CLERICAL FALSEHOOD

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 27, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 39.

Read the full edition

CLERICAL FALSEHOOD.

AND HOW THE MICHIGAN “CHRISTIAN ADVOCATE” DEALS IN IT.

The Michigan Christian Advocate, of Detroit, Mich., in its issue of Aug. 13, 1887, published the following editorial note:—
“Our Adventist friends are publicly applying the most coarse and unkind epithets to Bro. Canright for having the courage of his convictions in stating the reasons for his renunciation of their faith. He is denounced and slandered at all points of the compass. Meanwhile he holds steadily on his way, and says what he has to say in the most gentlemanly, brotherly, and Christian spirit, leaving his late associates a monopoly of billingsgate and vituperation. The Advocate has received several hundreds of new subscribers for the weeks these articles will run, and is glad to be the medium of sending out the truth to so many eager inquirers.”
Being well satisfied that this was a malicious charge, wholly without foundation, we decided to call upon the Advocate to substantiate its statements, deeming it due to ourselves, if it could not do so, to expose its unchristian course. We, accordingly, under date of Aug. 17, addressed to the Advocate the following letter:—
Battle Creek, Mich., Aug. 17, 1887.
Editor Michigan “Christian Advocate,”
Detroit, Mich.,
DEAR SIR: The following editorial item I clip from your paper of Aug. 13:—
[The statement given above was here inclosed.]
I am somewhat surprised at this statement, it is so contrary to the course usually pursued by our people in such cases, or at least to the course they have been counseled to pursue. Inclosed I send you a clipping from our paper of March 22, which will show you the position we have taken with reference to the withdrawal of Eld. Canright from us, and the attitude our brethren have been counseled to maintain toward him.
[The article inclosed was that written by Eld. Butler, in reference to this matter, which it is not necessary for us here to repeat. Our readers will remember that he earnestly counseled all to refrain from saying or doing anything to stir up personal or bitter feelings concerning any who might go out from us; urging that we should not impugn motives or say unkind things about them. Such a course is wholly repudiated as not according to a Christian spirit. Concerning this article our communication to the Advocate continued:—]
Now, if our people have so far departed from this instruction as to justify the statements of the foregoing paragraph, we are greatly interested to learn the particulars of the matter. You would not, of course, utter so grave charges against any denomination without evidence upon which to base them. You will therefore oblige me by sending me in the inclosed prepaid return envelope, specimens of the “billingsgate,” “vituperation,” “slanders,” and “coarse epithets” which you say S. D. Adventists are “publicly” applying to Eld. Canright, together with the names of the persons by whom, and the places where, the offenses have been committed.
Yours truly,
URIAH SMITH, Editor REVIEW AND HERALD.
Waiting two weeks, and receiving no reply, we wrote again as follows:—
Battle Creek, Mich., Aug. 31, 1887.
J. H. Potts, D. D., Editor Michigan “Christian Advocate.”
DEAR SIR: The 17th of this month I addressed you a note in reference to an item which appeared in your paper of Aug. 13, 1887, requesting you to give me specimens of the “billingsgate,” “vituperation,” “slanders,” and “coarse epithets,” which you charged that S. D. Adventists were “publicly” applying to Eld. Canright. As yet I hear nothing from you on the subject, although my letter contained a stamped envelope for reply. Certainly it ought not to take more than two weeks to get a letter from Detroit to Battle Creek, provided you have the evidence at hand to support your statements. If you have no such evidence, the delay can easily be accounted for. How, then, shall I interpret your silence? Is it a confession that you have without cause or provocation uttered harsh and untruthful charges against a Christian denomination of whom Eld. Canright himself says, that, in humility, piety, and devotion to the service of God, they will compare favorably with any denomination in the land?
I hereby reiterate the request of my former letter, and await an early reply. Yours truly.
Waiting twelve days more, and receiving no reply, we addressed another note to the Advocate, as follows:—
Battle Creek, Mich., Sept. 12, 1887.
J. H. Potts, D. D., Editor Michigan “Christian Advocate.”
