In the fourth chapter of First Thessalonians the apostle Paul addresses to the Thessalonian brethren some words of instruction and consolation concerning some of their number whom they mourned as dead. In that age of the Christian dispensation, it seems evident that believers had but a feeble comprehension of the future of the righteous who are laid away in the grave, compared with the flood of light which illuminates the subject in this day from the sacred page. In any case, the loss of friends and relatives by death is an occasion of the deepest sorrow; but it would be doubly so if no ray from the throne of Omniscience had penetrated the dismal blank of the future, dark with uncertainty, to light it up with the bright promise of the resurrection of the just. Hence Paul addresses to them words of instruction on the subject, that they might not sorrow as others which had no hope. He presents before them the great future event which in that day constituted the hope of the church, and to which they earnestly looked forward,—the glorious appearing of Christ in the clouds of heaven, with the divine assurance that the dead in Christ should then be raised to appear with him, and together with the living saints be caught up to meet their Saviour in the air, ever to remain with him. “Wherefore,” he concludes, “comfort one another with these words.”
But how vastly things have changed since the time of Paul! What different conceptions people now have of what should be spoken to the mourner to comfort him concerning the loss of those whom he has laid in the grave! Go into any of our church edifices when a funeral is being conducted in the modern orthodox style, and you will be given a specimen of the words which are now thought to be most suited to comfort the mourning heart. You will hear the minister tell the sorrowing friends and relatives that the deceased is “not dead, but gone before,” and that “there is no death; what seems so is transition,” etc. Unmindful of the fact that death is in the Scriptures termed the “king of terrors,” he will speak of it as “the gate to endless joy.” He will dwell in glowing terms upon the advantages which the deceased has reaped by dying,—his blissful state in paradise, the higher wisdom and knowledge of which death has made him the possessor, and the wonderful expansion of all his faculties in the spirit world; he will present these as the thoughts which are to comfort those whom this happy change has left in bereavement, and in all probability the resurrection will never be once alluded to.
Paul evidently did not have such a knowledge of the post-mortem condition of man as is possessed by the apostles of modern orthodoxy. If he had, he would not have spoken as he did to the Thessalonian brethren. Paul was an eloquent writer; how is it, then, that he failed to even allude here to a subject over which pulpit oratory nowadays waxes so eloquent? It strikes us as a most singular thing indeed. We can think of just three ways in which it might be accounted for: (1.) Human nature might have so changed since the time this was written that what was a comfort to bereaved persons in Paul’s day would not be a comfort to people in similar circumstances now, and vice versa; or (2.) Paul mentioned only some of the least of the consolations of the Christian’s hope, and cruelly withheld from his Thessalonian brethren those which we recognize as pre-eminently the most comforting; or (3.) Paul was altogether ignorant of the doctrine of the soul’s conscious existence after death, with all that modern theology has appended to it. Which of the three is the correct hypothesis? We will let the reader judge for himself. L. A. S.