AdventAI

THE WITHDRAWAL OF MR. SPURGEON.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 44., November 8, 1887

In our news column last week, we noticed the fact that Mr. Charles H. Spurgeon, the great English divine, had announced his withdrawal from the English Baptist Union. He did not do this without giving to the Union his reasons. As they appear in an American religious journal, they are as follows:—

“A new religion has been initiated (in the Baptist churches), which is no more Christianity than chalk is cheese. And this religion, being destitute of moral honesty, palms itself off as the old faith with slight improvements, and on this plea usurps pulpits which were erected for gospel preaching. The atonement is scouted, the inspiration of Scripture is derided, the punishment of sin is turned into fiction, and the resurrection into a myth; and yet these enemies of our faith expect us to call them brethren, and maintain a confederacy with them!”

‘At the back of doctrinal falsehood comes a natural decline of spiritual life, evidenced by a taste for questionable amusements, and a weariness of devotional meetings. . . .

“The case is mournful. Certain ministers are making infidels. Avowed atheists are not a tenth as dangerous as those preachers who scatter doubt and stab at faith. A plain man told us the other day that two ministers had derided him because he thought we should pray for rain. A gracious woman bemoaned in my presence that a precious promise in Isaiah which had comforted her had been declared by her minister to be uninspired. It is a common thing to hear working-men excuse their wickedness by the statement that there is no hell—the parson says so.”

These are a few of Mr. Spurgeon’s statements to the Union on the occasion of his withdrawal. He is a conscientious Christian minister, and if his statements are true it is no wonder that he withdrew. The Baptist Union and other popular religious bodies are not ready to admit that they are. Mr. Spurgeon is a prominent figure in the religious world, and the Union is very loth to have him leave; and other prominent bodies are well aware that these same charges could be made against them with as much propriety as against the churches of the Union. Thus they try to excuse his action on the ground that he is hot-headed and impulsive, and has taken this step in a fit of impatience. His charges are the same which Seventh-day Adventists have published against the popular churches in this country, and are met in the same manner,—“His statements are too sweeping,” “they apply only to isolated cases;” “The churches as a body are all right;” “they contain as good men now as they ever did,” etc.

What the condition of the churches composing the English Baptist Union is we have no very direct means of knowing; but it is reasonable to presume that Mr. Spurgeon has had ample opportunity for observation, and in making these charges knows what he is talking about. Perhaps Mr. Spurgeon’s zeal is rather hot in religious matters (it could not have been hotter than Paul’s), and the charges which he makes not true of the Baptist’s Union as a whole; must a person wait until the corruption has extended to the entire body before proceeding to separation? That there are such persons in the body as those mentioned in the above charges, no one has denied; and when the Baptist Union, at its late session at Sheffield, having their attention called to the work of these men, virtually indorsed it by refusing to take any action in the matter, no conscientious Christian with his eyes open could have done otherwise than as the great evangelist did.

Were these charges made against the leading denominations of America, who would dare deny them? Who that has been observing in the matter could fail to see in it marked tendencies toward these very things? Is it an uncommon thing to hear language from the pulpit which scouts the atonement, or which derides the inspiration of the Scriptures? Is not the punishment of sin turned into a fiction, and the resurrection into a myth, by the utter ignoring which they receive in the world of religious thought and utterance to-day? And is any one so stupid as not to have observed that the worldliness of the church and the unscriptural teachings of popular ministers are making infidels on every hand? Ministers may deny these things, but the common people know that they are true. We believe Mr. Spurgeon’s arraignment of the churches is none too severe. We believe he was not so desirous of parting with his co-laborers in the work of the Baptist Union as to leave them for other than valid reasons. In doing this he has but added his voice to the cry already sounding to the honest in heart throughout Christendom, “Come out of her, my people; that ye be not-partakers of her sins, and receive not of her plagues.”

L. A. S.