Some one, being asked how long a sermon ought to be, replied, “That depends upon how broad and high it is.” The idea is a good one. A sermon ought to be a cube—the length, breadth, and hight equal. People will never complain of the length of a sermon unless its longitude is out of proportion with its latitude or altitude. I heard Horace Bushnell’s great home missionary sermon on “Barbarism the First Danger,” in the old New York tabernacle in 1847. It was two hours long, but everybody in that crowded congregation wished that it was longer. Henry Ward Beecher, in the zenith of his power as a preacher, often delivered sermons from an hour to an hour and a half in length. Yet I never heard of a hearer who wanted him to stop before he did. But when the Rev. Sylvester Shallow takes a text, and begins to talk away from it; when he tells his hearers what they have heard a hundred times already; when he drones and drawls as if the few ideas that he has were stampeding, and he was trying to lasso them, the people begin to take out their watches after twenty minutes of impatient attention, and wonder if he will never be done.
I have listened to sermons that reminded me of a piece of lath, or an old-fashioned yard-stick—they were so long and yet so thin and narrow. I have heard other sermons that were broad as well as long, and yet were flat, like a piece of veneering. It would take half a dozen of them glued together to make an inch of solid thought. And there is a third class that are high. The preacher goes up into the clouds as if his native home was there. But the hearer soon sees that he is on the topmost round of a very narrow ladder, and he watches with painful interest, hoping that the reverend acrobat will climb down before the ladder falls.
Yes, the cube is a good model for the sermon. It ought to be four square and symmetrical. It ought to have a base of Bible truth. On this should rest arguments and illustrations at right angles; not crooking and curving, now far beyond the base and now far within it. And the application should crown the whole, being just as broad as the scriptural base, and no higher than the logic which has carried the hearers’ convictions up to it. And still further, the true sermon should have angles, sharp corners. It is not a round, smooth ball, to be rolled about and to remind the undevout hearer of his game of billiards or ten-pins, but a solid and solemn appeal to his conscience. A sermon without corners is not a gospel sermon. Our Saviour never preached without saying something that was sharp enough to be felt by somebody.
But though the sermon ought to be a cube, it need not be an opaque one. God has made many cubic crystals. They are beautiful in their translucency. Many of them are transparent as well as translucent. The crystallization is so clear that you can see through them. And yet they are not the less solid on that account. The great beauty and charm of an eloquent discourse is that light shines through it, and you can see through it from side to side and from top to bottom. Everything is clear as well as massive and strong. The Bible, in its practical teachings, is a model of clearness. No honest reader can mistake its meaning. Christ said, “I am the light of the world,” and all his teachings are luminous. He sent forth his disciples to shine as lights in the world, “holding forth the word of life.” The man who pretends to be an ambassador for Christ and a successor of the apostles, and yet preaches sermons so opaque that the common people cannot see through them, shows that he has not learned the alphabet of his mission. A cubic crystal, yes, that is the ideal of a gospel sermon!
But is not crystallizing thought into compact, symmetrical and transparent discourse the work of genius? Can the average preacher make such sermons? I answer, Yes, if he will work for it. Dr. Lyman Beecher, when asked by a student at Lane Seminary how long it took him to prepare his sermon on The Moral Government of God, replied, “Forty years.” His meaning was that he had been studying the subject from the beginning of his ministry, and writing and rewriting it. He gathered material in all directions. He arranged it. He condensed it. He formulated propositions and pruned them, so that the maximum of thought would be expressed in the minimum of words. He sought for illustrations, and he pressed all the verbiage out of them, so that they were as compact as his arguments. In this way he made a sermon so comprehensive that it seemed to exhaust one of the grandest of themes, and yet so clear in its style that a child could understand it.
Soon after Dr. Archibald Alexander moved to Princeton, and while he was yet a stranger in that region, he went out one Sabbath afternoon to preach in a school-house where the theological students had been keeping up a service. He preached one of his cubic crystal sermons—giving the results of years of thought and study in his inimitably simple style. And one of the rustic hearers said: “I liked that old man. He is not learned like those seminary fellows who generally preach here, but I could understand every word that he said, and I can remember more of that sermon than of any other that I ever heard.” What higher encomium could have been uttered than that?
Condensing and crystallizing is hard work. I have often watched “a press gang,” as we call our itinerant balers, baling hay. They want to crowd the stack into one third of the space it occupies. They tramp, tramp, and then they apply horse power. It is the hardest kind of work for both men and horses. To have good bales of hay for the market, we must first have good hay, and then we must put it up in packages that are portable. The minister may take a lesson from the farmer. Let him see to it, first of all, that he has something really worth saying. Let him study his Bible, study nature, study human nature. Let him gather truth and illustrations of truth in all directions; then let him bring closely related truths together, and build up his stack. Let him exclude all that is erroneous or doubtful, as we throw out all weeds and thistles in stacking our hay. Then let him say to himself: “Now I must put up this food that I have gathered for my flock into bales. It will not do to take it loose into the pulpit. People are impatient of mere platitudes. They want ideas and not words only. I must study as hard in systematizing and condensing this truth, as I have in gathering it, or harder.”
The man who does this kind of work faithfully, may not be a brilliant speaker, but he will never fail to interest and instruct a congregation. The really popular preachers are all hard workers.—Obadiah Oldschool, in Interior.