If we are to preserve our free institutions permanently, they must be kept dissociated from all forms of ecclesiastical domination. The silent but effective inroad which the Roman Catholic parochial-school system is making upon our established free-school system, is a matter of really grave concern to those who fairly comprehend and appreciate the magnitude of the movement.
The peril consists in the subversion of the foundation principle on which our system of government rests, and the substitution for it of the principle of pure absolutism, on which the Roman Catholic Church is founded. This is the vital point in the matter.
These parochial schools are being pushed forward in all directions with the utmost energy and industry, though without exciting special public attention. As fast as these schools are set up, the children of Roman Catholic parents are being quietly withdrawn from the public schools. A point to be noted is, that the former disputes between Catholics and local school committees are by no means so frequent as they were. The Bible-reading question is held in abeyance. The dogs have been called off. Of course this is in obedience to a subtle policy.
Let us not mistake the Catholic position in this matter, much less fail to understand it. The Catholic does not object to our public schools simply because they are Protestant instead of Catholic, but because they are wholly secular, and not positively religious. He stigmatizes them as “godless,” and therefore infers that they are immoral. Hence the rapid but silent growth of the Catholic parochial-school system which we now see going on. It appears, from a recent statement in a well-known magazine in this country, that there are at present upward of 2,532 Catholic parochial schools in the United States, in which are 481,834 children. This is nearly seven per cent of the whole Catholic population of the country, while the public schools contain not over ten per cent of the entire population of the country. There is but one way in which this result could be wrought: through the efficient machinery of the Catholic Church, and the absolute obedience of its members to the orders and decrees of its government. The money needed for this work has come from the pockets of the Catholic population, and not from endowments by rich Catholics.
It is a noteworthy fact that the Roman Catholic parents who send their children to the free schools of this country are not the ones with whom originate objections to those schools—quite the contrary. Complaint comes from the priesthood and those in authority in that hierarchy. In many cases where parochial school buildings have been erected, and orders issued for the communicants to pay for the edifices and send their children to be educated therein, no special effort has been made to stir up the Catholic lay element to the work; it has been done quietly; and some day the newspapers have announced that an eligible lot has been purchased and contract made for the erection of a Catholic parochial school building. The bishop has spoken, and the thing is done! This is only an illustration of what is going on all through the country. What more natural, as the next step in this matter, than to form these numerous parochial schools into a system, and appoint a board of education who shall have sole charge of the parochial school interests within its district, and shall have no other business; a board which, avoiding the lay element in its composition, shall be empowered by those in authority to prescribe the text-books, draw up the course of study, determine the qualifications of teachers, inspect the schools, and see to it that the correct theological twist is given to the vision of the rising generation!
“At a time,” remarks a press correspondent, “when in several countries of Europe public opinion is in a struggle to rescue common school education from the hands of the priesthood, in this country the Catholic population is rapidly and energetically moving to adopt the parochial school system, which enlightened nations are discarding.” And he well thinks this increase of Catholic parochial schools bodes no good to the future of the United States. While crediting the Roman Catholic Church with certain great virtues, he charges that it has been the persistent foe of human progress in just those matters on which the stability and success of free institutions depend. The necessary condition of sound and progressive republican government is education in the largest and best sense,—the training of the people to individual thinking, to self-reliance, and to mental and moral responsibility.
But that is no part of the system of education which the Roman Catholic policy adopts or intends to adopt. Instead of that policy being founded on the republican idea, it is established on that of absolute monarchy. That is its living, guiding, inspiring idea. It is a power that rests on authority alone, and that, at last, the authority of one man. Hence the schools established by such a power can be no other in spirit and teaching than absolutist, which is directly, thoroughly, and forever at war with the spirit and teaching of free republican principles. Well and truly says the writer just quoted, that under the absolutist principles of the Catholic Church, “people are inevitably kept in a condition of mental and moral childhood. They are trained to obedience, not to self-sovereignty; taught to follow leaders, not to think and to act upon their own thought. In politics, this principle leads to bossism, with all its degradations and corruptions.” By the general withdrawal of Catholic children from the public schools, for the purpose of putting them in sectarian schools under priestly supervision, a wholly different generation is coming forward, that will at least not be in the highest degree capable of discharging the duties of American citizenship.
As one sign of hope in a murky sky, it gives us pleasure to be able to record that both the great parties in Massachusetts—the Republican and the Democratic—have recently and officially declared themselves to be friendly to the public schools and their continuance; and we trust the same outspoken course may be followed in other States, as the self-respecting answer of American freemen to the challenge which a foreign temporal as well as spiritual sovereign is now giving to political and religious liberty as known on this Continent ever since the foundation of our grand Republic!—Banner of Light.