AdventAI

“TOO NARROW.”

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 43., November 1, 1887

One of the most frequent charges made against the position and work of Seventh-day Adventists, is that of narrowness. Our specific work is compared with the more general work of other denominations, and a contrast is drawn which is not favorable to us. Some individuals who have labored among us, have painfully realized this narrowness. They felt cramped and impeded in their work, so they have said, so much so that they finally felt compelled to separate from us and enter some field where they would have room for the free exercise of their abilities. These and some others have accused us of being hobbyists, have stigmatized our work as small and very narrow,—altogether too narrow to comprise the true work of the gospel.

We might answer this charge by referring to the work of God in past stages of its progress. Take, for example, the days of Noah. How easy it would have been to apply the stigma of narrowness to his work! And how cramped some professional theologians of to-day would have felt had they lived in that age, and found the coming flood to be the sole theme of their preaching! Doubtless some of those engaged in that work did feel cramped, and left it to enter a wider field; but the result does not seem to have been favorable. Seventh-day Adventists have a much broader message to present to the world than the one which was preached in the days of Noah.

So, also, it was in the time of Moses, of the judges of Israel, of Nehemiah, of Elias, of the apostles, and of the reformers since their day. Their work was a specific work, which, compared with that of other professedly religious bodies, seemed very narrow, fully as much so as the work of Seventh-day Adventists. In fact, this charge of narrowness has been so often made against every work of reform, afterward acknowledged to be the true work of God, that it ought to have but little weight, considered by itself, in determining the nature of any religious work.

But let us see if this charge is a true one, as applied to our work, without appeal to any of the facts of history above cited. Is it true that we stand upon a narrower platform than that of other religious denominations? We do not think this is so. The platform upon which we stand, as a denomination, is, “the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.” We have never heard of a denomination whose religious platform included more than this, except false systems, such as Mohammedanism, Mormonism, etc. On the other hand, there are many which embrace even less. Some have the commandments of God without the faith of Jesus; quite a number have the faith of Jesus without the commandments of God; and others have the faith of Jesus and a part of the commandments. The very broadest can include no more than all the commandments of God, with the faith of Jesus, and this is the platform upon which we stand.

Is this platform a narrow one?—We think not.p. 683 The psalmist says: “Thy commandment is exceeding broad;” this part of the platform, therefore, is certainly not narrow; and in addition to this we have the faith of Jesus, a platform in itself as broad as that of some denominations who are not generally accused of being narrow. Certainly Seventh-day Adventists should come last in the list of denominations against which this charge can be made.

Those who make this charge of narrowness against us, simply show that they are not gifted with very great powers of moral discernment. They mistake the platform for the way. The true people of God have ever stood upon a very broad platform, but have traveled in a very narrow way; while other professedly religious bodies have stood upon a narrow platform, but traveled in a broad way. People have always been given to mistaking the one for the other, and thus it is that the servants of God have always had this charge of narrowness hurled against them. We admit that the way is narrow; it is getting narrower all the time, and we are not surprised that those who leave our ranks experience a certain sense of freedom; but a broader platform no denomination ever had or can have. We prefer the broad platform and the narrow way to the narrow platform and the broad way. L. A. S.