AdventAI

ROMAN CATHOLICISM AND PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

By J. A. P. M'Gaw

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 45., November 15, 1887

DR. EDWARD McGLYNN in an article in the North American Review for August, says:—

Thirty-five years ago it was extremely rare to hear from bishops and priests the denunciations, now so common, of the public schools, which, in spite of the hackneyed character of the phrase, have well been called, and may for all time to come well be called, the palladium of our liberties, and the safeguard of American institutions. The late James A. McMaster, editor of the Freeman's Journal, well-known for his rabid hatred of the public schools, stated in his paper that at the time of the first plenary council of Baltimore, only one venerated prelate and himself took the correct view of the school question.

Since that time the opposition of the Roman Catholic authorities to the public schools has become more and more decided. The third plenary council of Baltimore, held in 1884, decreed and directed that a parochial school should be established in connection with every church. Bishop Gilmour, last March, promulgated a constitution and by-laws for the government of the parochial schools in the diocese of Cleveland. In his introduction he says:—

The school is the heart of the parish, and on it and in it the priest must spend himself, and be spent, if our young are to be saved. The school will be held as the great test of success, whilst failure in the school will be accepted as strong evidence of failure in the parish.

An address from the Roman congregation of the propaganda, issued ten years ago, declared the public school system “full of danger and very much opposed to Catholic interests.” The address quoted from the words of the pope to the Archbishop of Freyburg, July 14, 1864,—

Certainly if this most pernicious design of driving the authority of Church from the schools should be formed, or should be in process of execution in any places or countries whatsoever, . . . the Church . . . would be forced to admonish all the faithful that schools of this kind, opposed to the Church, cannot in conscience be frequented.

Pope Pius IX., in his Syllabus of Errors, expressly condemns that system of popular education in which schools open to all children of every class of society are freed from all authority, direction, and interference of the Church, and are subjected to the sway of the civil and political authority. That is just the system which prevails in this country. Our schools are established, maintained, and governed by the people, and are free from all interference or control of the Roman Catholic Church or any other. Hence they fall under the condemnation of the pope and of the propaganda. The faithful are warned that they cannot in conscience patronize these schools.

Now, what is the significance of all this?—It means that the Roman Catholic Church, as an organized body, is determinedly opposed to our system of common school education, and will destroy it if she can. It is well known that many intelligent laymen in that Church are in favor of our public schools, and gladly avail themselves of the opportunity afforded by them of securing a better education for their children than is possible in their parochial schools. No doubt many priests, like Dr. McGlynn, the suspended priest, are willing that the children of their parishes should attend the public schools. But what do the individual opinions of such priests, when opposed to the judgment of the Church, amount to?—To just nothing at all. When the Church speaks, as she has spoken in this case, they are bound to listen to her voice, as if it were the voice of God.

As Protestants and Americans, we need to understand what the attitude of the Roman Catholic hierarchy toward our free schools is, and that there is involved in it a menace of no small magnitude to our free institutions. Of course, the Roman Catholic, or any other church, has a right to establish as many parochial schools as it chooses. But let it be noted that the Roman Catholics complain that they are unjustly treated in being taxed to support schools which their consciences will not allow them to patronize. Bishop Gilmour, in a speech at the laying of the corner-stone of a forty-thousand dollar school building in Akron, Ohio, spoke very warmly of the injustice of their being compelled to erect such a building for the education of their own children, and of having, in addition, to help support the public schools in which they had no representation. Dr. Quigley, pastor of a prominent Roman Catholic church in Toledo, said recently in a sermon, that as God had given the American people grace to throw off the yoke of British tyranny, and to destroy slavery, so he would give them grace to destroy the public school system.

The Roman Catholic authorities propose to continue this kind of agitation against the public schools. Is it thought that such agitation can effect nothing, that our free school system is so firmly established in the confidence and affections of the people that it cannot be destroyed, or even seriously injured? Let us not be too sure of that. There is no such thing as the Methodist vote, or the Presbyterian vote, in this country, and God forbid there ever should be! But there is such a thing as the Catholic vote, and politicians know it. Roman Catholic bishops and priests can and do tell their people how they must vote on such questions as this. The danger is that by persistently clamoring for a division of the school fund, they may by their influence with political parties eventually secure a portion of the public funds for the support of their sectarian schools. This, or the utter destruction of our system of popular education, is their aim; and it behooves all who believe in our public school system as an essential part of our free institutions, to be on their guard.—Rev. J. A. P. M'Gaw, in Interior.