AdventAI

TITHING IN THE STATE OF MICHIGAN.

By J. L. B.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 5., January 31, 1888

At our recent general meeting at Flint, the subject of tithing was carefully considered by the Conference committee, the Board of Directors, the ministers, and all present. It was generally felt that the time had come for an advance move all through the State on this important subject. Reports were called for from the various districts of the State concerning the payment of tithes, and as to whether our people were generally faithful in this duty. We were surprised to learn some of the facts brought out. For example, in some localities it was stated that not more than half the membership paid tithes at all. In others the proportion was better; but in none was it what it ought to be. In some cases it was stated that prominent persons in the church not only did not believe in paying tithes themselves, but openly used their influence against others’ doing so, or spoke against the system. In a few cases the elder of the church, or the deacon, or the treasurer, was opposed to paying tithes. Some of the most wealthy brethren in some churches paid no tithes at all. Others paid but little.

Of course we can readily see how such a state of things would affect the payment of tithes in churches where it existed. The whole tendency would be to discourage all but the most conscientious from paying tithes. Those who are weak and covetous naturally would be surely tempted to follow such an example, and in the end become careless or cease giving entirely. These examples, especially when seen in prominent persons, are calculated to influence our members powerfully against that system of supporting the cause. They tend to injure our financial strength, and hinder our work. Such influences prevail in many places in this State, and deeply affect the efficiency of the tithing system.

We have long felt that evil influences were operating in this branch of the work in this State. The great Conference of Michigan ought to stand at the very front, not only in other good works, but also in tithing. Let us state a few hard facts and figures taken from that most instructive missionary table in the new “Year Book.”

Here we learn that our largest Conference stands thirteenth in the order of paying tithes in the field. That is to say, twelve other States exceed it in the amount of tithes per member paid in to the cause. Michigan pays per member, on an average, throughout the State, $6.95; California, $17.12; Colorado, $13.67; New England, $11.31; Illinois, $10.73; North Pacific, $10.23, etc. But taking out the Battle Creek church, the average amount paid throughout the remainder of the State is but $5.51 per member, while the average in the Battle Creek church, with its large membership of some seven hundred, is $14.47 per member.

Thus it is seen that the average in all the rest of the State is but a little over one third of what it is in Battle Creek. We are fully confident that the comparative wealth of the membership in the other churches of the State is not only equal, but exceeds, that of the Battle Creek church. Here are large numbers of students, workers in the Office and Sanitarium, with very little if any property of their own; also quite a number of poor people who have no means. Nearly twenty families have to be helped or fully supported by the charity of the church. The Battle Creek church pays about one third of all the tithes paid in the whole State. Yet we know that even in this church, whose liberalities are heavily taxed, and whose percentage of tithes is quite large compared with that of others, not all are by any means paying a full tithe.

We have long believed, from much observation and reflection, that if our people everywhere in this country paid an honest tithe throughout, it would range from fifteen to twenty five dollars per member. In the table above referred to, is given a list showing the church in each State which pays the highest tithe of any in its respective Conference. For example, Hillsboro, Colo., pays $21.54 per capita; Belvidere, Ill., $34.23; Lakeview, Mich., $18.09; Fair Haven, Minn., $21.44; Boston, Mass., $10.21; Pittsburg, Pa., $16.67; Milwaukee, Wis., $18.00, etc. It is possible that in some of these instances there are special circumstances causing the tithe to be larger than usual; but in some of them we know this is not the case. We cannot suppose that in any of these churches they would be likely to pay more than they supposed their tithe really was; and very likely some paid little or nothing, thus cutting down the rate per capita. We think all these facts go to show that our statement is literally true, that the average of tithes, if fully paid, would be not far from twenty dollars per member all through America. Indeed, we believe it would be higher than this.

