THE FOUNDATION OF GOD STANDETH SURE,

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 6, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 36.

Read the full edition

“THE FOUNDATION OF GOD STANDETH SURE,”

These words of the apostle Paul occur in an interesting statement to Timothy concerning the errors of prominent persons in the early church who made shipwreck of their own faith and led others astray also. Hymenæus and Philetus “concerning the truth . . . erred,” “and overthrew the faith of some.” “Nevertheless the foundation of God standeth sure, having this seal, The Lord knoweth them that are his.” God’s foundation of everlasting truth will never be moved. This foundation, laid by “prophets and apostles,” the precious truths of the Old and New Testament Scriptures, will stand as firm as the throne of the Eternal.
And another glorious fact connected with it in this world of mutation, is that the “Lord knoweth them that are his.” Those are “his” who from their hearts repent of their sins and believe and obey his truth. Many profess to do this, run well for a season, make many professions of honesty, and seem to human eyes to be very good; but, alas! there is weakness or wickedness or both in their hearts, hidden from human view. Selfishness or unbelief is covered up in their hearts. When time and God’s providence test every man’s work, these plague spots appear, and, like Hymenæus and Philetus of old, they withdraw from the work of God. Men open their eyes with astonishment, but God knew it all beforehand.
This result is seen in connection with the cause of religion in all ages. But it is more especially visible in connection with special movements containing a present truth for that age of the world, in which there is a cross. The warning of Noah to the Antediluvians, the exode, the return from Babylon and the rebuilding of Jerusalem, the establishment of the gospel of Christ and the apostles, and our own work, all give us examples of this kind. These all were, or are now, important movements for the benefit of mankind, in which God’s plans were or must be carried out. Most of these were foretold by prophecy; and to preserve God’s predicted word from being broken, they must be consummated where the inspired word located them.
In the very nature of things these great movements take time. Large numbers must know of them, and many participate in them, and, as we shall see, many apostatize from them, who could not or would not endure the cross connected with them. From the best data we possess (Gen. 6: 3), we draw the conclusion that Noah was 120 years warning the people of the flood. From the time the announcement of the coming deluge was made to him, God’s Spirit was to “strive” with men that length of time. The great capacious ark was to be made, capable of holding and provisioning for about a year representatives of all the leading species of animals, birds, and reptiles on the earth, besides Noah’s family. The immense labor of building and furnishing such a ship could never have been performed by that one family having only four men. To suppose that Noah never interested or convicted a single soul but his own family during all that time, would be highly absurd as well as contrary to all other experience in the effects of God’s special messages and work. We are confident large numbers at first were interested, and assisted him in his work. But like many since, their faith failed during the long-continued trial, and through unbelief and other causes they apostatized and were lost.
In the great movement of the exodus—the transplanting of a nation from Egypt to the land of promise—as a marvel of God’s power for all succeeding generations, we have in some respects a similar experience. It must have been nearly fifty years from the sending of Moses to lead out the Israelites—to say nothing of the work of preparing him and them for this experience—till the tribes were established in their inheritance. None can deny that this was a movement foretold by prophecy (Gen. 15: 13–16), and one especially ordered of Heaven. Yet rebellion, unbelief, murmuring, and apostasy marked it all the way through. Only two persons out of some millions who entered upon it ever reached the Promised Land. Two hundred and fifty princes, leaders in the nation, “famous in the congregation, men of renown,” gathered against Moses. Num. 16. And the Lord had to make an example of them all, by utterly destroying them. Nearly the whole nation were, for a time, in sympathy with the wrong. We need not rehearse their many painful experiences. Even Moses and Aaron displeased God and fell in the wilderness. But the movement itself never failed. It triumphed gloriously. But what a long time it must have seemed to wander in that terrible desert, to those who started nearly half a century before!
