J. W. MORTON AND THE SANCTUARY QUESTION.
In the Sabbath Recorder of July 21, 1887, appears a very singular article from the pen of him whose name stands at the head of these lines. As it is designed to controvert publicly the position of S. D. Adventists, it challenges some notice at our hands. Had he confined himself simply to the theology of the question, we might have let it pass unnoticed; for when a person still clings to the fog and mysticism of medieval theology, instead of exchanging that musty pabulum for the clearer light and more satisfactory conclusion of modern investigation, in this age of advanced Biblical knowledge, he could hardly be expected to present anything worthy of serious refutation. But when he seeks to hold up the denomination to the concentrated gaze of all whose attention he can secure, and then descends to the work of perverting their views and grossly misrepresenting their position, it becomes a very different matter, and some one is called upon to remind him that he is doing a work very unworthy of his profession, to say nothing of his years. Respecting his theory on the Sanctuary question, it is unnecessary for us to say anything to those who have investigated our views upon that subject, and understand the reasons upon which they rest. But we can hardly refrain from noticing a point or two, that the reader may get something of an idea of the condition of his mind on this subject. 1. He admits that there is a sanctuary in heaven, but claims that it has but one apartment, and that is the “most holy place.” To this it is sufficient to reply that the earthly was a type of the heavenly, and the “pattern” according to which Moses was commanded to make the earthly, was the heavenly Sanctuary itself. Working after that pattern, Moses made a sanctuary with two apartments, a holy place and a most holy place. Yet Mr. Morton says the pattern had but one apartment. Then Moses was a wonderfully stupid builder, so phenomenally stupid that the Holy Spirit itself couldn’t save him from such a blunder! But no; the fact that Moses made two apartments in his likeness of the heavenly temple, is a demonstration that the latter has two apartments also; and it is utterly useless for men to deny it. This fact being forever settled, we inquire, If there are two apartments in the heavenly temple, what are they for? Why will not people be consistent on this question?—It must be that a priestly service is performed in both; and the priests here on earth, in both apartments, served unto the example of a like service in heaven. So Paul directly testifies. Heb. 8: 5. Then it follows, as clear as type and symbol and direct statement can make it, that as the two apartments of the earthly sanctuary typified the two apartments of the heavenly, so the service in each apartment here typified a like service there; and therefore the service in the temple above must follow the same order as that performed here in the shadow which that cast on earth; namely, a long service in the first apartment followed by a short service in the second, which service consisted in making the atonement (Lev. 16), and finished the yearly round of the tabernacle ministry. So Christ will finish his priestly work by a short work of atonement in the most holy place of the heavenly Sanctuary; and then, his work as mediator being done, he will come in all his glory as King of kings and Lord of lords. In strict accordance with the type, this closing work is the cleansing of the Sanctuary; and it is most appropriate that the time when Christ enters upon that momentous division of his priestly work, should be noted in prophecy, as it is in Dan. 8: 14: “Unto two thousand and three hundred days; then shall the Sanctuary be cleansed.” 2. Mr. M. will have Christ perform no service above, except in the most holy place. He says:— “The services performed by the priests in the court of the tabernacle and in the first tabernacle itself, were all typical of the work of Christ on earth, and were completely fulfilled when he expired on the cross.” According to this, Christ must have performed a portion of his priesthood on earth; but this directly contradicts the apostle Paul, who declares positively that he accomplishes no part of his priestly work here below. In Heb. 8: 4, 5, he says: “For if he were on earth, he should not be a priest, seeing that there are priests that offer gifts according to the law; who serve unto the example and shadow of heavenly things.” That is, all the work of the tabernacle priesthood performed here was to be performed by those priests who were ordained thereto by the law of Moses; and all the priesthood of Christ must be performed in heaven. The text referred to (Heb. 7: 26, 27) simply relates to the fact of his giving himself as an offering. But his priesthood could not commence till he had provided the offering wherewith he was to plead for man before his Father. 3. He has Christ make the atonement immediately on his ascension to heaven. He says:— “In the natural order of things, the atonement preceded the session of Christ on the mediatorial throne. . . . His very first act, therefore, after his ascension, was to present his atoning blood in the holy of holies. There he sat down by the Father’s side.” This is no particular improvement over the more common error that the atonement was made upon the cross—an error which inevitably leads to Universalism or the most ultra predestinationism. What he lays down as the “natural order,” every reader of the Old Testament knows is exactly the reverse of the natural order; for in that yearly round of priestly service which prefigured the work of Christ in heaven, making the atonement was the closing up of the work, not the beginning of it; it was the last act, not the first. If this is not so, and if Mr. M. is not entirely wrong in his position, then the type deceives instead of instructs us, and the shadow plays false to the substance which cast it. 4. He falls into the usual chaos over Heb. 10: 20. Verses 19 and 20 read as follows: “Having therefore, brethren, boldness to enter into the holiest by the blood of Jesus, by a new and living way, which he hath consecrated for us, through the veil, that is to say, his flesh.” In reference to this Mr. M. comments as follows:— “The veil therefore was an essential part of the earthly sanctuary. This veil represented Christ’s human nature—his flesh. Heb. 10: 20. When this human nature was lacerated on the cross, and he was in the agonies of death, ‘the veil of the temple was rent in twain.’ The mortal flesh was thenceforward to be replaced by the glorified and immortal body, in which the worshiper might approach into the presence of God.” The person who can evolve an intelligible idea from such a view of the subject ought to rise and explain. Moses was commanded to make a tabernacle and all its furnishings according to patterns which were shown him. According to the view here set forth, it seems that “Christ’s human nature” was shown to Moses, and he was commanded to make something to represent it; and the nearest likeness he could devise was a curtain of fine linen, wrought all over with figures of cherubim, suspended before the most holy place of the sanctuary! But it is said that after this mortal flesh, this veil, was “rent in twain,” it was “to be replaced by the glorified and immortal body.” Then was there not another veil immediately set up when the first was destroyed? And then Mr. M. says that in this we approach to God, but Paul says that we have a way through it. The ancient apostle and the modern expositor are a good ways apart, and one or the other is fearfully mixed. But a slight transposition will free the text from all ambiguity, and make the apostle’s meaning clear and consistent. Thus: “Having, therefore, brethren, boldness to enter through the veil into the holiest by the blood of Jesus, by a new and living way, that is to say, his flesh, which he hath consecrated for us.” Thus it appears that Christ’s “flesh,” that is, the offering which he has provided, is—not the veil, but the new and living way by which we enter through the veil into the Sanctuary on high, and have access to the one mediator between God and man. 5. To prove that there is but one apartment in the heavenly Sanctuary, Mr. M. quotes those texts in Hebrews which speak about the “holy place,” as it is rendered in the common version. Thus Heb. 9: 8: “The Holy Ghost this signifying, that the way into the holiest of all [or, Revised Version, holy place] was not yet made manifest, while as the first tabernacle was yet standing.” Verse 12: “Entered in once into the holy place.” Heb. 10: 19: “Having therefore, brethren, boldness to enter into the holiest by the blood of Jesus.” And, following the Revised Version, he quotes Heb. 9: 24 as follows: “For Christ entered not into a holy place made with hands, like in pattern to the true.” Now Mr. M. knows better than to quote these texts thus, and make this application of them. He is a Greek scholar, and well understands that in every one of these instances the word is in the original in the plural number, reading “holy places,” and should be so translated. This would seem like a deliberate attempt to deceive and mislead the uninformed. But we will not accuse him of this. His course is rather to be attributed, perhaps, to the bewildering influence of a false theology which has led him, like the translators themselves, to turn their rendering into a lie in obedience to its imperious demands. 6. Speaking of S. D. Adventists, he further says:— “They teach that when Jesus did enter into the holy place, it was not for the purpose of presenting his blood, and thus making an atonement, for the sins of his people, but rather that he might enter upon what they call ‘The Investigative Judgment,’ for the purpose of ascertaining from the books of God’s remembrance the actual moral and spiritual489 condition and character of those who in all ages have professed to be his people.” We are utterly unable to account for such a statement as this; for by the insertion of the word “not,” which should not be there, it expresses exactly the reverse of the truth. The very thing we do teach, as every reader of our literature knows, is that Christ entered the most holy place for the very purpose of presenting his blood, and making an atonement for his people. And from the very nature of the case, this is the “Investigative Judgment.” We do not claim that we find this term in the Bible; but we adopt it as being the most clearly expressive of the nature of this portion of the Judgment work; and a moment’s thought must convince any one that just such a Judgment, or investigation of character, and decision of cases for salvation or destruction, must precede the coming of Christ, inasmuch as when Christ appears there is no time allotted for investigation of character, but in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, the two classes, righteous and wicked, both dead and living, are divided, the righteous being made immortal, and the wicked given over to destruction. Well, it may be asked, could not God do this?—No doubt he could; but he has seen fit to reveal to us that when the Judgment sets, books are opened (Dan. 7: 9, 10), and from the record therein men are to be judged according to their works. Rev. 20: 12. Mr. M. thinks our view contrary to the Scriptures because it is as King that Christ judges the people. In this he overlooks the fact that in all judgment work there are two divisions: the judicial, through which examination is made and sentence passed; and the executive, through which the decision rendered is carried into effect. It is as King that Christ engages in this latter work of Judgment, not in the former; as King he executes the Judgment, but does not investigate. This latter work is all done in the Sanctuary, while the “Ancient of Days,” the Father, sits in Judgment (Dan. 7: 9), and Christ, as he makes the atonement, presents the cases to him for acceptance. 