What shall we say, then, when the amount actually paid on an average in the State outside of Battle Creek is but $5.57? However, some of our churches in Michigan pay even a larger tithe per capita than the Battle Creek church. They do their duty nobly. But in looking over the list, we find quite a number of churches paying only one, two, or three dollars per member, and some even less. Shall we not say, then, that something ought to be done all over the Conference to bring up the tithing to a proper standard? Can we treat this important part of the truth with proper respect, and leave things as they are?—Surely not.

In view of these facts, and after careful consideration by the Board of Directors and Conference committee and all present, the following resolutions were adopted:—

Whereas, The Scriptures teach that negligence, inactivity, and failure to walk in the light are an indication of spiritual dearth; and,—

Whereas, We as a Conference are greatly remiss in the duty of paying tithes, many of our members not paying in an honest tithe; therefore,—

Resolved, That we deplore our condition in this respect, and that we do pledge ourselves to be faithful in the performance of this duty, and we will earnestly work to present these duties to our brethren as we labor among them.

Whereas, The Bible evidences upon the subject of tithing are not well understood by our people; and,—

Whereas, There is no uniform system of collecting the tithes; therefore,—

Resolved, (1.) That we recommend the Conference to present the pamphlet on tithing (by Ed. Butler) to every family of Seventh-day Adventists in our Conference who will promise to read it; and (2.) That in presenting this, we recommend it to be done by the directors, assisted by the ministers who shall personally labor with the people upon this important subject.

We recommend, 1. That the treasurer of each church visit monthly, or at least quarterly, every member of the church within his reach, to collect the tithes; and in each case where it may not be practicable for the treasurer to do this work, that the church appoint an assistant. 2. That the church treasurers be required to give a receipt for all tithes paid to them. 3. That at the end of each quarter, treasurers be required to read before the church the names of all members, and the amount of tithe received from each during the quarter; also that he show receipts or cash for the same. 4. That at least once each quarter all the tithes be sent to the State treasurer.

It will be seen that these resolutions have a large scope, and cover most important ground. If carried into effect, we believe they will largely increase the tithe of the State, and bring up our percentage per capita to where it should be. We will not attempt in this article to present the Bible argument on the subject. It ought not to be necessary. These arguments have been forcibly presented in our publications; and we have never seen even an attempt made to answer them. We maintain that the duty of tithing our income is as clearly taught in the Bible as are any of the leading doctrines held by us. The evidences are overwhelming in its favor. The duty of paying tithes is set before us as a religious obligation. The neglect to pay tithes is denounced as “robbing God.” “Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings. Ye are cursed with a curse; for ye have robbed me, even this whole nation. Bring ye all the tithes into the store-house, that there may be meat in mine house, and prove me now herewith, saith the Lord of hosts, if I will not open you the windows of heaven, and pour you out a blessing, that there shall not be room enough to receive it.” Mal. 3:8–10.

These words occur in what is certainly a prophecy of what is to occur just before the burning day. As a people, we have ever regarded these words as referring to our time. All our leading writers have agreed in this. The testimonies of the Spirit recognize this fact, that we are accused of being guilty of this sin of “robbing God” by neglecting to give him his dues. He claims the tenth as his own. “And all the tithe of the land, whether of the seed of the land, or of the fruit of the tree, is the Lord’s; it is holy unto the Lord.” Lev. 27:30.

The Lord makes us stewards over the nine tenths, while the one tenth he claims as his own. It is not ours and never was. The Lord has reserved it to himself, for the purpose of sustaining laborers in his cause who give their time and service to him. We have no more right to use the Lord’s tenth for our own purposes, than we have to take the landlord’s one third which we were to pay for the use of his land upon which to raise a crop, and hold it as our own. How people dare to rob God is passing strange. In the

Judgment day, such acts will be called into account. We cannot believe that any one can really make anything by “robbing God.” It is a losing job throughout. It does not pay for this world, and surely will not for the world to come. We believe it is designed to test our loyalty in these last days. The time has come for an advance move, not only in Michigan, but in every Conference of our people. In this State we must make an organized movement to bring our people up on the tithing. The Conference committee of this State, feeling the importance of this subject, propose to present to every family of Sabbath-keepers that does not have it, the pamphlet on tithing, if they will promise to read it. So all will be without excuse.

