One of the meanest modes of lying is by making the truth lie; by saying that which is true as far as it goes, but which intimates that which is utterly false. And while this mode of lying is a favorite mode with the willful slanderer and backbiter, it is not altogether abjured by thoughtless persons who are without malice in its using. It is strictly true, for example, of any woman, that “she is no better than she should be.” Yet when this truth is uttered concerning any woman of ordinarily good character, it is equivalent to a foul falsehood against her. Explicit details of truth in a narrative may be given in such a way as to amount to a cruel and baseless lie. If a man were to say of another, that he saw him in the surf when a companion was drowning, yet, although he was a strong swimmer, that man never moved a hand to help his drowning companion, it would be equivalent to a charge of cold-blooded heartlessness, if not practically of murder. The concealed fact, however, being that the strong swimmer was just then struggling to save his own child from drowning—the truth, so far as it was told, was made to lie.
There is a great deal of this kind of lying by truth telling in social comments on acquaintances and neighbors, and in incidental references to a preacher’s or a teacher’s utterances. “I never heard her say a hearty, enthusiastic word of anybody else;” or, “She never praises another woman’s neatness,” may be a literal truth while practically a lie; if, indeed, it be spoken by one woman of another whose characteristic is a peculiar quietness of manner and of speech on every subject, or who has an exceptional disregard of neatness for herself or for any one else. So, again, a hearer may practically lie by saying truly concerning a preacher or a teacher, “I never heard him say one word against gambling;” or, “In all the sermons I have heard from him, there has never been a single citation of a Bible text in explicit proof of the doctrine of the divinity of Jesus Christ.” It is not enough that we guard our lips lest we speak that which is false; we must also guard our minds and hearts lest we make the very truth to lie, by our lack of a spirit of Christian love in all our utterances.—Sel.