DEAR SIR: Receiving no reply to my communication of Aug. 31, relative to the “billingsgate,” “vituperation,” “slanders,” and “coarse epithets,” which you in your paper of Aug. 13, 1887, accused S. D. Adventists of “publicly” applying to D. M. Canright, I take occasion to write you once more concerning the matter. I pronounce your statements false and slanderous, and call upon you to retract or to present the proof to sustain them, which I have already twice called upon you for, and you have refused to give. You greatly miscalculate if you imagine you can dispose of this matter by adding to a violation of Christian fairness a breach of common courtesy, and passing it by in silent contempt. If you persist in this course, justice will demand that you be published to the world as a willful vilifier and slanderer of an innocent people.
The next number of our paper does not go to press till Sunday, the 18th, which will give you ample time to respond if you have any desire to attempt a vindication of your course. Yours truly.
By dint of this perseverance, we succeeded in drawing out, Sept. 14, the following response:—
Saginaw City, Sept. 14, 1887.
Rev. Uriah Smith,
Battle Creek.
DEAR SIR: Your personal letter to me has been forwarded here. I did not write the paragraph to which you allude. Have been out of the city at camp-meetings and the conferences almost constantly. Did not see the paragraph until after the paper was printed. No one intended to misrepresent your people, however. The party writing the paragraph did so upon what he believed to be reliable information. Very respectfully,
JAMES H. POTTS,
Editor Michigan “Christian Advocate.”
This letter, as the reader will perceive, contains nothing whatever to meet the circumstances of the case—no intimation that they might possibly have been misinformed in the matter, no expression of any purpose to look the matter up to ascertain the facts in the case, and no promise to make any amends if it should be found that the charge was not well founded.
Under date of Sept. 19, we wrote again, this time to the Methodist Publishing Company, Detroit, Mich., as follows:—
Battle Creek, Mich., Sept. 19, 1887.
To the Managing Editor of the Michigan “Christian Advocate,” Detroit, Mich.,
DEAR SIR: For more than a month I have been trying to secure some information or some satisfaction from your office respecting an editorial paragraph which appeared in your paper of Aug. 13, accusing S. D. Adventists of publicly following Eld. Canright with “billingsgate,” “vituperation,” “slanders,” and “coarse epithets” because he has renounced his former faith. To my first communication, under date of Aug. 17, no attention whatever was paid. I have since written twice, addressing the editor, Mr. Potts, by name. To one of these he has responded, treating the communication as merely a personal letter, and disclaiming for himself any responsibility in the matter, on the plea of absence from the office. This does not meet the issue at all, nor furnish any of the satisfaction which we require. I therefore make one more attempt to reach the responsible party in this transaction, if he can be found. The charge will stand as a base calumny until it is proved. If it cannot be proved, it must be retracted or exposed.
Awaiting an immediate reply, I remain,
Yours truly.
Waiting till it is evident that no reply is intended to these repeated requests, we now lay the matter before the public. We have given the Advocate more than a month to produce its testimony, or to look it up, if it was not at hand, to substantiate its slanderous charge. The malicious nature of this attempt is now apparent. In no way could a denomination be put in a worse light before the public, than to be represented as hurling billingsgate (“foul or profane language.”—Webster), vituperation and coarse epithets after a man because he had renounced their faith. Any people who would do this, would not be worthy of the Christian name. And in this light the Advocate would evidently like to have us stand, to cut off our influence and break down our work. But S. D. Adventists have done nothing of the kind. The facts are that none of our papers, except the REVIEW, have made any mention whatever of Eld. Canright’s departure; and in the REVIEW, aside from that number in which he made a statement of his own case, his name has been mentioned only three times, and then only incidentally. The charge is utterly false; and if the Advocate did not know it at first, it has known it since, and yet utterly refuses to pay any attention to respectful correspondence addressed to it on the subject. It thereby shows itself to be destitute not only of moral honesty but of common courtesy. In this we have a specimen of that “truth” which it is glad to be the medium of sending out to eager inquirers. This is a specimen of the spirit which goes with opposition to the Sabbath, and a sample of the justice which they who adhere to the Bible may expect at the hands of such opposition. What good the profession of Christianity will do persons when coupled with such a course of action, or how much patronage a paper is entitled to, while under such management, we leave a candid public to judge.