In this closing article on this subject, we have to consider the change which took place when the old covenant was superseded by the new, at the opening of this present dispensation.
We have seen how God's moral law was the basis, or condition on God's part, of the old covenant, inasmuch as he would enter into no negotiations for the formation of that covenant unless they would agree to keep what he calls “his covenant,” and obey his voice—that voice by which the ten commandments were three days afterward uttered from Sinai.
The same law he makes the basis of the new covenant. There are many proofs of this fact. In the prophecy of the new covenant (Jer. 31:31–34) the Lord is very careful to state what position his law should occupy in the new arrangement; and this item receives the first attention in the announcement made. He says: “This shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel: After those days, saith the Lord, I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts.” The phraseology of this text obliges us to understand that it is spoken with reference to a law which had once been written somewhere else. When the old covenant was made, there was a remarkable writing given by God. He wrote his law with his own finger, but wrote it upon tables of stone, and had it deposited in the ark. Under the new covenant he promised to write something also; and what was this writing to be?—It was to be his law—the same document which he wrote before. But this time he was to write it in the hearts of his people, instead of upon tables of stone.
But was not this law kept under the old dispensation? and was it not written in the hearts of the people then as well as now? and where, then, is the difference? Some, undoubtedly, like David, could exclaim during that time, “Oh! how love I thy law,” and “The law of the Lord is perfect, converting the soul;” but the Jewish people largely regarded it as an external code, with the letter of which they must scrupulously comply, but with the spirit of which they need not be so much concerned; whereas when a person has the law written in his heart, he regards it as an internal standard reaching the thoughts and intents of the heart; he has respect to the spirit as well as the letter, and realizes, as the Saviour taught, that to cherish hate is to be guilty of murder, and to harbor impure thoughts and sensual desires is to violate the law of chastity. Obedience becomes true because prompted by love; but it is the same law that is obeyed all the while, only under the new covenant it is more fully and spiritually obeyed than before.
The proposition now before us is further confirmed by some prophecies concerning Christ, the minister of the new covenant. David, speaking of the spirit with which Christ would come into the world to do away with the types and offerings going before, expresses it in these words: “Sacrifice and offering thou didst not desire. . . . Then said I, Lo, I come; in the volume of the book it is written of me, I delight to do thy will, O my God; yea, thy law is within my heart.” There can be no question, in view of this testimony, as to what law was enshrined in the Saviour's heart. It was not the law of sacrifices and typical offerings; for God no longer desired nor required them; but it was God's moral law, which was an embodiment of his “will.”
Again, in Isa. 42:21, the prophet, speaking of the future work of Christ, said: “The Lord is well pleased for his righteousness' sake; he will magnify the law and make it honorable.” This certainly cannot apply to that law which is called “the enmity,” which was “against us,” “contrary to us,” and which he took “out of the way,” and nailed it to the cross. The law which, as minister of the new covenant, he magnified and made honorable, was that law which was within his heart, the one which he explained in all its length and breadth, and taught the people that they must observe if they would enter into life. This was the moral law of ten commandments in testimony of the immutability of which he “became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross,” in behalf of man, whose crime was that he had broken that law.
When Christ came into the world and commenced his ministry, he took occasion first of all to upbraid the people for their laxity in regard to the law. The scribes and Pharisees were scrupulous to comply with the text of the law in every particular; but he told the people that their righteousness must exceed that of the classes named, or they could in no wise enter into the kingdom of heaven. The law was to remain unchanged in jot or tittle so long as heaven and earth should endure, and all his followers were to do and teach all its commandments till that time. Matt. 5:17–20. Then he proceeds to magnify the law by showing how much more it comprehends than they had supposed.
That the same moral law remains under the new covenant that existed under the old, is further shown by the ministry of Christ. His ministry is the antitype of that of the priests under the Mosaic dispensation. So Paul expressly states in Heb. 8:4, 5. Those priests ministered at a sanctuary in the most sacred recess of which—in the ark in the most holy place—reposed the tables upon which God had written his law. With reference to the transgression of that law, which was sin, they performed their ministry. The law was real, sin was real; but the ministry was a shadow. The substance which cast that shadow was the ministry of Christ for sin in this dispensation. Then we ask, in all earnestness, With reference to what law must Christ perform his ministry, which is the antitype of theirs? Every one can see that it must be the very same law, word for word, jot for jot, tittle for tittle. If it is not, then their ministry was not, and could not be, a shadow or type of his; and Paul has misinformed us. To deny that the moral law of this dispensation is identical with that of the old, is to rend the two dispensations apart, and destroy the whole law of type and antitype.
