AdventAI

RELIGIOUS FANATICISM, ALIAS “CHRISTIAN SCIENCE.”

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 35., August 30, 1887

Under the heading, “A ‘Christian Science’ that is neither Christian nor Scientific,” the Christian at Work makes the following pertinent remarks concerning the lately developed “mind-cure” craze:—

“Fanaticism is proof against common sense, against experience, against education, against the ordinary instincts of humanity. History teems with examples of persons who, though wise and good in other respects, have been, when dominated by some idea of hallucination of the imagination, strangely foolish and unnaturally cruel. Not long since a faith-cure establishment in Colorado was exposed to public condemnation, because its proprietor had been caught burying secretly by night, in his back yard, children that had been allowed to die in their disease and misery without medical aid, and in the vain and fanatical hope that prayer was the only needed and all-sufficient remedy for any and every ill to which flesh is heir. Now, the head of that establishment was not, and is not, a brute devoid by nature of kindness, sympathy, and other charitable feelings belonging to our race. On the contrary, he was tender-hearted, a Christian gentleman, and earnestly desirous to provide a home for orphans, and to relieve their distress and agony in sickness as well as to minister to their bodily wants in the matter of food and clothing. Sane enough on other subjects, he had become an intense and wild fanatic on faith cure, maintaining that physicians were a useless class, that medicine scientifically administered was not only an impertinence, but an injurious and poisonous procedure, and that the prayer of faith was about to come into universal practice, abolishing disease and introducing immortality of human life on earth. It is simply a waste of time to attempt to reason with such a deluded person. Everything you say only fires and enlarges his fanaticism. Deeply sincere and terribly zealous, he denounces you as the fool, pities your impiety, and hugs his darling theory with a more delighted and martyr-like hallucination in proportion to the opposition he meets and the mischief he works.

“Here plainly is a case where what is needed is not argument and reasonable expostulation, but law. Arrest and punishment, or at least some method to prevent these fanatics from playing havoc with human life, should be adopted.

“The latest form of fanatical monstrosity consists in attempting to cure invalids by working up their imagination to a high degree of excitement, ending in the conviction that nothing at all ails them. No matter what dreadful form of sickness and disease may afflict them, nor what darting agonies, or continuous pains, sleeplessness, weary gnawings, or burning fever, or slow wasting of cancer may torture and assail the seat of vitality, they are told to think these things down and out, to fancy that they are getting well, and health will return.”

After proceeding to cite a case in which a victim of this “science,” an aged woman, died after enduring untold suffering which might have been greatly mitigated by the use of proper treatment, the Christian at Work remarks: “It sounds like an instance of the dumb and savage ignorance of the Indian medicine man swinging his wampum, and grunting sighs before the hapless sufferer, whose soul in the meantime is traveling fast toward the spirit land; or, again, it seems to be a trick of the African fetich worshiper imported from the lowest and most brutal, as well as most superstitious, race on this earth. Really the wise but firm hand of law ought to supplement the lack of Christian sense and decency which such a case betrays, and rescue some persons from themselves.”

Would that modern religious fanaticism were confined to the limits of the “mind cure”! It would then be comparatively harmless. But it is not, and the worst of it is that very few people in this age of the world appear to know this article when they see it. The idea seems to prevail that the world has outlived the age of such fanaticism, and has now entered upon an era of such dazzling religious light and knowledge that any extensive imitation of the fanatical doings of mediæval times is an impossibility. It is the same mistake which every other age has made, more or less. The superstitions of one age, a little transformed, re-appear in another, are given an attractive name, and people think they have discovered something new and of superior virtue. Especially does this seem to be true of the present age,—a fact which is due, doubtless, to the greater contrast which it forms with those which have preceded it. The light of its brilliant achievements clothes many things with a luster which they do not intrinsically possess, and but for which they would have only the somber appearance which they present when viewed through the smoked glass, so to speak, of the Dark Ages, or of still more ancient times. So we have such phenomena as the “mind-cure,” “holiness” movements, and Spiritualism, all palmed off upon the world as new discoveries,—advance steps in the field of religious truth,—when in fact they are neither new nor true. And besides these, we have a party who are about to repeat the mediæval experiment of making laws to enforce religion, as if this also were a discovery of the nineteenth century. Verily we have not outgrown the age of religious fanaticism, and the “mind-cure” superstition is but a small part of that which, under some sounding title, flourishes in the midst of our enlightened land.