WITHOUT A MOTIVE

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 7, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 23.

Read the full edition

WITHOUT A MOTIVE.

The two features of that system of belief cherished by Seventh-day Adventists which excite against their work the greatest and most persistent opposition, are, first, the view that the Sabbath of the fourth commandment ought still to be observed; and, secondly, the position that the gift of prophecy (1 Cor. 12:10), one of the gifts of the Spirit (verse 4), is now in the church, as exemplified in the visions of Mrs. E. G. White.
This condition of things is plainly pointed out in the prophecy which foretells the closing experience of the church, where it is said that opposition comes upon the remnant because they keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ. Rev. 12:17. This must refer to those who are keeping the true Sabbath; for though God may recognize others as his children while they are ignorantly breaking the fourth commandment, if they sincerely intend to do his will, and honestly suppose they are doing so, it would be impossible for the Scriptures to set forth any class of people as distinguished by their correct position and practice as commandment-keepers, if they were violating, however honestly, any one of them.
But the same class are equally distinguished by something else, here called “the testimony of Jesus Christ,” which expression is defined in chap. 19:10, to mean “the spirit of prophecy.” Can any one tell what this is? The words “spirit” and “prophecy” would certainly seem to look very strongly toward one of the gifts in the church already referred to. It would be strange, indeed, seeing it is one of the things that calls down upon the remnant strong opposition, if no one could tell what it is. If, however, we have any trouble in deciding for ourselves what it is, we can submit the question to our opponents, and they will soon teach us.
Of these two points of attack, the Sabbath and the visions, we desire to say a few words about the latter. It is usually correct, when we see certain effects produced, to attribute those effects to certain causes, and when we see persons enter upon a course of action, and follow it earnestly and persistently, to suppose that there is some powerful motive in their hearts prompting them to such action. We have reasoned in the same way in regard to the opposition to the visions which seems to have struck certain parties in its most malignant form. In our work, “Objections to the Visions Answered,” published in 1868, we classified the opposers into two divisions and attributed their opposition respectively to the following reasons: First, believers, who felt themselves aggrieved by reproof or admonitions, or sympathized with those who were in this condition, and turned against the visions from personal feelings; secondly, open opponents of the S. D. Adventist cause, who attack the visions with the object of destroying confidence in the movement with which they are connected.
Nineteen years have elapsed since the publication of that book. Believers in the visions now number fivefold what they did then, but the opposition still continues as bitter and persistent as ever, and apparently from the same motives. There is no question, certainly, in regard to the second class mentioned above, but in regard to the first, on the part of whom the opposition is the most active, we are now told that we are mistaken. No, say they, we do not oppose the visions because we hate them, or Mrs. White or her work, or because we have been reproved, or sympathize with any who have been reproved. Then we ask, What is the cause of all this opposition? The most venomous opposer of the visions, the one who even declares that sister White in these exercises is under the direct control of a demon, has publicly admitted that if any one would live up to what is taught in the visions, he was sure of heaven; and so all must admit. Why, then, we ask, in view of the disclaimer now put forth, is there all this opposition against them? We are tempted to illustrate the point by the anecdote of the old Scotch divine who was accustomed to repeat the personal pronoun “he” after every proper name in the third person. So taking for his text 1 Pet. 5:8, “The Devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour,” he said: “I shall divide my subject into three heads, and inquire, first, Who, the Devil, he is; secondly, Why, the Devil, he walketh about as a roaring lion; and thirdly, What, the Devil, he is roaring about.” So we would like to know, what—these men—they are roaring about.
We would not spend another day writing and publishing arguments in behalf of what we hold to be truth, if we did not think that men’s eternal interests were placed in jeopardy by the errors we have to combat, and that their spiritual interests here and their prospects for the world to come would be vastly improved by their following the light that is offered. But if a person by following the instructions of the visions will be saved, as all will admit, then wherein is one endangered by believing them, and in what respect would he be made better if he should be led to believe finally that they were all of the Devil, and discard them as such? Can any one tell?
These questions can be weighed more understandingly now than they could have been some years ago. When organized opposition first began, in 1854, the cry was raised that the visions were the great barrier to the progress of this cause. Take them out of the way, they said, and then the work will go free, souls will embrace the truth by the thousand, and the loud cry of the message will soon be heard. It was to some a new thought; the experiment had not been tried; and many minds were thrown into a quandary whether it might not be so, and if so, whether that might not be the best thing to do. But thirty-three years certainly ought to be a long enough time to test the matter to the complete satisfaction of every one. A few embarked on that enterprise, which in their estimation promised so much. What was the result? Instead of gathering to their standard the thousands anticipated, they had not enough coherence to hang together themselves. Ungoverned and ungovernable, confusion led their councils and anarchy followed in their steps; and their cause has wriggle-waggled on through various phases to the present time, its one key-note from first to last being a long wheezy howl against the visions.
The disinterested observer can now very easily satisfy himself on the following questions: When persons once believing the visions and trying to live according to their counsels are persuaded to join the anti-vision movement, what effect does that move have upon them? Does it make them any better Christians? Does it bring among them more love and union? Does it give them a higher standard of godliness? Do they become more generous with their means and self-sacrificing in the cause of God? Does it lead them to more purity of heart and life? Do they love Christ, the Bible, and the prayer-meeting any better than before? Are they stronger in the truth and more ready to do and dare in behalf of the Saviour?
To those cognizant of the facts, no answer to these questions need be given. To others we are compelled to say that very largely it is just the opposite of this. One thing is sure to follow, and that is, the person will surrender point after point of the faith, till the unity of the message is entirely destroyed, and he gives evidence that he utterly fails to comprehend the purport and spirit of this work.
And while these results follow negatively, what positive effects must on the other hand appear?
1. The person must come to feel that, whereas he supposed the Lord was manifesting himself to his people in one of the precious gifts he had set in the church, the gift turns out to be spurious, either human or devilish, and we have not the blessing we supposed.
2. He must come to feel that we must surrender one of the tests by which it is shown that this movement is a true work of prophecy in fulfillment of the Third Angel’s Message; for the remnant church and the last message are to have in connection with their work the manifestation of the spirit of prophecy; and we challenge any movement which cannot show this test to give any satisfactory proof that it is the work of God for the last days. Then if it is not here, where is the truth and where is the work of the Lord? Thus we are plunged into a sea of doubt and uncertainty, the only certain thing about it being that we have lost the thread of prophecy, the remnant church has not yet begun to appear, and the coming of the Lord, the consummation of the blessed hope, is put far away into the indefinite future.
3. He must come to feel (while he adheres to other points of the faith, which will not be long) that here are special truths for the last days, which the providence of God has brought forth, which the Lord raised up men to advocate, and supplied means that they might be published through the world, but that right in connection with them has been another movement, which, not being the operation of the Spirit of God as it claimed to be, was therefore a fraud and cheat, an element from beneath and not from above, and that God has strangely suffered his truth to be in partnership with, and largely influenced by, this imposture. When a person is brought to feel thus in regard to the visions, it is very easy to see what the effect would naturally be upon other points of the faith.
And yet there are men who profess to be friends of the cause, and have an interest in the truth, and who at present believe that in the main we are right in the positions we hold, who seem to consider it their special calling to write and talk and labor to induce people to discard the visions. Give up the visions! Give up the visions! What do they mean? What are they talking about? They must have lost their mind or lost their conscience.
Concerning the charge that the visions divide churches and alienate brethren, we will speak in our next.