No doubt much thought has been given, by the leading brethren of our denomination, to the future prospects of the city mission work. This department of the cause has assumed much prominence for the last two or three years. Since the Bible-reading work has been inaugurated among us, and we have seen its vast importance so fully, it has been discerned that through it access could be had to many persons, especially in our large cities, whom we could not reach otherwise. And we have no reason at the present time to doubt that by means of workers experienced in giving Bible readings, much good has been done, and that more can be done in the future. The success of this branch of the work, and its great importance, have been demonstrated beyond all question. It is evidently one of our most effective agencies to reach intelligent, conscientious people in our large cities. Already churches have been brought out by this means, where before scarcely any observers of the Lord’s Sabbath were to be found. It reaches a class of people that perhaps could not be induced to come to our tents to listen to lectures, owing to the prejudice they have against adventism and the Sabbath. By means of these intelligent workers this prejudice is removed, and they come to feel the deepest interest in Bible subjects. We have no doubt whatever concerning the importance of this method of disseminating the truth, and we apprehend that it will increase, and become more and more efficient as the work advances.
Having said this much in favor of the Bible-reading work and city missions, we wish to consider some other points which seem to be of similar importance. Many of our larger city missions, in various Conferences, have really been designed to fill the position of training-schools, to educate workers and give them experience. In the remarks made, we have spoken of experienced workers, those who have become thoroughly familiar with the work, and have developed earnestness and piety,—persons of intelligence and character; in short, those who fully understand their business. If we had one hundred of these where we have one, they could find abundance of work to do in advancing the truth. Our training-schools are designed to develop such workers, and we have succeeded in obtaining some of real excellence. But these training-schools are certainly very expensive, and those who have had experience in them know full well that there is no branch of the cause that costs more in proportion to the work accomplished than do the training-schools and city missions. Some Conferences have depleted their treasury, and brought themselves under burdens of indebtedness in trying to carry several of these at the same time.
When the thought of city missions and Bible-reading work first dawned upon our minds, we felt that we had reached a matter of great importance, and that much was to be accomplished through this agency, and in some cases evidently sufficient caution was not used; and our brethren found to their cost that there was another side to this question, and they experienced much perplexity and difficulty in extricating themselves from the position they had assumed.
Another point which we think has been abundantly demonstrated in the past in connection with these training-schools, is the fact that in all cases they have not produced the results that are most favorable. We know some that have been abandoned, and a discouraging feeling is left in consequence. Why is this?—Because, first, they are very expensive; secondly, only here and there are to be found persons suitable to manage such schools; thirdly, sufficient care has not been exercised in selecting persons to receive instruction in them. In regard to the cost, we have learned by experience that a mission training-school, such as is really worthy to be placed in connection with the work in our large cities, will cost several thousand dollars per year, at least, to keep up its expenses. Rent is high, and with such buildings as are really fit to be occupied, and from which the present truth can be presented in an intelligent and suitable manner, the expense must be high. In fact, it is quite difficult for a weak Conference to bear such a burden. By such workers as are usually sent there for instruction, there is but little missionary work done until they have received instruction for a period of some months. These must be excellent schools to accomplish the work they should. Then, in training workers to become persons of experience, very much indeed depends upon the qualifications of the persons instructing them. We cannot teach others what we do not know ourselves, and many who have good ideas are not able to impress them on others.
After some observation, we feel very certain that there are few, indeed, among us of our ministers and public laborers who can do this kind of work acceptably. The difficulties are great when we bring large numbers of persons of both sexes together, to train them for this work. To bring them where they can become intelligent, persons of thorough piety, capable of meeting all classes, and understanding history and the Scriptures so as to meet the objections which will arise, requires the most earnest devotion, and constant care and tact of no mean order, united with firmness, intelligence, love of mercy, untiring zeal, and an intimate knowledge of human nature. In some of our missions we have had fair success, but we feel sure that those who have had charge of them see many things in which they desire improvement. One great difficulty to be met among young people under such circumstances is a sympathetic sentimentalism which some are in danger of mistaking for religion. This will, with the least encouragement, develop into love-sickness and a courting spirit. Such things, when they come into a mission, blight its prospects and often ruin its effectiveness. To be eagle-eyed enough to keep out these malign influences, and have enough grace about us to impress deeply the spirit of consecration and true religion, requires constant watchfulness, and care, and devotion, and much prayer, and spiritual perception of the highest order. Satan will bring into such training-schools, if possible, a spirit foreign to the gospel of Christ.
We verily believe that greater care must be exercised in selecting persons to enter these missions. Many of our people seem to think that almost any one can become a successful missionary worker, if only blessed with good looks and a sprightly tongue. But this is a great mistake. Persons present themselves who have never even read their Bible through, who know nothing of experimental religion, who are animated by a worldly spirit, and many who have but little real intelligence, and small experience in life. But they seem to think it would be nice to become Bible readers, mission workers, etc. They never dream of the real work of preparation to be accomplished in order to become successful laborers. In some of our missions much time and patience has been exercised in trying to teach such minds what they ought to have learned before they ever entered upon this work. We question seriously the advisability of sending young girls sixteen or eighteenp. 666 years of age to our city missions, expecting they will be prepared to go out and instruct men and women of intelligence and experience in life, persons who understand history and are well acquainted with life in all its phases. Such young workers must appear at a great disadvantage. It is possible there are, here and there, some who will succeed after long and patient training, but they are few and far between. Successful Bible readers need to be just as well qualified to teach the Bible as is the minister who labors for the salvation of souls. They need not have precisely the same gift, but they need the same intelligence. We have doubtless made many mistakes in sending out young persons as ministers who were wholly unfitted for such a sacred calling. But if we view the matter correctly, we are making still greater mistakes in sending out some of this class as Bible readers. They require the same tact and ability and Christian experience that the laborer does who speaks from the desk. We need to have the standard raised so as to procure a better class of laborers to engage in this important and sacred calling.
It is too costly to undertake to do this work of training entirely in our city missions. There should be some preliminary arrangement where this training can be given before they come into our city missions. We incline to the opinion that the number of our training-schools will decrease rather than increase. We should seek for the very best gifts among us to take charge of this work of instruction, and make them more thorough, so that our workers will attain a higher standard of excellence, and be prepared to do much better work. We incline to the opinion, also, that the General Conference will have to oversee this matter to an extent that they have not yet done. And we trust the coming General Conference will carefully consider the whole subject. We do not, in saying this, design to discourage but to elevate. We feel sure that our efforts to educate workers in our missions ought not to decrease but greatly increase, and that every person among us who is capable of doing faithful and intelligent work in bringing the truth before our fellow-men, ought to be found and given the best education for it possible. For we have to meet intelligent people, and we want to do it in a way that will not bring contempt upon the truth, but honor and success. May God give us wisdom to deal with these questions of importance as we should.
G. I. B.