AdventAI

KNOWN BY ITS FRUITS.

By I. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 44., November 8, 1887

In Matt. 7:16-20, our Saviour gave to his disciples, and through them to the church, a principle by which they might with unfailing accuracy detect between the false and the true, the good and the evil, of all that should come to them claiming their confidence. He says: “Ye shall know them by their fruits.” “Every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit. A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.” “Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.”

This principle of testing character by fruits is recognized by men everywhere, whether in the church or out of it, as a sound one. We apply it to our neighbors as a test of their character, and the world applies it to the Church (often with sad results) as a test of the genuineness of its professions. Why may it not also apply to the doctrines taught by the church, as a test of their truth or falsity? Certainly nothing can be more truly said to bear fruits than a person’s religious belief; and it ought to be true that a correct belief will bear good fruit, and an erroneous belief, evil fruit; and conversely, if the fruits which a doctrine bears are such as benefit mankind, that doctrine is a good one; if its effects are of an opposite nature upon those who receive it, it is a bad doctrine, and ought to be rejected. We believe no one can dissent from the reasonableness of this proposition. Let us consider the nature of some of the beliefs commonly held by the religious world to-day, as determined by this principle.

Take, for example, a very popular belief—that of man’s natural immortality. We select this because its fruits are numerous, and easy to be discerned. Here the question might be asked, What are to be considered as the fruits of this doctrine? We answer, The various religious beliefs which owe their existence to it, which spring directly from it, and of which it is the fundamental idea. That there are many such the reader hardly needs to be told. Any one who has examined closely the foundations of present popular religious beliefs, knows that should the doctrine of man’s natural immortality be suddenly swept from its place, there would be a mighty crash in the great temple of orthodoxy, and many a theological superstructure would come tumbling to the ground. We will name a few of them, and notice whether their effect upon mankind has been beneficial or otherwise.

First, it follows that if man is naturally immortal, he will never die, in the sense of becoming unconscious, but will exist to all eternity. This is well enough for those who pass this eternity within the gates of the celestial city, but where does it place the remainder, and according to the words of Christ, the majority, of mankind?—In the lake of fire, without a possibility of escape. Through all eternity, as long as heaven and God himself shall exist, there will exist the fiery abode of the damned, tossing upon its flaming billows the shrieking, blaspheming souls of the finally impenitent. Only thus far can we follow out this idea before we are brought face to face with this revolting spectacle. Brought up to believe this horrible picture is a necessary result of the teachings of Christianity, how many have renounced faith in the Bible and the very existence of God, and made shipwreck of their lives upon the rocks of infidelity? They are not a few, as the reader knows.

In the minds of others, as they have pondered over this matter, there have arisen some grave queries. The missionary sent abroad to heathen lands, brings to mind the cases of the heathen who have lived and died without any knowledge of the true God, and whose ears have never been gladdened with the good tidings of the gospel. He reflects that other people have been blessed with every privilege Christianity affords, but these poor beings have passed into the grave without having had the slightest opportunity either to embrace Christianity or to reject it. Perhaps they would have accepted it gladly if only it had been brought within their reach. And now these souls, in common with the most incorrigible of Christian lands, must be plunged into the lake of fire, and there suffer to all eternity, like the most hardened sinner. The opportunities of one have been very slight, and his sins very few, while another has had every opportunity and been guilty of the most atrocious crimes; yet the punishment of both is exactly alike. Can such inconsistency, such manifest injustice, ever have a place in the plans of the beneficent and all-wise Creator?—No, it cannot be. There must have been some provision made for such cases. But these heathen can never cease to exist somewhere, for their souls are immortal. It is not justice to keep them forever in the flames of hell, and there is no other abode in the universe except that of the righteous; consequently they must in some way and at some time find their way into this abode. Thus he reflects upon the matter, and finally arrives at the conclusion that there is to be another chance for those who have been denied Christian privileges in this life, and out of this comes, with a great flourish, the doctrine of future probation. The American Board of Foreign Missions is shaken with a mighty convulsion, a division is formed, a long period of wrangling and strife ensues, and the work of the Board is crippled: and what further evils are to follow in the wake of this new doctrine, time only can reveal.