The restoration of Jerusalem after its destruction by the king of Babylon, was also a matter of prophecy, a movement which must be consummated, and one in which the honor of God was concerned, inasmuch as his word was pledged that it should be done. The name of King Cyrus was mentioned long before his birth as the one who should order it (Isa. 44: 28; 45: 1), and God gave the period of seventy years as the extent of its desolation. 2 Chron. 36: 21, 22. It might have been naturally supposed that the work of restoration would require but a brief period. Yet from the time Zerubbabel led the captives back till Nehemiah had enclosed the city in a substantial wall and fully restored the civil polity, it was about eighty years, according to the chronology. And what trying experiences God’s true servants had to meet in this work! Ezra and Nehemiah found the people all mixed up with the heathen around them, marrying their daughters and giving their own to them. The holy seed were contaminated with the ungodly, and quarters even in the temple building were devoted to strangers in alliance with the priest; and some persons of high position among the Jews, rather than give up these heathen alliances, took up their abode in Samaria, and became leaders in that mongrel system of worship which continued till Christ’s time among that people. Apostacies were common. Let any one read the books of Ezra and Nehemiah, and he will see this clearly.
The same general experience characterized the establishment of the blessed gospel by Christ and the apostles. We all know that this was foretold in almost every prophetic book of the Old Testament. It was the great event of the plan of salvation. Yet it took time. Vast sacrifices, immense labor, terrible disappointments, and constant apostacies marked its development.
From the birth of Christ to the general diffusion of the light of the gospel among the nations then living, and the death of the last apostle, must have been about a century. The Jews were tested and their wicked rejection of light endured nearly half a century. And were there apostacies among those who professed to receive the gospel? And did Christ himself and the great apostles have their hearts made sad by the falling away of those dear to them, and their going back from the light? It would seem strange if such master-workers as these should ever lose their converts. Yet such truly was the case. To give a brief summary of our Saviour’s work, we learn that on one occasion “many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him” (John 6: 66), and that he even asked his apostles if they would go also. He was rejected by the nation he came to save. His foremost follower, Peter, denied with an oath that he knew him on his final trial. Another one delivered him to his murderers, and all “forsook him and fled.” We cannot learn that after his earnest labor of three years and a half there were more than 120 pronounced and thorough disciples, though of course there were deep impressions made on a vast number of minds. But the outward manifestations seemed small indeed, compared with what we should naturally expect from the advent of such a personage as the Son of God, and the display of so many wonderful works.
Paul’s experience was similar. He says on one occasion, “All they which are in Asia be turned away from me: of whom are Phygellus and Hermogenes.” 2 Tim. 1: 15. These last were doubtless leading persons in the work. Here was a large province, in which Paul had bestowed much labor; but all these disciples had forsaken him. Demas, also, a prominent minister, honorably mentioned with such laborers as Luke, his constant beloved companion (Col. 4: 14), forsook the great apostle because he “loved this present world.” 2 Tim. 4: 10. Yea, when called before Nero the first time, a great crisis in the apostle’s work, all forsook him as they did his Master. Verse 16. Whole churches, also, as that at Corinth and the Galatians, fell into grievous errors, till Paul could hardly acknowledge them as Christians at all. So we might continue to multiply instances of great trial, sorrow, and apostasy in his experience. Indeed, he prophesies in several places that apostasies would constantly mark the history of the true church. See Acts 20: 29, 30; 2 Tim. 4: 3; 2 Thess. 2: 3, etc. From these examples in different ages, what should we reasonably expect when it comes to the last great movement for warning the world of the close of probation? Should we conclude that all would be pleasant and agreeable, that every one connected with it would be true to God and his work, and that it would take but a brief time, and there would be no crosses, no disappointments, no unbelief, no false professors, no apostasies, no trial of faith? Superficial believers, with little knowledge of God’s ways of working and little experience in spiritual things, might think so, and doubtless will. But the true child of God, instructed in his ways of working, with an experimental knowledge of his blessed Spirit, will not make this mistake.

