AdventAI

SCIENTIFIC SOPHISMS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 47., November 29, 1887

THE THREE BEGINNINGS.

AND to begin at the beginning, we shall do well to note, not merely the order, but the fact here admitted. There was—no matter when—an actual beginning, a first start, distinct, definite. Antecedently, there was a prior time when this first start had not been made. The process of evolution, a “process of unraveling and unfolding,” is a process which then had not begun. It is therefore not eternal. It had a beginning. But who began it?

You postulate “matter.” But in so doing you are hypothecating a substance which before the “first beginning” had not begun to be. How did it originate? Unable to answer that question, you make another assumption. You postulate “eternity” for that “matter” of whose origin you can give no account. But this accumulation of postulates will not help you. What is this matter which, impelled by the exigencies of agnostic evolution, you assume to have been self-originated? Make its essence what you will—extension with Descartes, or palpableness with Fechner—matter is always, and is manifestly, the local lodgment, the objective manifestation, of power. “The withered leaf is not dead and lost. There are forces in it and around it, though working in inverse order; else could it rot?” Matter, force, motion are not unknown to science; but of matter self-originated and self-sustained, of matter self-existent and therefore eternal, of self-originated force or self-originated motion,—of all these throughout the realm of the inorganic world, science knows nothing.

When, therefore, we have granted “the eternity of matter,” the theory of evolution is as far as ever from being able to make a “beginning.” That theory requires not merely matter, but matter in motion; not merely matter in mass, but matter in its constituent atoms—matter so minutely subdivided as to be immeasurably beyond the sphere of visibility, and yet matter not within the sphere of infinite divisibility. “The atoms” are “the first beginnings.” But speculation is at fault as to the mode in which, or the power by which, they “first began.” In his panegyric on Lucretius, Prof. Tyndall draws special attention to his “strong scientific imagination,” and tells us that “his vaguely grand conception of the atoms falling eternally through space” suggested nebular hypothesis to Kant, its first propounder. The “eternity” of these falling atoms, however, must not be confounded with the antecedent “eternity” of their origination. Like the “eternity” of the rhetorical preacher, it has its own statute of limitations. It came to an end. While it lasted there might have been seen, “far beyond the limits of our visible world” (by aid of a “strong scientific imagination”) “atoms innumerable,” “falling silently through immeasurable intervals of time and space.”

“Falling eternally through space”—“falling silently through immeasurable intervals of time and space”—but this eternal silence was broken by “great shocks of sound,” “the mechanical shock of the atom;” and this eternal falling came to an end when “interaction of the atoms” came to a beginning. How came that beginning? Nothing more simple. At first, the atoms, silently falling, fell in parallel lines. After that they began to deflect from the perpendicular. Not all of them, nor all in the same direction; but only so many, and in so many directions as were necessary to produce “the mechanical shock,” and “the interaction.” But falling is motion, and matter is inert, and atoms in motion are atoms in which inertness has been overcome by a force external to themselves, and falling atoms are atoms gravitating toward a center. What center? and how originated? Why should atoms in motion have moved originally all in one direction? or why should they have ceased to do so? What and whence is that force which first moved them, which deflected them from the perpendicular, as assumed by the hypothesis?

It is certain, according to the doctrine of evolution, “that the existing world lay, potentially, in the cosmic vapor.” But where it lay before the cosmic vapor existed, deponent saith not. “The fundamental proposition of evolution” is, as we have seen, “that the whole world, living and not living, is the result of the mutual interaction, action according to definite laws, of the forces possessed by the molecules of which the primitive nebulosity of the universe was composed.” Fundamental, however, as Prof. Huxley declares it to be, it is very far indeed from the “first beginning.”

This nebulosity was composed of certain molecules. But nebulosity is a state or condition, not a substance. Like the rigidity of an iron bar, or the malleability of gold leaf, or the ductility of copper wire, “nebulosity” is a word not of matter, but of mode. It denotes a property, or it specifies a condition; but it does not distinguish, still less does it define, a substance. It is characteristic of unintelligible hypotheses, not less than of “cosmic gas.” In this instance, however, let it pass. We will not say that it was “caused,”—that word might lead us back in the search for a vera causa to a “first beginning,”—but only that it was composed. We will not even inquire who composed it. And yet, if it were permitted us to inquire at all, we might perhaps be excused for asking, How do you know that this nebulosity was primitive? or that its constituent molecules were possessed of forces? or that these forces were controlled by definite laws? or that the relation between them was that of mutual interaction? or “that the whole world, living and not living,”—the molecules themselves included,—is the result solely and exclusively of the “mutual interaction” which you have imagined?

