AdventAI

RESIST NOT EVIL.

By Jacob Abbott

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 2., January 10, 1888

Another reason why we should not make it a principle of our conduct always to resist and resent evil, is that it makes us a judge in our own case, and a hasty judge, too; so that, in mistaking fancied injuries for real ones, or accidental encroachments on our rights for those that are willful or intended, we punish the innocent instead of the guilty; or, in cases where real wrong is intended, and the wrong-doer may really deserve some punishment, by not considering properly the extenuating circumstances, we punish him more than he deserves. The world is full of trouble occasioned by mistakes which people make in their resentments—resenting innocent things through a misunderstanding, or making a great deal out of very little by a hasty and impetuous judgment.

A man in a great city provided himself with a revolver, and declared that if any burglar attempted to get into his house he would shoot him on the spot. He had a right, he said, to shoot a burglar. Perhaps it is not to be denied that he had such a right. Not very long afterward he heard, about midnight, a noise at his door. He crept to the parlor window, which projected a little, and saw from it a man at the front door, at work upon the lock, trying, apparently, to get in. He immediately raised the window and fired, aiming low, as he did not really wish to kill the burglar,p. 21 but only to wound him in the legs. The man sank down upon the stone step with a groan, while the gentleman, with his revolver still in his hand, shouted out to the police.

On going down to the door when the policeman came, the gentleman found that the supposed burglar was one of his neighbors, who lived in the same row, and in coming home late at night had mistaken the door, the houses in the row being all alike.

Now, such a case as this, under precisely these circumstances, is doubtless rare, though we very frequently receive accounts in the papers of innocent people being shot by persons who arm themselves with pistols and are always ready to use them promptly to resist aggression. But the world is full of cases which in all essential points are precisely analogous to this—that is, where persons acting hastily, in the resentment or resistance of supposed wrong, make mistakes and punish the innocent instead of the guilty. A boy sees another boy running off with his ball. He is angry, and throws a stone at him, not stopping to consider that perhaps the boy has made a mistake and thought it was his own ball. A person fails to receive a letter which he expects. He at once, in his own mind, charges his correspondent with neglect, without stopping at all to ascertain whether peculiar circumstances might not have caused the delay, or whether a letter may not have miscarried. A lady fails to receive a call which she had a right to expect, or an invitation, and she at once decides that a slight is intended, and begins immediately to devise some mode of retaliation. Thus a very large portion of the alienations, heart-burnings, and quarrels which fill the world arise from this hasty resenting of acts of supposed hostility because the law of prompt and ready resistance to wrong does not allow us the time to ascertain the true character of an apparent aggression. In other words, we are all continually shooting imaginary burglars.

There is one more reason why the principle of promptness in resenting and punishing injuries is wrong, and that is, that even where there is no mistake about the facts of the case, there is often a very honest difference of opinion about the right interpretation of them. The transactions which give rise to conflicting interests among men are very complicated. Each case has various aspects, and no two men—considering the limited powers and capacities of the human mind, and especially in view of the bias by which we are all more or less blinded when our own interests are involved—can ever see the same transaction from the same point of view. The man, therefore, who is doing what, to us, seems clearly wrong, may, from the aspect which the affair presents to his mind, honestly think that he is right. A sudden and resentful resistance on our part is the way, not to lead him to look at the subject from our point of view, but to fix him obstinately and perhaps furiously in his own.

And even where a man is acting clearly under the influence of angry and malignant passion, to meet him with a calm and forbearing spirit, without returning blow for blow or injury for injury, is the best way to soothe his disordered mind and bring him back to reason. It is an ancient proverb that anger is a short insanity, and this is much more literally true than is generally supposed. A great deal of the depravity of men is so connected with, or even dependent upon, a morbid condition, and perhaps actual malformation of the brain, generally perhaps functional, but often even organic, that it is a serious question with some moralists whether all crime ought not to be regarded and treated as insanity. There is no question that all outbursts of bad passion ought to be so treated in private dealings between man and man. When, therefore, we encounter an “ugly man,” we must regard his ugliness as a disease; and, instead of bristling up in angry resistance against it, we must consider calmly what is the best mode by which it can be cured.

This is what Jesus meant by the precept which he expressed so tersely, we might almost say paradoxically—“Whosoever shall smite thee on the right cheek, turn to him the other also.” That is, when you receive, or think you receive, a sudden injury, do not fall into a sudden passion of resentment and retaliation. Be quiet and calm till you can consider what is best to be done. Perhaps the wrong-doer will repeat the injury through your forbearance. Let him do it if he will. Your not being eager to prevent him from doing it will often be your best protection; but if he should repeat the injury, you would better suffer the double wrong than to commit a wrong yourself by haste and inconsideration. Act mercifully and forbearingly with men in all your dealings with them. Make allowance for their errors and faults by considering how liable all men are, not only to be mistaken as to facts, but also to err in the interpretation of them. And even in the case of passion and crime, consider how much the circumstances in which the wrong-doer is placed, the training which he has received in the life in which his lot has been cast, and even his bodily organization, may have to do with his excesses, and do not allow feelings of anger or resentment to rise in your mind, nor eagerly and suddenly take measures to prevent a repetition of the wrong.

We must remember, however, that this principle of non-resistance to wrong-doing, though stated, like all of the other precepts of Jesus, in absolute and unqualified terms, is, like all the others, to be interpreted in accordance with the dictates of sound judgment and common sense, and not to be carried to absurd extremes. Jesus announced the precept in a broad and unqualified manner, but that he did not intend it to be carried to an absurd or extravagant extent is abundantly obvious. Paul, when he was in danger of his life before a Jewish tribunal, did not quietly submit, but appealed to Cæsar for protection; and when an insolent official commanded him to be smitten on the mouth, instead of receiving the insult and the blows without complaint, exclaimed indignantly, “God shall smite thee, thou whited wall: for sittest thou to judge me after the law, and commandest me to be smitten contrary to the law!” This was a case for resistance against wrong, and such cases constantly occur. As is the case with all other precepts of moral duty addressed to rational beings, the exercise of sound judgment, discrimination, and sometimes of great tact and a deep knowledge of human nature, are required to determine questions in respect to the proper application of it. But, when thus understood and thus applied, it is admirable in its working; while the old principle—the one which was almost universally enjoined and acted upon in the world before Jesus came; namely, that a man must stand up squarely and inflexibly upon what he supposes to be his rights, resisting promptly every aggression, returning blow for blow—is condemned as decidedly by the principles of a sound philosophy as it is by the authority of Jesus. In other words, it is as unreasonable as it is unchristian. Instead, therefore, of saying, as so many do, that this precept, though beautiful in theory, is impracticable in such a world as this, we ought to see that its chief excellence consists in the facility with which it can be obeyed and the beneficence of its operation.—Jacob Abbott.