Another important move recommended, is that each church treasurer shall visit or call personally upon every member in his church as often as once in a month, or at most once a quarter, and ask them for the “Lord’s money” in their hands. In several Conferences this plan has been adopted with excellent results, and a large increase of tithes. This plan has been adopted for many years in some of our largest churches in Michigan. As it has been in most of the churches in Michigan, the treasurer simply received whatever was offered to him by any of the members, while if they did not offer it, nothing was said to them. Here has been a great loss to the treasury. We cannot think that sufficient care has been used in this particular. Many would pay who do not, if they were asked to do so. With many the neglect springs from forgetfulness. The treasurer feels a diffidence in asking the members to pay over their tithe. Why should they feel thus? Is there any impropriety in the Lord’s treasurer’s asking for the Lord’s tithe? It is a real benefit for them to cease “robbing God,” and give him his own. By retaining it, they bring sin upon themselves, and the frown of God will follow them. By persuading them to do their duty, and pay their tithe, the treasurer will assist in bringing a blessing upon their souls, and will greatly help the work of God. Let such treasurers, then, do their duty. We trust the efforts made this winter will greatly add to the amount of tithes in this State.

We are entirely opposed to the practice of putting persons in office in our churches who are opposed to any of the doctrines held by the body of our people. What should we think of the practice in the army of having officers who were opposed to the object for which the army was fighting? How could we expect success in pursuing such a course? What can we expect but weakness and inefficiency where churches appoint persons to office who disbelieve our doctrines? Especially important is it that all the officers be in favor of the tithing system, and set an example in accordance thereto. The natural covetousness of many leads them to excuse themselves if they have half a chance. And when the elder or treasurer sets a bad example in this respect, it is sure to affect the membership. This practice of appointing persons to office who oppose important points of faith, just because they can talk fluently, is perfect folly, disorganizing in its tendency, injurious in its effects, ruinous in its results. Steps should be taken to bring about a change wherever such a state of things exists. While we must often bear with those who are “weak in the faith,” and we should try to help them to become strong therein, we should never place them in the position to lead the church in a wrong direction; for this would imply that we considered it a small matter to disbelieve important points of faith, and we should virtually say to these persons, We consider your views good enough, which would injure both them and the church. We prefer a correct example and a good influence in the officers, even if they cannot talk quite so fluently. “Actions speak louder than words.” We desire to see this evil practice of appointing persons to leading positions who are not sound in the whole faith, and whose example is faulty, cease in all our churches. It will be a happy day for us as a people when these plain principles are regarded.

As the laborers designated in this issue go from church to church, we trust they will labor faithfully in public and private to present the subject of tithing before our people in a forcible light. They should become perfectly familiar with all the arguments used in favor of tithing, and be able also to answer the objections sometimes urged against it. They should have the courage of their convictions. Away with this weakness which makes us feel fearful to teach every point of Bible truth! May God forbid that we should fear to tell the people that it is a sin to “rob God.”p. 73

Fellow-laborers, we must meet our stewardship in the Judgment. Can men be admitted through the pearly gates, and hear it said, “Well done, thou good and faithful servant,” who have knowingly, covetously, and persistently “robbed God”? Answer this question to your conscience now, and do your duty as you will wish you had in the Judgment. We fear many will be lost because these things have not been brought before them faithfully by our ministers.

As we look over this great Conference, we see a great lack of spirituality, devotion, and the missionary spirit. God is not blessing us as we greatly need. How can we reasonably expect he will while evidences of robbing him exist? Would we reward liberally those who should thus treat us? Ah! we know we would not. We are satisfied that if our people would take up their neglected duties, live up to the principles of the truth, and be faithful in all these things, we should see a far greater out-pouring of his Spirit in our midst. Brethren and sisters, think of these things, and act as you will wish you had in the day of God. (J. L. B.)