AN ILLUSTRATION

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 20, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 38.

Read the full edition

AN ILLUSTRATION.

INDIVIDUALS who disclaim against the law of God, the ten commandments, as being only a temporary arrangement for the Jewish dispensation, and not existing before the creation of man, have endeavored to heap ridicule upon the opposite view by pointing to the fact that some of these commandments make provision for circumstances and relations which from the nature of things could not have existed before that time, and cannot exist in the future immortal state. Pointing to some one of these, as, for instance, the fifth, they will triumphantly ask, How could this commandment have been broken in heaven, when none of the inhabitants ever had any mother? Or perhaps they will point to the seventh commandment, or the tenth, and inquire how it would have been possible for any one to violate them before the conditions to which they relate had come into existence. They seem to think this objection unanswerable, and sufficient to establish beyond all question the temporary nature of the law of ten commandments.
Let us examine the above specimen of anti-nomian reasoning in the light of a text of scripture which brings to view a parallel case. It is in the fifth chapter of Galatians, and relates to the operations of the Holy Spirit. This Spirit pervades every action of the heavenly host; the same Spirit also controls the actions of Christ’s followers upon the earth. The text (verse 22) reads: “But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, long-suffering, gentleness, goodness, faith, meekness, temperance.” Let us see. One of the fruits of the Spirit is “long-suffering.” Is there any long-suffering in heaven?—Certainly not, for the simple reason that there is no occasion for any. There are no circumstances or conditions which would demand its exercise. Again, faith is mentioned as one of these fruits. Is faith something that is exercised by the heavenly host?—Certainly not, in any such sense as it is used here. Faith is lost in sight. Now let us apply the astute reasoning of the antinomians. The operations of the Spirit relate to conditions which involve the exercise of long-suffering and faith. But such conditions have no existence in heaven. Hence we come to the sublime conclusion that in heaven the fruits of the Spirit do not exist. To better illustrate the fallacy of such shallow philosophy we put the two side by side, in the form of the syllogism:—

ANTINOMIAN REASONING.

Major premise: The ten commandments govern such conditions as the maternal relation, the conjugal relation, and the ownership, of cattle, oxen, asses, etc.
Minor premise: These conditions had no existence before the creation of man.
Conclusion: Therefore, the ten commandments had no existence prior to the creation of man.

APPLIED TO GAL. 5:22.

Major premise: The operation of the Holy Spirit governs conditions which involve the exercise of long-suffering and faith.
Minor premise: In heaven these conditions do not exist.
Conclusion: Therefore, in heaven there is no operation of the Holy Spirit.
To such preposterous conclusions does this specimen of antinomian logic lead. When a person resorts to such reasoning as this to do away with the law of God, it is pretty good evidence that he feels the need of making a desperate effort to free himself from the heavy load of its condemnation.