SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 18, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 41.

Read the full edition

SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS.

ANSWERS BY G. W. MORSE.

684.—THE SPIRIT OF MAN.

What is signified by the “spirit of man,” as mentioned in 1 Cor. 2:11? L. A. W.
The word that is translated “spirit” in this text, is pneuma in the original, which is defined by Robinson, in his Greek Lexicon, to mean, in this instance, “the rational spirit, mind, soul, as including the understanding, intellect.” In harmony with this, Dr. Adam Clarke, in his comments on this passage, says: “The spirit of a man knows the things of a man; that is, a man is conscious of all the schemes, plans, and purposes that pass in his own mind; and no man can know these things but himself.” This explanation must commend itself to all candid readers as the correct one, and as furnishing no evidence that man possesses an independent, conscious entity, that is termed by many his immortal soul.

685.—“HIS FLESH UPON HIM SHALL HAVE PAIN.”

How do you harmonize Job 14:21, 22 with the doctrine of man's unconsciousness after death? T. J. E.
The first passage referred to reads thus: “His sons come to honor, and he knoweth it not; and they are brought low, but he perceiveth it not of them.” This is conclusive evidence that in death man knows nothing of what is going on upon this earth; he has no knowledge even of the circumstances surrounding the members of his own family; they may come to honor, but he knows nothing about it. The second passage reads thus: “But his flesh upon him shall have pain, and his soul within him shall mourn.” If this be interpreted literally, can it have reference to man after death has occurred?—No; because his flesh is absolutely insensible to pain, and very soon decays and wastes away to dust. The life principle has forsaken the body, and there is nothing within him that can with any propriety be called a “soul,” that is capable of mourning. To what condition of man can those words apply?—To his condition when alive. In this chapter, Job gives a discourse on the miserable condition of man while alive, and refers casually to his state in death. Verse 21 certainly has reference to his condition in death, and it seems quite as conclusive that verse 22 refers to his condition in life: he suffers physical ills and mental anguish.
We know of only one other interpretation of this verse that can be given with any degree of plausibility, and that is this: In the daring spirit of original poetry, the flesh, or body, and the soul, or breath, are clothed with consciousness; the former lamenting its putrefaction in the grave, and the latter mourning over the moldering clay which it once enlivened. The former interpretation seems to the writer the better of the two. In the Vulgate the passage is translated thus: “But yet his flesh, while he shall live, shall have pain, and his soul shall mourn over him.” This translation is also followed by Coverdale, and others, and, if accepted, relieves the text of all difficulties.

686.—THE APOSTASY FROM WHICH RECOVERY IS IMPOSSIBLE.

What do you consider constitutes the apostasy spoken of in Heb. 6:4-6? J. V. W.
Regarding the subject of the above query, we can do no better than to quote from Dr. Adam Clarke, who comments as follows on the texts named:—
“1. I do not consider them as having any reference to any person professing Christianity. 2. They do not belong, nor are they applicable, to backsliders of any kind. 3. They belong to apostates from Christianity; to such as reject the whole Christian system, and its Author, the Lord Jesus. 4. And to those of them only who join with the blaspheming Jews, call Christ an impostor, and vindicate his murderers in having crucified him as a malefactor, and thus they render their salvation impossible, by wilfully and maliciously rejecting the Lord that bought them. No man believing in the Lord Jesus as the great sacrifice for sin, and acknowledging Christianity as a divine revelation, is here intended, though he may have unfortunately backslidden from any degree of the salvation of God.”
“As repentance is the first step that a sinner must take in order to return to God, and as sorrow for sin must be useless in itself unless there be a proper sacrificial offering, these, having rejected the only available sacrifice, their repentance for sin, had they any, would be nugatory, and their salvation impossible on this simple account. . . . They reject him [Christ] on the ground that he was an impostor, and justly put to death. And thus they are said to crucify him to themselves—to do that in their present apostasy which the Jews did; and they show thereby that, had they been present when he was crucified, they would have joined with his murderers.”