What a tissue of conjectures is here! And yet all this is assumed as certain, and is postulated as “the fundamental proposition of evolution.”

But now, suppose it certain: what then? It leaves us as far as ever from a knowledge of “the first beginnings.” It tells us of forces controlled by definite laws. But if it tells us truly, then the law is the controlling power, and has a priority over the powers controlled. Then “the forces possessed by the molecules” were at best subordinate and secondary: the definite laws alone were primary and supreme. But laws never make themselves. Who made these? and who made them thus distinctly definite?

But even their definiteness is not greater than their complexity. And this complexity—immeasurably beyond our power of exploration—is everywhere adjusted to the attainment of a common end. Who originated a complexity so intricate, yet so illimitable? Who established this unvarying adjustment of it, in the very first beginning? For we are now asked to imagine space filled with a frictionless fluid; to suppose that some portions of this fluid did somewhere, somehow, by some means, at some time or other, become “rotational;” and that having by rotation gained rigidity, they can now, by the latest triumphs of hydro-dynamics, be proved to be indivisible and indestructible. Let it be granted. Granted that light, heat, and sound, electricity, magnetism, are molecular movements mutually transmutable; that arrested molar movement displays itself as molecular movement; that the pressure of a gas is due to the varying motion of its molecules impinging on the walls of the vessel that contains it; that the rigidity, or space-occupying power of matter, is due to the formation of vortices in a frictionless ether, and that each vortex-atom is thenceforth indestructible; when the reality of the conceptions thus assumed has been granted, then by exactly so much has the absolute necessity been increased of assigning—at the first beginning—a First Cause, equal not only to the origination of matter and of force, but equal to the origination of matter thus constituted and of force thus adjusted.

Evolution is thus seen to be the measure of involution. Whatever has been evolved in the effect was previously in the cause. To deny this is to affirm that the effect may transcend the cause. If therefore, though in utter contempt of scientific verity, we were to resolve all chemical forces into forces mechanical, all life into chemistry, and the infinite diversity of living beings into mere variety in the play of molecular forces, ultimately resolving itself into a motion or motions of the universal ether, we should simply have increased by so much our previous estimate of the Power which, at the first beginning, was able thus potentially to endow the cosmic vapor.

Matter, force, order, law, diversity in unity, concord in complexity; they are all known to us, but not one of them is known as self-originated. Distinct in character, definite in operation, invariable in result; who made them so? You trace “the whole world, living and not living,” to certain properties of matter, acted upon by certain capacities of force, operating in an invariable order, under the reign of law. You do well. Pursue your induction to the “First Beginnings.” Whence came those properties of matter? those capacities of force? Order could not regulate them before matter received them. Could matter create them? Through all the “immeasurable intervals of time and space,” matter has never created one single atom. Causa causarum: what was that? Whatever it was, you will not be able to ignore it, except by refusing to go back to the “First Beginning.”

That “first” beginning was followed by a second. Immovably based on the deep foundations of the inorganic world, there rises everywhere, elaborate and multifarious, the mysterious superstructure of organization and life.

No conclusion of modern science is more widely received or more confidently maintained than that which teaches that in the earliest history of our planet, life was unknown. Not only was it not actual: it was not possible. Life then was not; but now life is. Life, then, had a beginning. What was that beginning? And whence?

“If,” says Professor Huxley, “the hypothesis of evolution be true, living matter must have arisen from not-living matter; for by the hypothesis, the condition of the globe was at one time such that living matter could not have existed on it, life being entirely incompatible with the gaseous state.” And he adds that even if we adopt Sir William Thompson’s theory, that life on this planet may have been derived from life on some other, the difficulty of accounting for its origination is as great as ever. For the nebular theory, which is a part of the hypothesis of evolution, asserts that all the worlds were once in “the gaseous state.”

“But,” he continues, “living matter once originated, there is no necessity for another origination, since the hypothesis postulates the unlimited, though perhaps not indefinite, modifiability of such matter.” Waiving, for the present, the “unlimited . . . modifiability” thus postulated, it is important to observe the profound significance of the admission here made. “Living matter once originated;” yes, but how? To that crucial question, the answer on the same high authority is given in these words: “Of the causes which have led to the origination of living matter, it may be said that we know absolutely nothing.” “The present state of knowledge furnishes us with no link between the living and the not-living.” But however inscrutable the mode, there is no question—nor any room for question—as to the fact. “Living matter” was “once originated.” Life had a beginning.—True Baptist.