A woman, not overstrong, and tired with a year's hard work, starts for a sea-shore resort to spend the summer vacation and get rested and well. She first takes a comfortable seat in a parlor car. At the end of the car and near her chair is partitioned off a select "smokers' apartment." The fumes from within that enclosure steal out and make her feel ill. She asks of the porter the privilege of exchanging her seat for one farther removed from this smokers' apartment. Her request fortunately can be granted. She makes herself comfortable once more, with an inward protest against the favoritism which allows smokers to so nearly defraud her of the better air, for which, together with the more room, she has paid her extra fare. A seat next to her new resting-place is vacant, but she sees a bag and papers which indicate that it has an occupant to come. Soon the owner of the seat appears. He has been having a chat with friends and a smoke in the "regular," not the parlor-car "smoker." His clothing and person are saturated with old and new flavors of the weed. He removes a heavy woolen coat, and puts on a cool "duster." The coat is hung on the hook next our traveler, and the air from the ventilator which she has had opened for her benefit, wafts its condensed aroma directly to her nostrils. By and by, a gentleman from the "parlor-car smoker" comes in, and greets cordially the gentleman from the "regular smoker," and asks him "to have a game" in the little room sacred to the smoking clan; and all the while he is talking about matters and things in general, leaves the door of said apartment open. The woman traveler begs the porter to "shut that door." As he does so, the two men look at her as if she must be a trifle peculiar. They then leave her for their game, and doubtless another smoke, to return in a half hour, take seats on either side of her, and industriously "season" her with breath and clothing to the secondary aroma of pipe and cigar. An aching head and a rebellious stomach almost forbid brain exercise, but the sufferer cannot help starting a train of wondering something after this fashion: "Wonder why the same money buys a non-smoker, or any man, the use of two and even three seats—one in the regular smoker, one in the parlor-car smoker, and one in the ordinary or parlor car, and buys a woman only one seat? Wonder why the railroad officials do not secure the woman that one free from tobacco smoke? Wonder if smokers know how offensive they make themselves to many people? Wonder if they would care if they did know? Wonder if there is anything in 'the weed' which makes men less gentlemanly, as they assuredly are, respecting smoking than in any other particular? Wonder if there is any place this side of heaven where one can breathe pure air?"
At this point her station of exchange for another road is reached, and our traveler goes from the hot car into a stifling little waiting-room. A card in the ladies' room says, "No smoking allowed;" but the gentleman's room is divided from her waiting-place only by an open archway, and almost all the occupants of it seem inclined to the favorite "nerve-soother."
After a little more car travel the steam-boat is reached, which is to take the pilgrim to her destination. Even the "ancient and fish-like smell" of the wharf is refreshing, and with delight she establishes herself on the forward deck, which will be the shady and breezy end of the boat when the steamer turns out into the broad bay. A seat is selected where the back can be rested against the walls of the upper saloon, and with only a few heads in sight, and those of strangers who are naught to her, and who do not much obstruct her view, our traveler's joy begins. "The sea, the opaline, the beautiful, the strong," what a magic cure is it for the headache and the heart-weariness and the temper-annoyance! The breeze freshens, the billows dance, the swell grows heavier. Ah, this is life! What grateful thoughts well up in answer to nature's bounty of healing and of joy! Worth while is the strain of stress of laborious days, if by them one earn the right to so enjoy this glorious summer world!
Just at this moment of content and happiness, the quick senses of a traveler detect the familiar and hated tobacco smoke. There is her neighbor of the parlor car. He is indulging in another cigar.p. 70 He leans over the rail in front of his victim, and puffs and puffs his column of airy contamination right into the sea breezes which were so full of healing for body and mind but a minute before. The glory is gone. The little tobacco fiend gains a speedy victory over great nature's purity and peace.
The purser comes around, and "Is smoking allowed on this boat?" is the dispairing question.
"Yes 'em, on this forward part. There's nobody smokin' at the other end."
"But the other end is sunny and has no breeze. Here is where I wish to stay, and," raising her voice a little, "tobacco smoke is very disagreeable to me, and makes me ill."
"Sorry, ma'm. Perhaps you'd like to go into the saloon? Ladies mostly do."
The saloon! Hot, stuffy, and with a party of excursionists dancing as nimbly as the motion of the boat will allow, to the wheezes of a parlor organ from which an unwilling waltz is being coaxed! Saloon, indeed!
The gentleman with the cigar has heard the remonstrance, and gallantly throws the end of his cigar into the sea, but looks as if a woman who "would make a fuss over a good cigar in a public place," was beneath contempt.
