THE STORY OF BATHYBIUS

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 1, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 43.

Read the full edition

THE STORY OF BATHYBIUS.

It is not with any intention of making light of the researches of science, or from any lack of appreciation of the benefits science has conferred upon mankind, that we publish, from time to time, articles which are not designed to reflect any credit upon the cherished theories of some of its eminent devotees. Theories which are directly contrary to the teachings of the Scriptures and directly calculated to undermine confidence in the same, have no claim to be treated in any other manner. We think it is right also to call attention to the fact that even the most eminent scientists are liable to be and sometimes are wholly mistaken in their conclusions, even those which they support by the most confident of assertions. To this end we quote the following from the New York Observer, which prints it under the above heading:—
“A signal and striking example of the fallibility of human wisdom in the sphere of scientific investigation is afforded by the Duke of Argyle in a paper which appears in the September number of the Nineteenth Century. The paper has to do with the theory first propounded by Darwin, and afterward generally accepted in the scientific world, in regard to the formation of coral islands. In the course of the exploring voyage which Darwin made around the world in 1832–36, his investigations of submarine life led him to the belief that coral islands, instead of being formed, as had been previously supposed, by coral-building animals to ‘afford themselves protection in the inner parts,’ and based upon the craters of extinct volcanoes, were really built upon mountains and islands which had sunk beneath the surface of the water. Darwin studied and investigated the subject carefully with an earnest desire to arrive at the real truth. But all the facts which he was able to obtain seemed to square with this hypothesis, and he became convinced that he had made a great discovery. Accordingly, when he returned to England in 1836, he gave his subsidence theory to the world. The announcement laid the foundations of Darwin’s fame. He was hailed as a new light risen upon the earth. His theory was caught up eagerly and gladly by scientific men everywhere, and was soon generally recognized and accepted as established truth. For years men have been building upon it with as much confidence and unquestioning faith as they build upon the theory of gravitation. But what has come to pass now?—The whole subsidence theory broken down and overthrown as easily and completely as Darwin broke down and overthrew the theories that preceded it. The iconoclast this time is an English naturalist by the name of John Murray, a man whom the Duke of Argyle ranks among the foremost scientists of our time. He, too, has been on an exploring voyage among the coral islands, and has brought back evidence which proves almost beyond the shadow of a doubt that coral reefs and atolls are formed upon the natural surface of the ocean bed, elevated by subterranean forces, and not upon submerged islands and mountains. It is also proved by Dr. Murray that the foundations of coral islands may sometimes be, not solid rock, but, just what Darwin assumed they never could be, deep-sea deposits. Sufficient evidence has been afforded to make it certain that Darwin’s subsidence theory must now take its place among those exploded, wrecked, and worn-out things which lie along the backward track of human progress.”
“But a lesson still more pointed and striking than that to be drawn from the foregoing statements on the coral-island theories is contained in the concluding passages of the Duke of Argyle’s paper. It is the story of bathybius, the wonderful substance so long accepted by scientists because of its supposed harmony with Darwin’s speculations concerning the origin of life. The story is too rich and rare to be condensed or abridged, so we give it in the Duke’s own words:—
“‘Along with the earlier specimens of deep-sea deposits sent home by naturalists during the first soundings in connection with the Atlantic telegraph cable, there was very often a sort of enveloping slimy mucus in the containing bottles which arrested the attention and excited the curiosity of the specialists to whom they were consigned. It was structureless to all microscopic examination. But so is all the protoplasmic matter of which the lowest animals are formed. Could it be a widely diffused medium of this protoplasmic material not yet specialized or individualized into organic forms, nor yet itself in a condition to build up inorganic skeletons for a habitation? Here was a grand idea! It would be well to find missing links, but it would be better to find the primordial pabulum out of which all living things had come. The ultra-Darwinian enthusiasts were enchanted, Haeckel clapped his hands and shouted out, Eureka! loudly. Even the cautious and discriminating mind of Professor Huxley was caught by this new and grand generalization of the “physical basis of life.” It was announced by him to the British Association in 1868. Dr. W. B. Carpenter took up the chorus. He spoke of “a living expanse of protoplasmic substance,” penetrating with its living substance the whole mass of the oceanic mud. A fine new Greek name was devised for this mother slime, and it was christened “bathybius,” from the consecrated deeps in which it lay. The conception ran like wild-fire through the popular literature of science, and here again there was something like a coming plebiscit in its favor. Expectant imagination soon played its part. Wonderful movements were seen in this mysterious slime. It became an “irregular net-work,” and it could be seen gradually “altering its form,” so that “entangled granules gradually changed their relative positions.” The naturalists of the “Challenger” began their voyage in the full bathybian faith. But the sturdy mind of Mr. John Murray kept its balance—all the more easily since he never could himself find or see any trace of this pelagic protoplasm when the dredges of the “Challenger” came fresh from the bathybian bottoms. Again and again he looked for it, but never could he discover it. It always hailed from home. The bottles sent there were reported to yield it in abundance, but somehow it seemed to be hatched in them. The laboratory in Jermyn street was its unfailing source, and the great observer there was its only sponsor. The ocean never yielded it until it had been bottled. At last, one day on board the “Challenger” an accident revealed the mystery. One of Mr. Murray’s assistants poured a large quantity of spirits of wine into a bottle containing some pure sea-water, when, lo! the wonderful protoplasm bathybius appeared. It was the chemical precipitate of sulphate of lime produced by the mixture of alcohol and sea-water. This was bathos indeed. On this announcement, “bathybius” disappeared from science, leaving us, in more senses than one, a great lesson on “precipitation.”’”
“What words of ours can add to the force of this illustration of the credulousness of unbelieving men of science, especially where the matter which appeals to their credulity seems to uphold some previously conceived theory of their own. The wonderful bathybius is resolved into nothing more remarkable than a mixture of common alcohol and sea-water! How many “discoveries” of science, widely heralded because of their apparent antagonism to the teachings of religion, have been proved by subsequent investigation to be quite as ridiculous as the protoplasmic bathybius—the precipitate of human error and foolishness!”