Thus it is evident that the same law which was the basis of the old covenant, is the basis of the new. But if, as our opponents contend, the law of ten commandments was the old covenant to be abolished, the prophecy of the change should have read, This shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel: I will abolish my law and take it out of their way. Or if the law was not to be abolished, but only changed, that fact should have been noted in some such language as this: This shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel: I will change my law, and adapt it to the genius of the gospel dispensation.
But it says nothing of this kind, as the reader has sufficiently noticed. It says, I will put my law into their inward parts, and write it in their hearts. I will incorporate it into their very being; I will take away the carnal mind which is not subject to the law of God, so that it will be their delight to keep it in sincerity and truth.
But if we take the ground of our opponents, what is the difference between the old and new covenants? The old covenant being the ten commandments, which the people were then to obey, the new covenant is the code of requirements in force under this dispensation. And what are these?—The same exactly as the original ten with the Sabbath left out! The old covenant was therefore imperfect and faulty, because the Lord had inadvertently put a Sabbath into it; so he undertakes to make a better one by giving the same law over again, leaving the Sabbath out. But as soon as this is done, lo! it is found that the Sabbath cannot be dispensed with; for even man's physical necessities imperatively demand it. Mentally, morally, and physically, society would plunge into complete anarchy and ruin were it not for this beneficent institution.
Now, what shall be done? Under these circumstances, men step in to remedy this defect which the Lord has made in the new covenant; and the apostles, or somebody else, give to the church a new Sabbath.
Then, having a Sabbath inserted, is not the new covenant identically the same as the old? Oh! no; for another day is taken, which, as a Sabbath, has no foundation in fact, and no earthly significance whatever, and the Sabbath is put upon that day, and then it is all right! So the old covenant was one with a seventh-day Sabbath, and the new is one with a first-day Sabbath. The trouble, then, was not with the Sabbath in itself considered, but only with the day on which it was kept. And the only trouble with the day, we must conclude, was, that it was the day on which God rested in the beginning; for that alone gave it all its significance.
This is a fair statement of the case; but does it look like the work of the Lord? Does it not look like the short-sighted and blundering work of men, or rather like the work of the great foe of all righteousness, who is working behind the scenes, to impel mankind into every species of error and confusion?
If, then, under the new covenant the law which requires the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath is written in the heart of every believer, how does it happen that multitudes who have lived under this covenant, and who have certainly enjoyed the blessing and favor of God, have lived and died in the observance of the first day of the week? This is with many a very perplexing question. But we think it is subject to a fair and consistent solution. We reply, that these persons have had the true principle of obedience implanted in their hearts. And they have kept the first day of the week, because they have for a time labored under a misapprehension of what the law requires. In keeping that day they have honestly supposed they were rendering obedience to the fourth commandment of the decalogue; or in not keeping any day in a true Sabbatical sense, they have supposed honestly that God's law required nothing of the kind at their hands. Had they become convinced that the fourth commandment required of them the observance of the seventh day, whether they were keeping another day or no day, would they not have immediately changed their practice accordingly?—Assuredly, every individual of them. Otherwise the principle of obedience was not in their hearts, and they were not in covenant relation with God.
Therefore, leaving them with the Lord, who will deal with all in accordance with the light they have enjoyed, and the sincerity with which they have followed it, it becomes us all to look rather for the truth for our time, and to our own circumstances and obligations. Paul speaks of times of ignorance which God winked at, and at other times of greater light, when he commanded all men everywhere to repent. Our times are of this latter character. Covering after covering, which the great apostasy had thrown over the law of God and other portions of his truth, has been lifted off, and men are accountable to God for the increasing light. We are living in days of reform preparatory to the coming of Christ; and we have reached the last reform; for we can find nothing higher or holier than that law of liberty which is designed to develop perfect characters in us, and by which we are to be judged in the last day. James 2:10–12. Friend, you may heretofore have honestly kept the first day of the week for the Sabbath, and have enjoyed the favor of God; but you can do so no longer. The light has now come clearly forth; and before whomsoever it is set, he has no longer a cloak for following the traditions of men.
Blessed be God, for so graciously condescending to take mankind into covenant relation with himself! Reader, are you yet a stranger from these covenants of promise? If so, you are without hope. The present brief scene of turmoil and trouble, and then the regrets, the remorse, and the pains of the second death, for privileges unimproved and mercies abused, are your only portion. In place of this infinite evil, you may have infinite good. Join yourself to the commonwealth of Israel. Christ is the way, and he invites you to come. The promises are of value untold, and will soon be fulfilled. The opportunity will expire by limitation when Christ concludes his work as mediator. Come while you may. And soon in that heavenly city, which bears upon the twelve foundations with which it is garnished the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb, and upon its twelve gates of pearl the names of the twelve tribes of the children of Israel, and into which all who have entered into covenant relation with God, both of the literal and spiritual seed, will have a right to enter, you will realize what an infinite blessing was couched in that arrangement through which God condescended to be our God, and took us to be his people.