Aided by a few words of explanation, our readers will be much edified as they read the following arraignment of the arguments for Sunday-keeping, taken from the Cincinnati Commercial Gazette, of Jan. 1, 1888. The explanation is this: A correspondent of the Herald and Presbyter, writing from Kansas, asked the corresponding editor of that paper, “C. E. B.,” the following question:—
“By whose authority was the Sabbath changed from the seventh to the first day of the week? Do we who keep the first day, violate the fourth commandment, either in spirit or letter? The Seventh-day Adventists, who have been preaching here, say that the change was not made until the third or fourth century, and by Roman Catholic authority.”
To this the said “C. E. B.” undertakes an extensive answer, accusing the early Christians who kept the Sabbath of being a few troublesome Judaizers, whose testimony was set aside by the apostle Paul; alleging that it was only the proportion of time, after all, that was required, and not the particular day; then that the Lord met with his disciples on the first day of the week, he declaring that he was its Lord, and they calling it “the Lord’s day;” and, finally, that since the time of Constantine, A. D., 321, at least, it has been observed by the followers of Christ.
It is this argument of the Herald and Presbyter which the Gazette takes in hand, with ponderous logic and often stinging sarcasm; and from this reply of the Gazette we make the following extracts:—
“Such was the church of the disciples of Jesus, which is lightly wiped out as ‘a few Judaizing Christians,’ who ‘were always troubling the apostolic church’ with the things of the law which God spake by Moses, whose chief troublesome notion was the Sabbath. . . . The learned editor then pronounces the generally shifting property of the commandment:—
The Sabbath was made for man. He needs to rest one day in seven. He also needs that seventh day for worship—for attending to the interests of the soul. The particular time is not the essential thing in the institution of the Sabbath, but the proportion of time.”
“This may be better than God’s commandment, but it is different. That is distinguished from the other nine by giving the reason, and the reason fixes the seventh day and is not shifty. It is unalterably fixed to the six days’ work of the Creator:—
For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day and hallowed it.”
“Hallowed it,” i. e., made it holy time, on which to do any work is a mortal sin; not because it trenches on man’s need of rest, but because it is a “desecration” of God’s holy time. Therefore, “the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” Not that day or some other day; not man’s Sabbath, because the Creator winds him up to run just six days in all circumstances; but the seventh day, “the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” Therefore, “thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy man servant, nor thy maid servant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates.”
“The commandment does in terms make ‘the particular time the essential thing in the institution of the Sabbath,’ and it has nothing of ‘the proportion of time.’ . . .
“This is not to contend that C. E. B.’s dictum is not better [!] than the Sabbath commandment, but to note that the two are opposed and are not interchangeable. Also, to note that when he knocks off as troublesome Judaizing Christians all those who kept to the Sabbath commandment and the rest of the law as given through Moses, he knocks off the church of the disciples of Jesus, and a long period of the life of the church which is thought nearest to the life and light of Jesus. . . .
“God fixed the seventh day as the Sabbath, and gave his reason for it, which is not the reason given by C. E. B., although his may be better [!]. But even if it were merely for rest to man from work, or for a day to resume the ‘interests of the soul,’ a fixed day would be requisite. Else every man might say he would take the seventh of time according to his body and soul occasions, and in the absence of uniformity the Sabbath would disappear.”
“The learned editor, having knocked off the church founded by the disciples of Jesus, and the continuing chief apostolic church for a century or two, by his own fearful dictum, comes down to answer his inquirer’s question: ‘By whose authority was the Sabbath changed from the seventh to the first day of the week?’ He says of Jesus:—
The Saviour, while conforming to the law and customs of the old dispensation to a certain extent, came to introduce a new, a higher, a more spiritual dispensation. He declared that he was Lord of the Sabbath. He arose from the dead on the first day of the week. He met his disciples on that day again and again, between his resurrection and his ascension. They called it the Lord’s day, and on it were accustomed to assemble for worship and the celebration of the Lord’s Supper.”
“Many still think the Gospels good historical authority. They show that Jesus kept the law of Moses in every particular. When the Pharisees charged his disciples with Sabbath-breaking because in going through the wheat field they had plucked and rubbed the heads of wheat and eaten the grains, Jesus justified it by the example of David, who in stress of hunger had eaten the shew-bread. He was much accused as a Sabbath-breaker, but he justified his acts by their own laws, not by casting them off.”
“He declared that he is ‘Lord also of the Sabbath.’ But does this mean that he had abolished the Sabbath? Does not Christendom hold that he is also the Lord who gave the Sabbath commandment to Moses? True, he said, ‘The Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath.’ But does this abolish the Sabbath, or make it man’s in the property that man may spend it as he pleases? Does it shift the day? Did his rising from the dead on the first day of the week abolish the fourth commandment, or shift it to the first day? Did he meet his disciples more on the first day than on other days of the week? Not according to the Gospels. And if so, did that abolish or shift the commandment?”
“Is it not held by believers that the redemption of mankind by the sacrificial death of the Son of God was the great part? This was on the sixth day of the week. If the commandment has become movable from one day to another to celebrate events according to notions of relative importance, the argument for the sixth day is the stronger. But such argument is to let it slide. The Gospels tell of the re-appearance of Jesus after the resurrection as on ‘the first day of the week.’ They do not call it ‘the Lord’s day.’ And, if they did, would it abolish the Sabbath commandment or shift it to another day?”
