CANRIGHT VS. CANRIGHT ON THE LAW AND SABBATH.
We have thought it might edify the readers of this EXTRA, to have the privilege of reading both sides of an argument on the law and Sabbath question from the pen of Eld. Canright. It is not often that we can find a man who can perform the feat of arguing both sides of an important theological question with such positiveness, and such triumphant satisfaction, and such assurance of success. Such a discussion will be unique. It will be an illustration of remarkable versatility of mind when a man can say such strong things, squarely contradicting each other, on opposite sides of the same question. The Elder will pose as something of a theological acrobat. For the convenience of the reader, that he may be able to take in the matter at a glance, we will arrange these in two columns, side by side, and head them,—7 CANRIGHT IN THE DARKNESS.
"That circumcision, sacrifices, the Levitical priesthood, distinction of meats, clean and unclean, the feast days, new moons, sabbatical year, and the Jewish Sabbath, were all set aside by the gospel, as is plainly taught as any Bible truth. 1. Circumcision: 'If ye be circumcised, Christ shall profit you nothing.' Gal. 5: 2. 2. Sacrifices: 'Sacrifice and offering... thou wouldest not.' See all of Heb. 10: 1–10. 3. Priesthood: 'The priesthood being changed.' Heb. 7: 12. 4. Sabbatical years: 'Ye observe days, and months, and times, and years. I am afraid of you.' Gal. 4: 10, 11. 5. Meats, feast days, new moons, and sabbath days: 'Let no man therefore judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of a holy day [feast day. R. V.], or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days; which are a shadow of things to come; but the body is of Christ.' Col. 2: 16, 17. No one questions at all with regard to any of these terms except 'the sabbath days.' But this is just as plain as any of them, except to those who dare not admit its most manifest meaning, lest it overthrow their theory. That this does refer to the Jewish weekly Sabbath is manifest from many facts.'—Canright in Mich. Christian Advocate of Oct. 1, 1887. In another column of the Advocate of the same date he quotes Col. 2: 16 again, and adds: 'Here, as before, are the yearly, monthly, and weekly holy days, just as laid down in the law (Num. 28 and 29) where we know the weekly Sabbaths are meant. It is evident that Paul had in his mind those lists of holy days so often given in the Old Testament, where the Sabbath is included.' "But it is argued that as 'the sabbath days' of Col. 2: 16 'are a shadow of things to come' (verse 17), and the weekly Sabbath is a memorial of creation, pointing back to the beginning, therefore they cannot be the same; for the Sabbath could not point both ways. But is not this a mere assertion without any proof? How do we know that it cannot point both ways? The passover was a memorial of their deliverance from Egypt, and always pointed back to that event. Ex. 12: 11–17. Yet it was also a shadow of Christ. Col. 2: 16, 17. 'Even Christ our passover is sacrificed for us.' 1 Cor. 5: 7. So all annual feasts were types of Christ in some way, and yet all were memorials also of past events, as all know. . . . Paul says plainly that the sabbath days are a shadow of things to come; and one plain statement of Inspiration is worth a thousand of our vain reasonings. This is in harmony with Paul's argument in Heb. 4: 1–11, that the seventh day is a type. For forty years we have tried to explain away this text, and to show that it really cannot mean what it says; but there it stands, and marks all our theories. The Sabbath is a type, for Inspiration says so.'—Canright in Advocate of Oct. 1, 1887. "We are now prepared to show that the law of Moses, the ceremonial law, relating to the whole typical system of the Old Testament, such as the priesthood, the sacrifices, circumcision, etc., etc., together with those civil precepts which God granted on account of their blindness and hardness of heart, of which we have spoken before, was abolished at the cross, and that these were the only laws there abrogated. Every passage which speaks of a law being done away refers to these, never to the ten commandments or any moral precept or teaching of the Old Testament. The whole typical system pointed directly to Christ. Col. 2: 14–17. When he came, in the very nature of things it must cease. But why should any moral precept be done away there? There is neither reason nor Scripture for such a position. We will consider in its order every passage which speaks of the abolition of any law.'—Canright in Two Laws, pages 25, 26. "We have a plain statement in the New Testament to that effect whenever any of the rites or institutions of the Old Testament were done away. Was circumcision abolished?—Yes; and here is the proof: 'Behold, I Paul say unto you, that if ye be circumcised, Christ shall profit you nothing.' Gal. 5: 2. But where is it said that the Sabbath is not to be observed?" "Again, was the Levitical priesthood abolished?—Yes; and here is the text: 'For the priesthood being changed.' Heb. 7: 12. That settles that question. But where is it said that the Sabbath was changed?" "Again, the sacrifices of the old dispensation were abolished when Christ died. This is plainly declared in Heb. 10: 1–10. 'He taketh away the first, that he may establish the second.' Verse 9. But where is it said that the Lord took away the first Sabbath and established the second?'—Christian Sabbath, p. 2." In Eld. Canright's 'Critical Notes,' published at the beginning of this very year (1887), he says:— "1. 'BLOTTING OUT' could not apply to engraved stones. "2. 'HANDWRITING.' Decalogue written by the finger of God. Ex. 31: 18. Of the other law it is often said, 'by the hand of Moses' (Gal. 3: 19). 'By the hand of Moses' occurs twenty-four times in the Old Testament. Lev. 10: 11, etc. "3. 'ORDINANCES' cannot apply to the moral law. "4. 'AGAINST US.' Which of the ten commandments is against us? Not the Sabbath (Mark 2: 27; Isa. 58: 13); nor any of them. "5. 'NAILING.' Could not nail stone; but could parchment. "6. 'MEATS, DRINKS,' etc. Verse 16. These show what law is meant. None of these are in the decalogue, hence it cannot be that law. "7. 'HOLY DAY.' Greek, ἑορτή (heorteēs), means feast day. "8. 'MOON' not in the decalogue, but is in the ceremonial law. "9. 'SABBATH DAYS.' Which? Verse 17. Those which are shadows; but the 7th day is not a shadow, but a memorial, and points back. Ex. 20: 11." In his pamphlet on the 'Two Laws,' after quoting Col. 2: 14–17, he says:— "It can be clearly shown that there is not one reference in all this to the moral law or the seventh-day Sabbath. On this Dr. Adam Clarke says: 'By the handwriting of ordinances the apostle must evidently mean the ceremonial law.' (Comment on verse 14.) Look at the figures used. 'Blotting out.' That which was written on parchment in books, as was the ceremonial law, could be blotted out with a wet sponge. (See Num. 5: 23.) But it would be improper and absurd to talk of blotting out what was engraven in stones, as was the decalogue. 'Handwriting.' The ceremonial law was the handwriting of Moses, but the decalogue was written by the finger of God. Ex. 31: 18. 'Of ordinances.' Here is further proof that it is the law of ceremonial ordinances which is meant. Compare with Heb. 9: 10: 'Which stood only in meats and drinks; and divers washings, and carnal ordinances, imposed on them until the time of reformation.' Then there was a law which stood only in these carnal ordinances of meats, drinks, etc., the very things of which the apostle speaks in Colossians. Mark that these were imposed on them as a burden. So in Eph. 2: 15: 'Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances.'