AdventAI

LOSS OF LIFE THE PENALTY OF SIN.

By R. F. Cottrell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 1., January 3, 1888

BY ELD. R. F. COTTRELL.

To some persons “everlasting punishment” can be nothing else than eternal torment. They do not consider that deprivation is punishment, as well as pain. It is true, God threatens the infliction of torment; but the final and everlasting punishment of sin is the loss of life. “The wages of sin is death.” Rom. 6: 23.

To illustrate: The State may have abolished the use of the whipping-post; but has it abolished punishment? Is it no punishment to take away one's money or goods by a fine, or to deprive him of his liberty by imprisonment? And would death itself be no punishment, provided that the life were taken away without the infliction of pain? Could the life of the criminal be taken by a shock of electricity without the sense of pain, still death would be capital punishment; because the loss of life involves the loss of all things, of all enjoyment. And should there be no resurrection from death, capital punishment would be everlasting.

The everlasting punishment of the Bible is defined as “everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord, and from the glory of his power.” 2 Thess. 1: 9. The loss of life deprives one of all blessedness. As eternal life is the all-comprehending promise of the gospel of salvation, so the loss of it is the great and ultimate punishment of sin. The second death will deprive its victims of all good; and as there will be no resurrection from it, the duration of the deprivation will be eternal.

Some persons may be found so brutishly stolid as to esteem eternal unconsciousness no punishment at all. Say they: “If that were all, I would not care to be saved from it.” Some have been heard to talk in that way. Such ones must be exceeding stupid, thus to undervalue eternal life in all the joys of paradise restored. The loss of eternal life will be an infinite loss, since eternity is infinite in duration. And here we observe that those who hold to eternal torment as the punishment of sin, because, as they argue, sin against an infinite Being is an infinite evil, and consequently deserving of infinite punishment, can, if they will, find infinite punishment in the death which the Scriptures threaten,—a death without a resurrection,—a night which has no morn beyond it, and no star.”

But to the plea that sin is deserving of infinite pain, because committed against an infinite Being, we reply, God does not measure the sinner's punishment by his own infinity, but by what a finite, intelligent creature really earns during the brief period of his life. “The wages of sin is death.” It is no more than his just due. He will receive no more than his just desert. On the other hand, the righteous obtain that which they never did, and never could, merit. The award of eternal life is a free gift, and is obtained only through Christ. “The gift of God is eternal life, through Jesus Christ our Lord.” This being lost, all is lost, the soul is lost. “What is a man advantaged, if he gain the whole world, and lose himself?” Luke 9: 25.

But while we claim that for God to perpetuate the life of his creatures, that he may inflict upon them eternal suffering, is incompatible with his justice, we would not venture, and have no desire, to abate one jot or tittle from the threatenings of unmingled wrath and torment which are denounced against the impenitent and incorrigible in thep. 3 word of God. These are truly terrible, and will be fulfilled to the letter. Now is our time to make our peace with God, through the atonement of Christ, that we may escape them and stand before him at his coming. If thus prepared, we shall hail his coming with joy; if not, it will be to us “the great day of his wrath.”