7. He speaks of us as “the self-styled ‘Remnant Church.’” This is no self-styling of our own. The Bible calls the last generation of Christians, those who will be living at the second coming of Christ, “the remnant of the woman’s seed.” Rev. 12: 17. Now whether there is such a body on the earth to-day or not, all depends on the question whether or not we have reached the last days and Christ is about to appear. If we have reached that time, as we suppose, there is a “remnant” of those who have constituted the church, now on earth. And whenever that time comes, all who are ready for Christ’s coming will belong to that “remnant.” Even Seventh-day Baptists, if they are saved, must help compose it. We really do not see the call for the sneers with which he interlards his essay on this point. 8. He says that the 2,300 days are literal days, and that the prophecy has been fulfilled, and that if he knew more of history he could tell where. It will be enough if the reader will consider what a wonderful prophecy, on this ground, this would be. Twenty-three hundred literal days are not quite six and a half years. And when the angel propounded the momentous inquiry, “How long shall be the vision . . . to give both the Sanctuary and the host to be trodden under foot?” how sublime would be the answer, would it not, “Unto six years and a quarter; then shall the Sanctuary be cleansed”? He admits that in Num. 14: 34 and Eze. 4: 4-6 days represent years, yet cannot see how in the symbolic prophecy of Dan. 8: 14, days can also represent years. He says:— “I am perfectly satisfied, on the contrary, that there is not a single passage in God’s word in which it is clear from the context that this word [day] has any such meaning.” Has he ever read Dan. 9: 25? Here a period of sixty-nine weeks is marked off, to reach from the commandment to restore and build Jerusalem to the Messiah the Prince. All expositors, except Jewish, understand this to refer to the revelation of Christ at his first advent. In sixty-nine weeks there are 483 days. Were these days literal, or do they represent years? It would be the merest quibble to object that the word “days” is not here used. No one can deny that the same principle is here involved. If the time is literal, it is 483 literal days. If it is symbolic, it is 483 years. According to Mr. M. it must be literal. But who supposes that a prophecy was given covering only sixty-nine literal weeks—about a year and a third—before the manifestation of Christ as the Messiah the Prince? Or who supposes that a commandment to restore Jerusalem went forth a year and a third before Christ came? The idea is too absurd to mention. But if the days in Dan. 9 are symbolic, a day for a year, the days in Dan. 8, which Dan. 9 is given to explain, are also symbolic. 9. Enumerating a few of our “so-called expositions,” he calls them the most “complete column of assumptions,” he has ever seen set up. In answer he simply writes down “assumption,” offering no proof whatever. But as his ipse dixit is worth no more than so much air issuing through any other human larynx, we pass it by. 10. We now come to the crushing climax of his whole effort. He says:— “What I have written above respecting the teachings of the self-styled ‘Remnant’ Church, I have written in all sincerity and good will, but with very little hope that any member of that body will be influenced thereby. I know full well that though the doctrines criticised above are diametrically opposed to the Bible, they are in perfect accord with the teachings of their prophetess, whose so-called relations [revelations?] are permanent with those who believe in her inspiration. If the apostles contradict her ‘visions’ and ‘testimonies,’ so much the worse for the apostles! But I do most earnestly entreat those of God’s dear people who still believe in the Bible, and the Bible alone, as the rule of faith and manners, to pause and weigh the matter carefully before plunging into this miry pool of human invention.” We are sorry Mr. Morton could not finish his essay without unveiling to public view a darkened chamber of his soul out of whose murky recesses the serpent of falsehood thrusts its head to hiss, and the blind owl of bigotry and prejudice lifts up its voice to hoot. If he has investigated the subject at all, he knows that the views we hold on the question of the Sanctuary were not suggested by any vision from sister White, and in all our investigations of the subject we never appeal to any of her writings, but rest the argument wholly upon the Scriptures, taking the ground on this, as upon all other subjects, that whatever is not sustained by the Bible must fall. But he must have his fling at the “prophetess,” even though it be at the expense of truth; he must endeavor to raise prejudice against us, by representing that we would deliberately set aside a positive statement of the apostles, in behalf of a vision or testimony from sister White. All this foolish clap-trap about the Bible and the Bible alone, which we italicise in the foregoing extract just as he published it, is getting a little stale. The profession of “good will” with which he prefaces these statements might well have been dispensed with. We will forego that, sad as it would be, if he will keep himself in harmony with facts. A little less “good will” and a little more truth would be a wonderfully good exchange for him in our opinion. On the subject of the Sanctuary we have no misgivings. It throws a flood of light most wonderful on the philosophy of the plan of salvation, the relation of the two dispensations, and the position and work of Christ, the Redeemer of men, in our behalf. Nothing can exceed the beauty and harmony of the view which it presents. If it is truth, all the mighty hosts of heaven are enlisted in its behalf, and it cannot be overthrown. Mr. M. calls upon his brethren to be careful not to plunge into “this miry pool of human inventions.” We call upon our brethren to give themselves to God by a new, more full, and perfect consecration, that they may everywhere become the vehicles of divine power, and channels through which the light of the glorious gospel may go forth to those who sit in darkness.