The Mormon plea for statehood continues to be sounded, and will probably receive an answer in the halls of Congress during the present session of that body. The Mormons, as if anticipating a favorable answer, have met in convention and drawn up a State constitution for the governing of the prospective State, in which the doctrine of polygamy is expressly repudiated and guarded against by heavy penalties. But to guard against the appearance of trickery, as it is well known that every State, in a matter like polygamy, has power to make and enforce its own laws, a special provision has been inserted, binding the future State to make no change in the laws relating to polygamy without the consent of Congress. In this shape the question stands at the present time.
From all the evidence which can be gathered on the subject, this action of the Mormons is invested with a very suspicious character. Their system of church government is too well understood by the people of the United States to allow the Mormon protestation of honesty and sincerity any weight whatever. The Mormon faith with “gentiles” is understood to be something like the Roman Catholic faith with “heretics”—it is a virtue not to keep it. As it is viewed by the people generally, the question of the Mormon renunciation of polygamy is not one of faith, but of policy. They might renounce it, if the incentives thereto were sufficiently strong, but it is wholly incredible and contrary to all the testimony of history that an entire denomination should have experienced such a sudden and radical change in religious faith.
The circumstances under which this radical change is proposed, invest it, as before stated, with an appearance of insincerity. It is the outcome, not of quiet and peaceful deliberations, but of prosecution and trouble,—a thing which, however it may affect the outward actions, can never change the convictions of the heart. It is doubtless as true of a Mormon as of any one else, that—
“A man convinced against his will, Is of the same opinion still;”
and if any other force has been operating to convince them of the wrong of polygamy than that which has been so evidently against their will,—the pressure of Federal authority,—the world at large is ignorant of what that force is.
To renounce polygamy is to abandon faith in the “revelations” of Joseph Smith, unless the world has been greatly misinformed in the matter; and to abandon faith in his “revelations” is to abandon Mormonism. This no one believes the Mormons are ready to do.
As to the validity of the proposed anti-polygamy clause in the proposed State constitution, and the provision relegating all authority in the matter to Congress, there is much dispute, the majority of the legal opinion, however, being on the negative side.
The Mormon population of Utah, considering the exodus of the past few years due to adverse legislation, cannot be much, if any, greater than it was before the Mormon peace began to be disturbed by the action of the United States marshals; and as the “gentile” vote of the territory, which amounts to considerable, would undoubtedly be cast against its admission as a State, there is, on the customary grounds of admission, no more reason for it now than then. The fact of the Mormon system being a hierarchy, in nature contrary to a republic, and no more capable of welding with it than lead can be welded with iron, is sufficient reason why any claim for admission should not have been pressed formerly; and it would hold good to-day unless the reasons for desiring it were more than ordinary. On the whole, there is the best of warrant for viewing the action with suspicion; and the dreadful evil which would result from the establishment of polygamy by State law, renders it the imperative duty of those upon whom action in the matter may devolve, to take such action as will guard against not only the probability, but the possibility of its occurrence. L. A. S.