AdventAI

IS IT A UNION OF CHURCH AND STATE?

By W. A. Blakely

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 33., August 16, 1887

The National Reform Association are very strenuous in their assertions that they are opposed to the union of Church and State, as the following resolution, adopted at their National Convention in Cleveland, Ohio, will show:—

Resolved, That we re-affirm that this religious amendment, instead of infringing on any individual’s right of conscience, or tending in the least degree to a union of Church and State, will afford the fullest security against a corrupting church establishment, and form the strongest safeguard of both the civil and religious liberties of all citizens.

But as they “affirm” and “re-affirm” that the National Reform movement does not tend “in the least degree to a union of Church and State,” it would be well to consider what constitutes a union of Church and State according to “reform” ideas. Professor C. A. Blanchard, in the Pittsburg National Convention of 1874, defined it as follows:—

Union of Church and State is the selection by the nation of one church, the endowment of such a church, the appointment of its officers, and oversight of its doctrines.

And then he continues:—

For such a union none of us plead. To such a union we are all of us opposed.

But what they do want is stated by Mr. W. J. Coleman, one of the leading public lecturers of the Association, in the Christian Statesman of Nov. 1, 1883:—

The first sentence of Article 1 of Amendments reads: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” This would be made consistent with the proposed [National Reform] amendment by substituting the words “a church” for “religion,” making it read, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of a church.” This is what the Reform Association believes should be the rule in a rightly constituted State. There should be religion but no church.

Professor Blanchard presents to the public view such a union of Church and State as would be impossible for them to obtain in this country, and then boldly says: “For such a union none of us plead. To such a union we are all of us opposed.” They were probably opposed to “such a union” in the time of Constantine, too; for not one of those statements was true concerning the union that was then brought about, as we shall hereafter show.

But there is a union that the “reformers” do want, and that, as they express it, is the establishment of the Christian religion (i. e., the evangelical churches as a whole) by the State, but not by any one church. We find a statement of this position published in the Christian Statesman of Feb. 7, 1884, as follows:—

But these divisions are a fact, and they have been overruled so that they are not inconsistent with the unity of the church. All upon whom the name of Christ is named, have their calling. The Methodists have their vocation in the history of the church, to arouse Christian life; the Presbyterians their vocation, to conserve Calvinistic principles; and the Reformed Presbyterians their vocation, to keep unfurled the blue banner “for Christ’s crown and covenant.” We are different divisions of Immanuel’s army. The Methodists are the charging cavalry, the Presbyterians the fighting infantry, the Covenanters the batteries upon the heights. We have one Commander-in-Chief, and under him we go forward, one united phalanx against the common enemy. And when the victory is gained, the army will be one as the Leader is one.

In other words, it is the aggregate of religious influence and authority in this country. Now that is exactly what Webster defines as the church. We read:—

CHURCH—5. The aggregate of religious influences in a community; ecclesiastical influence, authority, etc.; as, to array the power of the church against some form of moral evil.

Then “religion,” in the sense that the Religious Amendmentists use the term, and “church,” as here defined, are exactly the same. Then that for which the National Reform Association are working, although they deny it on account of the odium of that term to a free people, is the union of Church and State in this country.

It has been established, then, beyond successful contradiction, that that for which this association is working, is the union of Church and State in this free Republic. Yet some may think that as long as the Christian religion, as a whole, is the established religion, it would be but very few that would be deprived of their rights. But let me state what no truly American citizen will deny: A just government will insure to each citizen the rights with which his Creator endowed him; and will in no way abridge or restrict the rights of a single person. This is the idea given in the immortal Declaration of Independence:—

We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men.

Then the moment that this nation deprives any of its citizens of their rights, even though those citizens be few in number, that moment it departs from the principles upon which this Government was founded; and, in action, if not in word, denies the truths for which our noble ancestors pledged their lives, their fortunes, and their sacred honor. For shame, then, that after we have so long enjoyed the liberty guaranteed to us by our present Constitution, there are those who—I say it with regret—in the name of Christ would seek to destroy one of the most important principles upon which our Government was founded—the right of individual conscience!

To show further that this movement is a union of Church and State, we will refer the reader to the pages of history. No one will deny that there was a union of Church and State brought about by Constantine. Yet what Constantine did is what the National Reform Association want the people of the United States to do. A comparison of history with the teachings of the “reformers” shows this conclusively. Gibbon, in his “Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire,” chap. 20, par. 17, says:—

The gratitude of the church has exalted the virtues and excused the failings of a generous patron [Constantine] who seated Christianity on the throne of the Roman world. . . . The exact balance of the two religions [pagan and Christian] continued but a moment.

Now, what do these agitators want this Government to do? Rev. J. M. Foster, one of the leading workers in the movement, says:—

The duties which the reigning Mediator requires of nations [are], (1.) A constitutional recognition of himself as King of nations. . . . (2.) A constitutional recognition of their duty as the divinely appointed keeper of the moral law. . . . (3.) A constitutional provision of moral and religious qualifications for their officers. . . . (4.) An acknowledgment and exemplification of the duty of national covenanting with him. . . . (5.) An acknowledgment and performance of the nation’s duty to guard and protect the church,—by suppressing all public violation of the moral law; by maintaining a system of public schools, indoctrinating their youth in morality and virtue; by exempting church property from taxation; and “by providing her funds out of the public treasury for carrying on her aggressive work at home and in the foreign field.—Christian Statesman, Feb. 21, 1884.

And again:—

According to the Scriptures, the State and its sphere exist for the sake of and to serve the interests of the Church.

He also says that it is—

The duty of the State, as such, to enter into alliance with the Church of Christ, and to profess, adhere to, defend, and maintain the true religion.—Christian Statesman, March, 1884.

And Professor Blanchard, in the National Convention, held in Pittsburg, Pa., in 1874, said:—

Constitutional laws punish for false money, weights, and measure, and of course Congress establishes a standard for money, weight, and measure. So Congress must establish a standard of religion, or admit anything called religion.

And then, as we find in the Christian Statesman,—

Enforce upon all that come among us the laws of Christian morality.

This is the reason why he says:—

Union of Church and State is the selection by the nation of one church, the endowment of such a church, the appointment of its officers, and oversight of its doctrines.

For they want to define the union of Church and State as something different from that for which they are working, and then they can boldly say,—

Resolved, That we re-affirm that this religious amendment, instead of infringing on any individual’s right of conscience, or tending in the least degree to a union of Church and State, will afford the fullest security against a corrupting Church establishment, and form the strongest safeguard of both the civil and religious liberties of all citizens.—National Convention, Cleveland, Ohio.

But their pretended argument is mere sophistry; for if nothing less than what Professor Blanchard asserts is a union of Church and State would constitute a union, then history proves positively that they were not united during the reign of Constantine. This statement will be verified in another article. W. A. BLAKELY.

(Concluded next week.)