A little peace, and then three men sit near the rail of the lower deck and smoke. And several promenaders come and go with pipes and cigars, and the traveler gives it up; she can keep her seat no longer.
She perches herself on the outermost seat of the deck, hanging to the rail in most uncomfortable fashion, still fighting for pure air.
At last the journey is ended; the hotel reached; the good supper dispatched with an already quickened appetite; and the piazza, which has been recommended as among the chief attractions of the place, is eagerly sought. It is indeed an entrance-way to one of nature's grandest temples. The fierce, hot day is going out gently to meet the lovely night. A broad stretch of heaving sea mirrors the gorgeous sunset sky, and the trees near the cliff-walk show grand and gloomy in the twilight. "Perfect," sighs the traveler in blissful praise.
But here comes the crowd of people from the dining-room, and ten out of the fourteen men light cigars and seat themselves within a few feet of our new-comer. She must either endure the sickening annoyance, or go in out of the glory,—into her little close room, which is not on the "view" side of the house. She is too tired to walk beyond the range of her tormentors to-night; but she foresees that she will have to do that all the summer or lose her sunset beauty. Is it any wonder that her blissful mood is again destroyed when she considers that she is paying as much for the privilege of being driven from the common piazza as these men are for using it?
Men and brethren, ought these things so to be? Is there not a question of right involved in a condition which bears so hardly upon one side, and gives the other so vast an advantage? Why should the smoker be given, or take, the mean privilege of driving from comfort to misery all those who dislike tobacco, even in the most public places? Can any one explain on principles of justice or good-breeding the right of the smoker to render the air of cars, steam-boats, public coaches, hotels, and boarding-houses, and all other places where he elects to be, disagreeable and often sickening? It has been truly said that "smoking is the only vice that all people are compelled to share the effects of in their own persons." If my neighbor drinks whisky, I am not obliged to take even a drop into my system. But if my neighbor smokes, I am obliged, as long as he remains my neighbor on the piazza or other place of resort, to inhale some of the poison he is consuming. There is much to say about the pecuniary waste and physical harm of tobacco-using as a personal habit. But the sole purpose of this article is to draw attention to the infringement upon the rights of those who dislike tobacco, perpetrated by tobacco-users, and sanctioned by those who cater to a tobacco-using public. This aspect of the question has passed beyond the boundaries of taste, or preference, or conventional good manners. It has entered the domain of ethics. The point now to be determined is, in brief, this: Have those who dislike tobacco any rights which tobacco-users are bound to respect?
If my neighbors in the city like the smell of decaying garbage about their houses, or think it wholesome and pleasant to keep a dirty pig in the cellar, I can complain of them to the sanitary authorities, and have the nuisance removed, in spite of their personal tastes in the matter. But if I take a sick baby into the country for pure air and wholesome surroundings, and the inmate of the room next mine chooses to poison the atmosphere of his own and my apartment through the open windows and thin partitions with a nasty pipe, or a meaner cigarette, I have probably no redress but to change my boarding-place. So debauched is the public conscience in this regard that any complaint of the omnipresent pollution is considered a foolish personal idiosyncrasy, to be disregarded as soon and as often as desired. It is considered by the majority of hotel-keepers, railroad and steam-boat officials and servants, and all who purvey to the taste of travelers and boarders, that the smoker has the right, and that the complainant is seeking to enforce a peculiar hobby of his own. The good-natured smoker will throw away his cigar if you frankly say it is disagreeable to you, but he very evidently thinks he is making a concession to an extraordinary weakness on your part, and that that weakness will soon make you as disagreeable in his eyes as his cigar can be in your nostrils.
It is high time that this inversion of the principles of right was exposed to just light. It is high time that the man who uses a public place for the indulgence of a private habit, which is positively injurious and disagreeable to many who have paid as high a price for their use of that public place as he, should understand that he is the offender against right and propriety, and not the person who complains of his pipe or cigar. It is high time that petitions setting forth the injustice of the present favoritism shown tobacco-users were presented to all who now pander to this false sentiment and discrimination, and the rights of those who want pure air insisted upon.
We cannot hope to cleanse our streets of the filth and foul air that smokers and chewers torment the cleanly with. It may be too much to ask that the man who selects the smoking-car for the first half of his journey be forced to stay in it for the second half, rather than to make himself a nuisance to some one else. But, at least, let us "strike" for the abolition of the smokers' apartment in the parlor car, and for unconditional prohibition of smoking in and about the pleasantest places of resort in hotels, and public parks, and gardens, and all the nooks and corners where the non-smoking class must congregate. And let this be demanded as a right; not begged as a kindness.—Anna Garlin Spencer, in the Open Court.