Dialogue on Obedience

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 21, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 25.

Read the full edition

Dialogue on Obedience.

At the Belden school-house, in North Star, a Sabbath-school of new Sabbath-keepers was organized on a recent Sabbath. There had been a good interest for several weeks, and the house was usually crowded with attentive listeners, and nearly all seemed to be convinced of the truth; but yet there seemed to linger in the minds of some a hope that some other kind of a shepherd would visit them, with food of an opposite character. That Sabbath afternoon brought the appointed hour for the commencement of the M. E. quarterly meeting, and with it a minister. In the evening a second minister came, and in the morning a third. As one discourse after another closed, and the last benediction was pronounced, disappointments were whispered, because no light had been given on subjects that were especially troubling their minds.
The Sunday-school followed, and the leading minister conducted the Bible class. The hungry watched for the long-expected crumb. One remark by the minister, namely, “You must keep all the commandments,” brought the golden opportunity, and the following conversation ensued:—
Baptist (Sunday-keeper).—Are we keeping all the ten commandments?
Methodist (minister).—Yes.
B.—Is there not one that we are not keeping?
M.—No. I know what you mean. You mean the fourth commandment; but we have been obeying that ever since Christ arose, by keeping the first day of the week. There is a class of people who talk much about the fourth commandment but ignore the other nine.
The writer sat in the class, a silent listener to this remarkable instruction; but as soon as the school was dismissed, I thought it not out of place to ask the minister a question; and though it was far past the hour for dinner, many remained to listen substantially to the following dialogue:—
Adventist.—What class of people is it that you say ignore nine of the commandments?
Methodist.—The Seventh-day Adventists.
A.—I did not know that before.
M.—Well, those that I have been acquainted with do.
A.—I have never been acquainted with any who did so.
M.—Are you an Advent?
A.—No, sir. I am not an Advent. “Advent” means coming. I am not coming; I am right here now. I am a Seventh-day Adventist, and wish to know the authority for the statement you have made.
M.—I have read their tracts, and some one takes the pains to send me the Sickle, and almost every article it contains is about the Sabbath.
A.—Have you ever seen an article in any of their publications, ignoring nine of the commandments?
M.—(Silence.)
A.—Have you ever known any of their ministers to ignore nine of the commandments?
M.—(Silence.)
A.—Have you ever known any of their members to do so?
M.—Well, you talk more about that commandment than you do about the other nine.
A.—Suppose you were preaching to a people who had been educated to obey all the commandments except the one that says, “Thou shalt not steal,” and they had an established custom of doing what that one forbids; would you not talk to them more about that commandment than about the other nine?
M.—We obey the fourth commandment by keeping the first day of the week.
A.—How is that proved by the Bible?
M.—Christ transferred the obligation of the fourth commandment from the seventh to the first day of the week.
A.—Where does the Bible say so?
M.—We have been obeying the fourth commandment by keeping the first day of the week ever since the resurrection of Christ.
A.—Will you please quote one verse in the Bible in proof of any of your statements?
M.—I have just given you the proof. I told you we had been obeying the fourth commandment by keeping the first day of the week ever since the resurrection of Christ.
A.—Would I commit sin by doing common labor on the first day of the week?
M.—Yes.
A.—What is sin?
M.—Sin is the transgression of the law.
A.—What law would I transgress by working on the first day of the week?
M.—The law of God.
NOTE.—If doing directly contrary to the commandment is obedience, and doing just as the law directs is transgression, then was not this minister, in his statements about Adventists, rendering such obedience to the ninth commandment as his theory teaches? Mal. 2:8, 9, 17. G. K. OWEN.
North Star, Gratiot Co., Mich.