to punish transgressors of his law; and then he will give to every sinner his wages. Governments here cannot mete out justice to individuals, for their motives cannot be seen. But when God judges the world, every sinner will have his due. The facts of the case are that men do not understand the exceeding sinfulness of sin, and in their present condition are incapable of pronouncing judgment according to the law of God. It is evident, then, that governments can only punish for the transgression of civil law, although in reality that law may be the moral law. Hence the penalty for Sabbath-breaking, enforced during the existence of Israel as a nation, was only to be enforced upon those in the nation, and not upon the whole world. But “now we know that what things soever the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law: that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God.” So these individuals will have to pay the penalty by suffering the “second death,” which is the penalty.
Again he says:—
Of course it is wrong for one who is enlightened, to waste his powers by failing to take his nightly rest; it is wrong to do anything whereby our bodies or minds are impaired and rendered less fit for God’s service; and therefore it is wrong to fail to observe the seventh-day rest unless duty to God requires us to sacrifice ourselves for the good of others. In such case as that, the high and glorious “law of Christ” supersedes the Sabbath institution.
In striking contrast with this reason of his, the Bible says, “For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore [for this reason] the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.” Ex. 20: 11. The physical rest that is required by the body is only a subordinate consideration. The Sabbath is to remember the Lord as Creator. But it is a mistake to speak of the “law of Christ” superseding the Sabbath institution or any other part of the moral law. This is contrary to the teachings of the Saviour himself, who said: “It is lawful [i. e., “agreeable” or “conformable” to the law now binding upon you] to do well on the Sabbath days.” Matt. 12: 12. It was in the Saviour’s time, and it always has been since creation; for it is according to the law. Just hear this:—
And now then, does it make any difference whether we go to bed at nine o’clock, and get up at five o’clock, or go to bed at ten and get up at six? When any one can bring sufficient proof that the former course is more acceptable to God than the latter, or that it is enforced by a rigid law upon all mankind, then at the same time he will be able to prove that one definite period of twenty-four hours is more acceptable to God than another, as the period in which man should take his weekly rest; or that he has placed mankind under law and penalty for the observance of this particular day.
Such language proves nothing, and is simply ridiculous. God never gave a command to “go to bed at nine o’clock and get up at five o’clock,” but he did speak in a voice from Sinai that shook the earth, and said: “But the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” And those words have never been abrogated. How can words express a particular day any clearer? He says:—
The Sabbath was made for man, and no one can adduce the shadow of a proof that to rest on Saturday would be more beneficial for man than any other day.
Nor is it needed. Of course, any one can derive just as much physical rest on any other day; but does that make it right?—By no means, God’s word is to be obeyed. It is certain that God sanctified one seventh part of time, and it is just as certain that the other six sevenths are not sanctified; if this were not the case, there would be no Sabbath. But in addition to the fact that we have the institution, we have it stated positively when we are to observe that institution; namely, on the seventh day of the week. Again:—
There is one very weighty reason against keeping Saturday; which is, that men have made this the badge, the sign, of servitude to an imperfect law which God himself declares was a temporary arrangement, designed for a certain purpose until the time should come for the perfect law of liberty and love to be revealed.
But it is with good authority “that men have made this the badge, the sign, of servitude” to the law of God; for we read in Ex. 31: 13, “Verily my Sabbaths ye shall keep: for it is a sign between me and you throughout your generations. . . . It is a sign between me and the children of Israel forever.” But there is another class who do not wish to show their servitude to that law. Their minds seem to be directly contrary to it. Of them we read in Rom. 8: 7: “Because the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be.” Of course, then, it would be but natural to call it “imperfect” when they will not be subject to it.
But this language simply shows the feelings of the writer; for the Bible says positively, in Ps. 19: 7, “The law of the Lord is perfect,” and in Rom. 7: 12, “Wherefore the law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good.” The other expression also, that the law was “a temporary arrangement,” the word of God proves positively to the contrary. “The works of his hands are verity and judgment; all his commandments are sure. They stand fast forever and ever, and are done in truth and uprightness.” Ps. 111: 7, 8. “Concerning thy testimonies, I have known of old that thou hast founded them forever.” “Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth forever.” Ps. 119: 152, 160. Rather strong language to express “a temporary arrangement”!
But in closing we will give one more statement made by the champion for the “wild solar holiday of all pagan times,” and that is in regard to the authority of Sunday observance. He says that “custom, and that alone, has selected Sunday, and there is no good reason for changing it.” This expression would indicate that its writer is a better historian on the origin of Sunday observance than he is a theologian. For it seems that Isaiah (58: 13, 14) gives a very good reason for a change, in these words: “If thou turn away thy foot from the Sabbath, from doing thy pleasure on my holy day; and call the Sabbath a delight, the holy of the Lord, honorable; and shalt honor him, not doing thine own ways, nor finding thine own pleasure, nor speaking thine own words: then shalt thou delight thyself in the Lord; and I will cause thee to ride upon the high places of the earth, and feed thee with the heritage of Jacob thy father: for the mouth of the Lord hath spoken it.”
Oakland, Cal.