AdventAI

IS PROTESTANTISM BECOMING EXTINCT?

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 3., January 17, 1888

Catholic writers and speakers affirm that it is. The majority of Protestants, of course, vigorously deny the imputation. The Catholic Standard contained a recent editorial in which it was asserted that evangelical Protestantism is “rapidly becoming extinct.” To which the Independent replies, “There is just as much truth in this assertion, and no more, than there would be in the statement that the United States is rapidly becoming a desert.” Which of the two opinions is nearer to the truth?

The answer to this question depends upon the position from which the subject is viewed; and the fact that there are two opinions, shows that the above parties view it from different stand-points. The question turns on the meaning of the word “Protestantism.” If by this term is meant that principle which actuated the Reformers and the Protestant masses of earlier times, in their separation from Rome and their denunciation of its wickedness, then the opinion of the Standard is correct. This is doubtless what the Standard means by the term “Protestantism.” If, on the other hand, the term refers merely to the organization or structure which is supposed to embody that principle,—the churches, colleges, ministers, congregations, journals, etc., which go by the name of Protestant, the assertion that Protestantism is rapidly becoming extinct would amount to saying that all these are rapidly disappearing; and the rejoinder of the Independent would be justified. The Standard and the Independent are evidently standing on opposite sides of the colossal bulwark of modern liberty, and accordingly each gets a different view. The Standard beholds its front, composed of the great principles of divine truth such as were proclaimed before Christendom in a protest of the German princes at Spiers, and which have, until recent years, actuated the Protestant world in opposition to Rome, under the conviction that friendship to Rome was enmity to God. It sees this opposition dying out, and exclaims, “Protestantism is becoming extinct.” The Independent, on the other side, sees the back of this bulwark—represented by the organization which followed later, and which, of course, is still intact. It cannot claim that the actuating principle is intact, unless it is prepared to maintain that the Reformers and martyrs of the Middle Ages were as friendly to Rome as the majority of professed Protestants are to-day, that they regarded it as a part of the “universal Christian church,” as being “zealous for the welfare of humanity,” a potent factor for good among the masses, etc., etc., as eminent Protestant divines of to-day are often heard to assert. And if it be argued that the fact of the organization is proof that the vital spirit is still there, that it could not exist without it, it should be remembered that the spirit existed first for a considerable time without the organization. And as the vital principles of Protestantism sprang up and flourished for years before the establishment of the first Protestant church, the ordination of the first Protestant pastor, or the framing of the Protestant system of faith, so the organization to which those principles give rise may stand for years after the energizing spirit has passed away. That this spirit is rapidly passing away, Catholics themselves have no difficulty in seeing. Their testimony on this point is practically unanimous.

L. A. S.