We cannot pass unnoticed, in this connection, the great structure of paganism. Upon what principle is pagan worship founded? Perhaps it would not be correct to say that the immortality of the soul is the fundamental idea of paganism, but we believe it is safe to assert that no doctrine has contributed more to the upholding of this mighty system of fraud. Take away this doctrine from the two great religious systems of the pagan world—Brahmanism and Hinduism—and how much of them would be left?—They would collapse completely, and their forms of worship would come to an end on the instant.

The Catholic doctrine of purgatory, and the various forms of hero-worship, ancient and modern, rest upon the same foundation. The gods of the ancient heathen nations were composed largely of the souls of their dead heroes, either real or fabled, which they believed to have passed on into a higher state of existence. The nations of Greece and Rome are well-known examples. Their worship could not have been carried on for a day without a belief in man’s natural immortality. No more could the doctrine of purgatory and a present hell have existed in medieval ages, to pave the way for the doctrine of popish pardons and indulgences, and furnish Romish monks an opportunity to rob their credulous subjects, without this same support.

What effect this doctrine of immortality has upon the doctrines of the resurrection, the Judgment, and the second coming of Christ, so prominent in the Scriptures, a moment’s glance will show. The soul of man being immortal, of course all the righteous at death go immediately to heaven, and enter upon their reward. This being so, where is the necessity for a future general Judgment? The only purpose of such a Judgment would be to determine who among mankind are worthy of the reward of eternal life, and who are not. But this has been already determined; for are not the righteous dead already in heaven, and the wicked dead in hell? Why hold a Judgment to determine over again what is already determined and can never be reversed? Following out this train of reasoning, the conclusion is soon reached that there will be no future Judgment, that the Bible really does not mean what it says upon that subject. Nor is there any greater need of a general resurrection, or of a personal coming of Christ to earth. He need not come here to take his people; they will go to him at death; and as for a resurrection of the body, there is no particular need of such a thing. The souls of the righteous are enjoying bliss unspeakable in the realms above; what more could they enjoy if re-embodied? And why re-embody the souls of the damned? The absurdities which are involved here sooner or later have their effect. Unbelief creeps in, and eventually these grand themes for religious thought, made so prominent in the Scriptures, are dropped from the individual’s belief altogether, taking with them a goodly portion of the sacred writings, or remain impenetrably shrouded in the mists of a darkened understanding.

One more doctrine which the immortality dogma upholds we cannot refrain from noticing, because it is one of the latest which have been built upon it, and of all such doctrines is destined to be the most injurious; namely, Spiritualism. The deplorable effects of this doctrine are so manifest that even the orthodox churches denounced it unsparingly when it first appeared, and do so now to a considerable extent; but they are powerless to combat it successfully. Why?—Because its main prop and pillar is one of their own cherished doctrines—the immortality of the soul. If our friends are each possessed of an immortal spirit, which is really the essential part of each, and lives on after the death of the body, with greater powers and higher knowledge than it had before, why is it a strange thing that they should visit us at times after their decease, and communicate to us the things of the spirit world? Spiritualists affirm that they do, and the advantage is on their side; for while other advocates of natural immortality can bring no evidence at all against this alleged fact, they can produce in support of it what is apparently the very strongest of evidence, namely, the actual, visible appearance of those who claim to be their dead friends, with every characteristic of features, dress, voice, and manners corresponding with this claim to the minutest detail, and possessed of all the knowledge which their friends ever had in life. Upon this vantage ground, Spiritualism has everything its own way, and pursues its ravages almost unmolested, teaching its deluded victims to throw away the Bible, renounce the most sacred family ties, and commit other sins of the most revolting character. Swiftly and surely it is doing its terrible work of undermining Christian faith, while the churches look helplessly on, unable to strike an effective blow. But take away the idea of natural immortality, uproot the belief that man’s spirit is immortal and self-conscious, a living, intelligent entity after the body dies, and the vital point is touched. Do this, and Spiritualism will have received its death blow, and Spiritualistic phenomena will stand revealed in their true light, as the working of Satan with power and signs and lying wonders.

We have not presented all the fruits of this great fundamental idea which upholds such a large portion of the superstructure of religious error; to do so would require the space of a volume. But we have presented enough to enable us to apply the principle: “Ye shall know them by their fruits.” We have seen some of the fruits of this doctrine, and they are unquestionably evil. Good fruits it has none; we challenge its advocates to point to any. “A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.” In the light of this scripture and the foregoing illustrations, we ask the question, What is the character of the doctrine of the immortality of the soul? Is it good or evil, true or false? We leave the answer with the reader.

I. A. S.