“WRATH OF THE ADVENTISTS.”
By Editor
Under this heading, the Michigan Christian Advocate finally responds to our exposure of its course, published in the REVIEW of Sept. 27. The weakness of its position is now fully shown in that it offers not a particle of proof to sustain its false and slanderous charge that S. D. Adventists were applying to Eld. Canright “coarse epithets,” “billingsgate,” and “vituperation.” All we wanted was some proof of this charge, and some specimens of the hard things, which it was claimed were being uttered. Referring to the fact that evidence of the truthfulness of the statement was repeatedly called for by the editor of the REVIEW AND HERALD, the Advocate says:— “As we did not deem the said editor entitled to a knowledge of the sources of our information, we made no reply except to assure him in a courteous manner that the item he referred to was not intended to misrepresent his people, and that the party writing the paragraph did so upon what he believed to be reliable information.” It may be according to the Advocate’s standard of courtesy to wait till three letters are written before replying at all, and then to attempt to pass the matter off by saying that they calculated they had reliable information; but we do not think it would pass in many communities. And we did not call for the “sources of information;” we called for the evidences of the truthfulness of the information itself. We are not concerned about the sources. But if the Advocate has ever heard, or any of its correspondents have ever heard, Adventists applying foul language to Eld. C., they can tell what it was and who said it. This is what we wanted to know. And the fact that they produce nothing of the kind, shows that they have met with nothing of the kind, and hence have made up the slander out of the whole cloth. The Advocate now volunteers this further information: “Our authority for the statement was the personal testimony of several of our preachers and correspondents.” The greater number they involve in the statement without wiping off from it the taint of falsehood, the worse it will be for them. We gave the Advocate ample time for it to secure from whomsoever the assertion might have come, the proof of its correctness. But it has nothing to present. It further says: “The words of our paragraph may have been too strong, but the provocation seemed great to the writer thereof.” And what was the provocation? Some false reports which some of their ministers sent in, and which the editor was apparently but too glad to get, and so published without waiting for proof. The words “too strong” are a pretty easy let down for an absolute untruth. Our people have either used billingsgate and vituperation against the party named, or they have not. If they have, it can be proved; if they have not, it is an odious falsehood to charge them with it. Referring to our offer of free copies of the leaflet containing the correspondence, the Advocate says: “Some of his people are acting as his tools, and our subscribers need not be surprised to receive copies of this bitter tract.” The general verdict of those who have read the tract is that we drew it very mild on the Advocate so far as the words are concerned, but the facts exposed must be rather a bitter pill for it; that is where the bitterness of the tract comes in; and for this the Advocate itself furnishes the wormwood. It is true that some of our people are having great freedom circulating the tract; but we are not aware that they are acting particularly as our “tools;” for it is no personal vindication that we are making. The charge rests upon the denomination everywhere, and our brethren may very properly put forth a little effort to clear themselves from the foul aspersion. And, finally, the Advocate lays unto its soul the flattering unction that it isn’t so bad to tell a lie, as it is to call it a lie after it is told! To this end it publishes a letter from a correspondent which opens as follows:— “I doubt whether the correspondence under the head of ‘Clerical Falsehood,’ is a Christian course to pursue. The words ‘clerical falsehood’ are about as hard words against a brother as can be used, and I believe are more guilty words than the paragraph complained of, the writer of which, I think, used stronger words than the case admits of.” To which we reply that we think that to utter a falsehood calculated to smirch and damage one’s Christian character and reputation is about as hard a course as can be pursued against a brother; and when such a course is pursued, it is right to call it by its true name. Falsehood is falsehood whether in the saloon loafer or the doctor of divinity; and when found on the lips of the latter, it appears as much worse than when found with the former, as the profession and position of the latter are higher than those of the former. It may seem to the writer of the foregoing to be a “Christian course” for one to suffer himself to be defamed by charges for which he knows there is no foundation, and make no remonstrance, and more wicked for him to repudiate the false testimony as a falsehood, than it is for the other party to utter the falsehood in the first place. But we have never yet ascertained that such is the ethics of the gospel, or that such an exposure is any particular exhibition of “wrath.”