AdventAI

THE RELATION OF CHURCH AND STATE.

By F. J. Bye

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 16., April 17, 1888

BY F. J. BYE.

At a recent ministers’ meeting in Minneapolis, Rev. Dr. Burrell read a paper on “Politics and Pulpit.” A few points are worthy of notice, as showing the drift of pulpit opinion and practice. He condemned the English and Romish theories of church and state as “contrary to the Spirit and teachings of Christ,” and spoke of the “American theory” as “averring that church and state are separate, yet co-ordinate. For it is one of the functions of the state to protect all religious institutions, and one of the primary duties of the church to uphold, strengthen, and bless the powers that be—church and state are co-ordinate, independent, and yet interdependent.”

What he here sets forth as the “American theory” is a comparatively modern notion that is coming to be extensively advocated by a certain class of would-be reformers; but the framers of the American Constitution were wise enough to avoid it. Yes, church and state are separate and independent; but it is the duty of the state, nevertheless, to step out of its proper and legitimate province, and administer protection to the religious institutions of the church! Whence does he derive this important information? Certainly not from the Constitution; for that document declares that the state “shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”

But suppose the Doctor’s theory of church and state be adopted, how shall the state carry out this protective idea?—It can do it only by making and enforcing laws in behalf of these religious institutions. Now, since the “church” is made up of numerous churches, differing widely upon many points of religious belief, it is evident that the state can “protect” only those points upon which a majority of the churches are agreed. And right here we notice a particular institution upon which there is quite general agreement, the Sunday-Sabbath institution; and just now there seems to be a growing sentiment in favor of placing it under the fostering care of the state. Having found that the Bible contains no law, precept, or example in support of this tottering institution of paganism, many of the advocates of Sunday sacredness are now clamoring for the aid of the civil law. And when they secure such aid, which they undoubtedly will, this institution and dogma of the church will be enforced by the penalties of the civil code; or in other words, the state will then have assumed the rôle of protector to the religious institution of the church. But religious oppression will inevitably follow as a consequence. And this will be nothing more nor less than the carrying out of the Romish theory of church and state, and a revival of the papal persecutions of the Dark Ages—that theory which the Doctor says is contrary to the Spirit and teachings of Christ. Again he says:—

It is a question of great concern to men in the ministry. How far may I, by pulpit utterance, touch the great questions, political and otherwise, of the world about me?

Yes, it is a question of great concern how far the discussion of political questions and the like may enter into the pulpit, and yet practical religion and the spirit and power of the gospel not be driven away or greatly hindered thereby. He continues:—

The gospel reserves the right to meddle with all secular affairs which can be conceived to affect the spiritual or eternal weal of men. The making of the kingdoms of the world to be the kingdoms of the Lord is not to be brought about by miracle, nor by placing the ecclesiastical power on thrones of secular government. The world is to be regenerated by the gospel of Christ, applied through the medium of preaching. But no such result will be accomplished by a ministry whose breath is spent in promulgating systems of abstract divinity. It is therefore not the right simply, nor the privilege, but the bounden duty of God’s ministers to make their influence felt in courts and council chambers, as everywhere else. Politics now give way to dynamics.

He then cites his ministerial brethren to the Sabbath (Sunday) question as one great problem which they are to work out on this plan of political intermeddling. The world is to be regenerated by the gospel of Christ; but as the world persistently refuses to listen to the gospel, it becomes the “bounden duty” of these ministers to make their influence “felt in courts and council chambers,” and thereby secure the enactment of laws which shall compel the world to hear and obey the gospel; “for not until this quiet world shall be vexed with scruples will it return to God.” Having imbibed the delusive doctrine that the world is to be converted, these political preachers evidently conceive that the regenerating process will be fairly inaugurated when they secure legislative enactments compelling men to keep Sunday. Thus a world-loving church, having lost the vitalizing power of godliness, is seeking to reanimate a lifeless form by courting political power.

In all this we behold the fulfillment of prophecy. It is just the kind of combination that must result in the establishment and worship of the image of Rev. 13:14. But his conclusion seems strangely out of harmony with the foregoing extracts. He says:—

The best policy is never to be politic, but to proclaim every atom of truth as God has taught it.

Yes, that is the whole truth in a nutshell. It is the best policy, and indeed the only policy that is at all safe to follow. Such a policy, however, would set men to proclaiming the commandments of God just as he has taught them, and would forever sweep away the vain sophistry and cunningly devised fables that are adduced in support of Sunday sacredness.

Minneapolis, Minn.