AdventAI

UNCHRISTIANIZED

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 27., July 5, 1887

The Christian Oracle chooses a horn of the trilemma, and impales itself. The reader will perhaps remember a quotation in the REVIEW of May 17, in which the editor of the Oracle declared he would keep the Sabbath if an example could be found where a Christian had ever kept it. We referred him to the holy women who returned from the burial of Christ, and of whom Luke is particular to record that they “rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment,” and at the close of the article, said:—

“Now we call upon the Oracle to stand up squarely to its pledge in the face of this testimony. No cowardice on this issue. Let it (1.) unchristianize those women, or (2.) keep the Sabbath, or (3.) repudiate its own pledge. On which horn of this trilemma will it choose to impale itself? We shall see.”

And now we do see. In its issue of June 16, 1887, it makes a few quotations from our article, and attempts a reply. It takes the first horn of the trilemma, and says, “The Oracle is ready to stand up and say the women referred to were Jews.” It thus unchristianizes those holy women, those intimate followers of Christ, in order to make it appear that their example in keeping the Sabbath has no force for us. Reader, what think you of that? Those holy women not Christians! The mother of Christ not a Christian! Those who had followed him, hung upon his teaching, and believed all he taught, not Christians! Now we had supposed that a follower of Christ was a Christian.

To try to put a bold face on its unpleasant predicament, the Oracle says: “Your trilemma has no horns, and it appears strange that you do not see it.” And we can easily imagine the wry face it was making up all the while inside when saying it. It then betrays its consciousness of having taken an untenable position by hastening to change its base under the plea of restating its position. It says: “Again we repeat our pledge,” and then asks where “an inspired apostle ever commanded a Christian to keep it,” or where the “disciples of Jesus under the guidance of the apostles [!] ever kept it;” which is a very different thing. It thus virtually confesses defeat, and surrenders its first position.

But a few other statements of the Oracle demand a word of notice, they are so utterly reckless and unreasonable Because the resting of these Christian women was before the Pentecost, the Oracle says: “To go back beyond the beginning of the Christian dispensation, to find where Christians kept the Sabbath day, is something we hardly thought possible even for an Adventist.” And we respond by saying, that, to deny that the new dispensation began where the old one ended, is something we hardly thought possible even for a Disciple. To show when they have the new begin, we quote again: “The new institution or covenant began on Pentecost, not before, and there were Jews, but no Christians before that time.”

We can find no language to express our astonishment at such a position. It is certain that the old dispensation ended at the cross. There the middle wall of partition was broken down (Eph. 2: 14); there the wall of the temple was rent in twain; there the enmity was abolished, and the law of commandments contained in ordinances was taken out of the way (Eph. 2: 15); there the handwriting of ordinances was blotted out (Col. 2: 14–16); there the shadow gave place to the substance (verse 17); and there of twain, Jews and Gentiles, was made one new man, so making peace. Eph. 2: 15.

Now who authorized the Oracle to throw in fifty-three days between the ending of the old and the beginning of the new? And what was the nature of that interregnum? The old had ended, the new had not begun. The old law was abolished, the new had not yet been promulgated. The world was then without law. By what will they be judged? or will all sinners during that most favored period, go scot free? The shadow ceased at the cross; but the Oracle jumps fifty-three days before it strikes the substance. Where is its philosophy? Where are its optics? Did it ever see a shadow snap short off and jump a rod or two before it came to the substance which cast it? Will the Oracle please take this proposition in before the philosophy class of its university, and see if such a thing could be.

But the Scriptures are positive on the point as to when the new covenant began; and it was at the cross, and not at Pentecost as the Disciples affirm. Paul says (Heb. 9: 16, 17), “For where a testament is, there must also of necessity be the death of the testator. For a testament is of force after men are dead: otherwise it is of no strength at all while the testator liveth.” Christ said when giving to his disciples a symbol of the blood he was about to shed upon the cross, that it was the blood of the new testament. Matt. 26: 27, 28: “And he took the cup, and gave thanks, and gave it to them, saying, Drink ye all of it; for this is my blood of the new testament, which is shed for many for the remission of sins.” Christ shed his blood upon the cross, and by that means, then and there ratified the new covenant, which was of force from that moment. It is the most transparent contradiction of scripture possible to say that the dispensation did not begin till fifty-three days later at the Pentecost, and we marvel that any one professing to believe the Scriptures should hazard such a statement. Here is a horn to the trilemma, which pierces the position of the Oracle to the very heart; and it must know it; or if not, others do. The new dispensation had come in; and the Christian women kept the Sabbath in this dispensation, according to a commandment which survived the cross and thus belongs to Christians. The man does not live who can successfully contradict this proposition. It is just such disconnected, disjointed, rickety theories as the Oracle sets forth that we object to. Let us have something that is connected and solid. No sensible man can believe that God suffered a great hiatus of fifty-three days in his moral government of the world.

Our astonishment grows as we continue to contemplate the position of the Oracle. There were no Christians, it says, till Pentecost. All were Jews up to that time. Then, presto! in a flash all became Christians. But what happened at Pentecost? Any new organization formed?—No. Any new institution set up?—No. The disciples were simply endowed with power to go forth and accomplish a work to which they had previously been commissioned. Any new truth imparted?—No; the object of the pouring out of the Spirit was to bring to their remembrance things they had already been taught. See John 14: 26: “But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance whatsoever I have said unto you.”p. 425

This promise was fulfilled on the day of Pentecost. Christ had thoroughly taught and instructed his followers, and now by the Holy Spirit his teaching was brought to their remembrance. But the Oracle will have it that all Christ’s teaching, and their acceptance of it, did not make them Christians, but when, the Spirit brought this teaching to their remembrance, that did! Oh! logic! But the Oracle is not satisfied with its own position in reference to Pentecost; for it finally refers to the resurrection of Christ as set forth in Rom. 1:4, as the great event back of which we should not go for examples of Sabbath-keeping.

We wonder what the Oracle thinks Christ was doing through the three years and a half of his ministry; for it says: “Those women who followed Jesus and kept the Sabbath had no conception of the Christian institution.” And again: “Those women kept the commandment because it was one of the Jewish laws, not because they were Christians or disciples of Jesus.” Three years and a half under the teachings of Christ, and yet had not learned a thing! The Oracle may set these women down as such poor dolts, or Christ as such a poor teacher, if it chooses; but we shall do neither the one nor the other.

One more quotation must suffice: “From the beginning on Pentecost the Church of Christ was extended throughout the Roman Empire. The Acts of the Apostles gives its history, the letters of the apostles full instruction for the guidance of the disciples, and not one command or example of Christians keeping the Sabbath.”

We know that many are inclined to give up and throw away the Old Testament; but here goes the record of all the evangelists, the direct record of the life of Christ and all his personal teachings. Dear brethren, we beg of you, do not thus repudiate the Saviour. You profess to be disciples—disciples of whom? Are you disciples of Christ? or only of Paul, or Apollos, or Cephas?

Be it understood, then, that the Disciples begin their Scriptures with the Acts of the Apostles, and look for their whole duty in the epistles, discarding the teachings of Christ as recorded by the evangelists. To such desperate straits are they driven to avoid the Sabbath. But strange to say, they find nothing for Sunday in what they retain, yet cleave to that as the great institution of the Christian Church. Verily, great is the mystery of theology.