OUR EXPERIENCE IN THIS MESSAGE.

There has been such a striking similarity in our experience as a people with these past movements of the Lord’s special work, that we should be almost warranted in concluding that this must be God’s work, even if we did not possess the overwhelming evidences found in the Bible in favor of the truth.
It is objected against our work that the time has been so prolonged since its commencement—so many years have passed away since we began to look for the Lord—that it must be a failure, and that soon it will all go to pieces. But it has been only about forty years since this message began to be proclaimed, and about fifty years since Mr. Miller first taught that the Lord’s coming was near. When we compare this with the periods during which other special movements in the past were in progress, such as we have mentioned, or when we consider the immense work of warning the hundreds of millions of earth’s present population, and the many obstacles in the way of such a work, surely we cannot think forty or fifty years a great length of time for it to be in progress. It took longer than this for the gospel to generally impress the people at the first advent, though they were not nearly so numerous as now. People who make such an objection must have very narrow views of what it means to warn the world of Christ’s coming.
And as to apostasies and backslidings among us, we know there have been many, though not as many as we would naturally expect when we compare this movement with some special movements in the past. We are all familiar with the apostasies of Stephenson, Hall, Snook, Brinkerhoff, Shortridge, and Moses Hull; also of Blanchard, Strong, Ball, Carver, Lee, and many others of lesser note. Indeed, some who have given attention to this point claim to find a list of thirty or forty ministers who have given up this doctrine. This may be so; but when we take into consideration another fact, viz., that while those have proved recreant some three or four hundred public laborers have come in to take their places, we need not be overwhelmed. There has never been a year in the history of this work but that there was a growth, even in spite of apostasies, and never was its influence so far-reaching as now.
But it is said by some objectors that the effect of this doctrine on those who have gone out from us has been exceedingly injurious, and therefore we are to judge the doctrine itself as injurious. It is a well-known fact that about all who have thus apostatized have been spiritually bankrupt ever after. Some have gone into atheism, some into Spiritualism, and some into Universalism. Others profess nothing, and live without hope and without God in the world. Most of them are murmurers, sour and hateful when the truth is mentioned, doing what they can against it.
This argument would be amusing, indeed, were not the subject matter so solemn. According to it, the character of a doctrine is to be judged by its effect upon those who apostatize from it, rather than by those faithful to it. It may bless and strengthen and make good Christians of those who keep it. That is nothing. But because some give it up, and go to the Devil in so doing, it must be bad. We suppose, then, the effect upon the two hundred and fifty princes who rebelled against Moses must have been good, according to this reasoning. But, alas! the Lord never discovered it; for he opened the earth and swallowed them up. Judas Iscariot must have been made happy by giving up Christ. But the poor fellow did not realize it, for he went away and hanged himself.
If these objectors were not blind as bats, they would see that this objection is really one of the strongest possible arguments in favor of the doctrine. What, forsooth, should we expect when men give up the special work of God for the last days—what else but that they would go into darkness, blindness, joking, and nonsense, and manifest a sour, hateful, unreasonable spirit whenever God’s special work was mentioned? None can be so bitter as an apostate. As in the case of Benedict Arnold of old, none of the British opposers of the Revolution could compare with him in malignancy and hatred, after he had turned traitor to his country. So we have found in our experience. None can put into their opposition to the truth quite so much virus as those who have formerly professed great love for it, and have given it up.
We have had some recent cases of apostasy who have evidently hoped to avoid the disastrous results we have just noticed. They would show to the world that they could give up this doctrine and still retain their piety and religion. They would be good evangelists in some orthodox church, and labor in the noble work of converting souls as long as they lived. So they parted from us with many professions of good will. They must have a broader platform, where they could do more good. We were too narrow and unsocial. They were cramped among us, and could not labor in the blessed work of their choice—the revival work. They felt kindly, yea, very kindly toward us, and loved us greatly, and were going out from us with a spirit of love, and would not indulge in the fighting spirit which had characterized so many, etc., etc.
This all sounded very fine, yet we dare say few were deceived by it except, perhaps, those who uttered it. So these were taken into an orthodox church, and were intrusted with the work of the ministry, and for some time past have officiated therein. But what has been the result? Have their extra piety and love for souls appeared? Have they escaped the spirit of contention and fighting against the cause they once professed to love? Have their great efforts in revival work appeared?—No, alas! But we find them going from place to place doing their utmost to turn people against us, holding our work and people up to ridicule, writing hosts of letters to undermine the faith of some, writing in various public prints against us, and endeavoring in many ways to make the public believe we are a narrow, bigoted, foolish people, and our work unworthy the respect of people of good judgment. So much for the professions of love and esteem made a few months since by some engaged in this new departure.
The same spirit follows these as all the other apostates from the present truth. We have no more to hope for in the line of consideration and good treatment than we had from those who went into Spiritualism or Universalism; in fact, not so much. The treatment we received from Moses Hull was far more
considerate than that which we are now receiving from some who have lately left us. He went out from us in quiet, and let us alone. What, then, are we to conclude?—That the spirit of apostasy from the truth is substantially the same in all cases. Pleasant memories of old associations go for little. The strongest professions of belief in doctrines and principles are all forgotten after the lapse of a few months. These can be turned into ridicule before promiscuous congregations, flippant jokes be made at the peculiarities of old friends and companions, and even the faults of those in their graves be held up to the public.
We sincerely pity those so unfortunate as to drink in this spirit that goes with those who turn away from the truth. We know too well that it is not the Spirit of our divine Redeemer which is spurring them on to go from place to place to do such work. He never prompts men to boast and tell of what great things they have done. It is a Spirit from another quarter. We have no fears that this cause will fall before such attacks. If there are any among us who can be attracted by such things, the quicker they go out from us the better, unless they can be converted. Our only fear for this work is that we as a people will not be humble and live near to God.
Thank God for the assurance of the text: “The foundation of God standeth sure, having this seal, The Lord knoweth them that are his.” So it has been in all ages, in every true work of God. We need not be deceived. We can readily discern the spirit and animus of any work by watching it closely. We should ask, Does it possess the Spirit of Christ—the “meek and quiet spirit, which is in the sight of God of great price”? Is its wisdom that which comes from above, or that which comes from beneath? The former is “first pure, then peaceable, gentle, and easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without wrangling [margin], and without hypocrisy.” The latter is full of strife, bitterness, ridicule, and joking, and uses all the weapons which men devoid of godliness love. God’s work has ever withstood these successfully, and it ever will. “The Lord knoweth them that are his,” and we may know them also, if we will use the means of instruction he has placed within our reach. Never was there a time when this work was so far-reaching in its influence and effects as now. Never before had we as much reason to hope in God as now. Never could the certainty of its success be more plainly discerned by the eye of faith than now. Dark unbelief is always blind. Living faith believes God’s word and truth, and stands a victor at last. O. I. B.