“Was it on the first day that Jesus appeared to seven of the disciples, when they had fished all night and caught nothing, when he wrought the miraculous draft of fishes, and then ate with them, and then pronounced his great commission to Peter? Was not that the most important of his re-appearances? Were the disciples assembled keeping the first day holy when Jesus appeared to two of them as they journeyed to Emmaus? Did not the disciples withhold from embalming Jesus till the first day of the week, because it would break the Sabbath if done on the day after his death? . . . The ‘Acts’ have no sign that the disciples were accustomed to assemble for special services on the first day, but, on the contrary, that they kept the law of the Sabbath. And is God’s commandment so weak that its engraving on stone was effaced by their assembling on any day? The ‘Acts’ have no evidence that the disciples called it the Lord’s day, and on it were accustomed to assemble for worship and the celebration of the Lord’s supper. The last supper of Jesus with the twelve before the crucifixion, was on the fifth day. If that supper made any day holy time, or transferred the fourth commandment, would it not be the day on which Jesus held it, instead of any day on which the disciples might happen to commemorate it? . . .
“This is not to question that C. E. B. is higher authority [!] than the history in the Gospels and Acts, but to note that he differs with them, and that the two are not interchangeable. But he then comes down to the authority of the State and the Catholic Church, citing the decree of Constantine, A. D. 321. And by a queer flip-flop of reasoning, he construes the arbitrary decree of that despot expunging the Sabbath, into proof that the Sabbath controversy had disappeared. Thereupon he lifts the matter into the realm of his faith by this:—
From A. D. 321, without any doubt, and from A. D. 33, as I believe, the followers of Christ have observed the first day of the week as the Sabbath of the new dispensation.”
“Here is a debatable margin of nearly three centuries coming out at the arbitrary decree of a tyrant who was a pagan till near the end of his life, and who looked upon paganism and Christianity as merely political means, and in whom it would be characteristic to splice the ancient day dedicated to the pagan sun-god to the new religion of the State. But this fetches the learned expounder round to an admission of what the ‘Adventists’ allege; namely, ‘that the change was not made till the third or fourth century, and was made by Roman Catholic authority.’”
“Herein is the sad case of an expounder who, in a matter so grave as the canceling of the fourth commandment, cites the example, tradition, and authority of a church which he holds to be anti-Christ, Babylon, the scarlet woman, the beast of seven heads and ten horns, and the rest; a church so corrupted by errors in faith and iniquities in practice that it is not now the church of Christ, and, therefore, never was; for ‘the gates of hell shall not prevail against’ the real church.”
“And if these be the attributes of the Roman Catholic Church of this time, with its well-ordered system, its ancient and wisely-sifted traditions, its great learning, its deliberate councils, its unquestioned spiritual jurisdiction, and its wise and conservative pronouncements, kept strictly within the domain of faith and morals,—if with all these attributes the Catholic Church is anti-Christ, and its decrees things to be rejected, what shall be said of its authority in the early centuries, when it was split into disputes of indefinable doctrines, when one part was excommunicating the other part, when that which is now heresy was declared the true doctrine by a Church council, when the most of the bishops were unlearned men, and when Constantine, vacillating between paganism and Christianity, commanded church councils to record his decrees in matters of faith? . . .
“But does all this expounding leave the Sabbath commandment abolished? Does it shift the commandment from the seventh to the first day? Has it all any relevancy to the question? Will the learned editor undertake to declare the fourth commandment abolished and the first day made a Sabbath by the authority of the Catholic Church? The church which can do that is stronger than ‘the gates of hell,’ and they who thus recognize its authority to revise God’s command, and then call it vile names, would better look to those gates. . . .
“God’s command cannot be played fast-and-loose with in such a way. If the first day is the Sabbath of the commandment, every doing which Moses declared a violation is now a violation. . . . If it is not the Sabbath of the commandment, by what authority do men impose it on others, while they adapt it to their own convenience?”
“The first day is either the Sabbath of the commandment,p. 26 or it is not a day of holy time by any divine authority. The attempt to make it the Jewish Sabbath by man’s decree is the greatest hindrance to the formation of rational customs and rules which shall secure that Sunday may be a day of rest to the toilers, and a day when poor as well as rich shall be at liberty to spend the day for their best physical and moral welfare.”
This closing paragraph contains a “dead fly” which gives a bad odor to his position after all, notwithstanding he has so thoroughly demolished the Sunday argument so far as any scriptural ground is concerned. It is the intimation that Sunday could properly enough be set apart as a day of “rest” and “rational” observance, provided it does not set up any claims to “divine authority,” or scriptural grounds, but rests upon a civil foundation. And in this direction many a zealous Sunday advocate is leaning who has become convinced that there is no shadow of proof for the institution in the Scriptures. Give us laws, they say, for Sunday as a civil institution for the good of the State. On this line the heaviest batteries of their sophistry will be planted; and we shall have at last presented before us the anomaly of an institution purely religious, sustained by authority that is purely secular.