MOHAMMEDANISM AND CHRISTIANITY

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 29, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 47.

Read the full edition

MOHAMMEDANISM AND CHRISTIANITY.

The assertion that Mohammedanism is advancing more rapidly than Christianity in Asia and Africa, has often been made of late years, but when it was repeated a short time ago in the English Congress, by a dignitary of the Church, it was received with surprise and anger.
The speaker was the Rev. Isaac Taylor, Canon of York, and his exact declaration was that “in Asia and Africa, Islam, as a missionary religion, is more successful than Christianity, and our efforts to convert the Mohammedans have failed.” Having since the Congress been challenged to prove these statements and produce the facts to sustain his generalizations, Canon Taylor now answers his critics and questioners through the London Times.
He points out that according to the census returns, the Mohammedan population in India increased 9,239,062 between 1871 and 1881, or about twenty-five per cent. After making ample allowance for the natural increase of births over deaths, this shows that the conversion of heathen and Christians to Mohammedanism had been going on at the rate of 600,000 a year. During the same period the conversions to Christianity barely amounted to one tenth of that number.
Yet the Mohammedans have no paid missionaries and no organized missionary agencies. Their conversions must, therefore, be due to the voluntary efforts of individuals and the intrinsic attractions of their faith. Meanwhile the Christians, on the other hand, have all the prestige of a Christian governing power, and are expending vast sums on proselytism, for which they have a long-established and carefully methodized system of missionary effort. Of the total number of conversions to Christianity, too, all, except a comparatively small part, are in the extreme south of the Madras Presidency, where Christianity obtained a firm footing at a very remote period, and the Christians are more numerous than anywhere else in India. Canon Taylor also finds as a “startling result” that four fifths of the Christian converts are Roman Catholics.
In the northern and central provinces, where Islam is strong and the conversions to Mohammedanism are at the rate of half a million a year, the conversions to Christianity, to use his words, “are practically nil.” The most active and powerful of the English missionary societies at work in India is the Church Missionary Society, according to whose report 841 missionaries and native agents, employed at a cost of toward $250,000, made last year only 297 converts out of a population of 220,000,000 in these provinces, if the number of genuine converts be measured by the number of adult baptisms. Of these converts, only seventeen seem to have been Mohammedans, out of a Mohammedan population of 55,000,000, and some of them were very suspicious, as, in fact, conversions from Islam almost invariably are.
Then he turns to countries distinctively Mohammedan, and in the four missionary fields of Persia, Palestine, Arabia, and Egypt finds that 109 missionaries and native agents, employed by the Church Missionary Society at a cost of $60,000, converted and baptized last year only one adult convert. This solitary convert, according to the report, was “a certain Moslem girl in the orphanage at Jerusalem, whose conversion,” Canon Taylor suggests, “is perhaps accounted for by the statement that ‘she is easily influenced and requires constant guidance.’” In all Egypt and Arabia the whole number of “native Christian adherents” is put at nineteen only, and they, perhaps, as he surmises, are largely made up of the wives and children of the four “native lay teachers.”
The practical results of eastern missionary labors, in the way of actual conversions, are not more encouraging elsewhere. In Ceylon, last year, 374 agents made only 207 converts, at a cost of more than $50,000; in mid China seventy-one agents made sixty-three converts, at a cost of $45,000; and in south China 148 agents made 297 converts, at a cost of about $40,000.
These are the facts and statistics with which Canon Taylor meets the challenge of his critics, and they are quite interesting. As to Africa, he will speak in another letter, but the spread of Islam there has been so remarkable within recent years that he will have no difficulty in proving his point.—N. Y. Sun.