HOW MUCH OF CHRIST'S TEACHINGS ARE FOR CHRISTIANS?
By W. A. Colcord
In a recent correspondence involving the Sabbath question, Eld. J. H. Painter, one of the Iowa State evangelists of the Disciple Church, called for a text proving that the Sabbath is binding on Christians. In answer, Matt. 19:17 was cited to him,—the words of Christ to the young man who had asked what good thing he should do to inherit eternal life, “If thou wilt enter into life, keep the commandments.” The context shows unmistakably that the commandments meant, were those of which the Sabbath commandment is a part. To avert the plain and logical conclusion from the testimony cited, the Elder was driven to the very, unchristian act of impeaching the binding authority of much of Christ’s teachings. His reply was, “1. The party here addressed was not a Christian.” Granting this to be true, what follows?—We are left to conclude that because Christ’s words were not addressed to a Christian, they are therefore not of authority for Christians. If this548 is not the idea intended to be conveyed by the answer, then there is no point to it. But if such a discrimination can be set up in the Saviour’s teachings, we should like to know how much of his instructions during his three and one half years’ ministry, are left for Christians?—A small proportion indeed! To follow out the idea suggested in the answer, we would be led to suppose that the Saviour taught the heathen to be heathen, the Jews to be Jews, and only Christians to be Christians. We had always supposed that Christ came to make Christians; to teach those who were not Christians, how to become such. In declaring his mission, he himself said, “For I am not come to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance,” and again, “For the Son of man is come to seek and to save that which was lost.” Matt. 9:13; Luke 19:10. All loyal followers of Christ have ever accepted his teachings as of authority; but it has been left for the advocates of error to thus discriminate and draw a dividing line, which if followed out, would ostracise a large proportion of his instructions, in order to shield a man-made institution. But quite a successful antidote to the idea that only what Christ said to Christians is of authority for Christians, is found, we think, in a little anti-Sabbath treatise, by D. R. Dungan, another Disciple minister, entitled “Sabbath or Lord’s Day? Which?” On page 30 of this pamphlet, the writer is endeavoring to show that nine of the ten commandments are taught in the New Testament. He says:— While, therefore, the authors of the New Testament gave but little, if any, heed to the order in which they occur in the decalogue, they teach nine out of ten of these commandments. To sustain this, in enumerating them and giving his proof texts, he starts out as follows:— If you want to see the Master’s way of condemning idolatry or presenting the first commandment, read Matt. 4:10. And what do we have here?—Christ’s words to the Devil. “Then saith Jesus unto him, Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.” The party here addressed was the Devil, and yet what Christ said to him is of authority for Christians, but not what he said to the young man! Ah, when error drives men into such a devious maze of inconsistency, and forces them to invalidate much of Christ’s teachings, is it not time to abandon it, and brand its devotees, as did the Saviour those who made void the commandments of God in his day—hypocrites? Matt. 15:1-9. While we shall accept the Saviour’s teachings as authority throughout the entire Christian dispensation, in their full and evident meaning, we shall leave Eld. Painter and Prof. Dungan to settle it between themselves which is of more authority for Christians,—what Christ said to the Devil, or what he said to the young man. But the second answer given by Eld. Painter to the text, Matt. 19:17, is deserving of a passing notice. He says:— 2. But the party addressed asked “which” commandments he should keep, to which Jesus replied without saying, “Keep the Sabbath.” The Elder seems not to have appreciated the fact that the two answers he has given are utterly incoherent, and directly opposed to each other. If his first is valid,—that because the language in question was not addressed to a Christian, it is consequently not of authority for Christians,—then his second is entirely unnecessary, for if what Christ said on this occasion does not concern Christians, then it matters not what the teachings in this instance respecting the Sabbath may or may not have been. The omission of the Sabbath commandment would not settle that question for Christians, if the instructions there are not for Christians. But if, on the other hand, his second answer is correct, then his first is not only superfluous, but incorrect. For if by the omission of the fourth commandment in this case, Christians are to understand that they are free from its obligation, then the instructions here are for Christians, notwithstanding the fact they were not addressed to a Christian. If there is any point to the first answer, it lies in the position that the Saviour’s teachings in this instance are not for Christians; and if there is any point to the second, it lies in the position that his teachings upon this occasion are for Christians. The two betray the proneness of error to excuse itself, no matter what the law or evidence may be in the case. The Sabbath must be avoided, if not in one way, then in another. If by saying, “Keep the commandments,” the Saviour meant the fourth, with the rest, then what he said on this occasion was not meant for Christians. But if in omitting to mention the fourth commandment, he meant to teach the abolition of the Sabbath, then most surely what he said on this occasion was intended for Christians. But our Sunday friend seems not to have settled in his mind which it is; for he has advanced both, though but one can be true, or held with consistency at once. We are reminded of the old lady who prayed, “Good Lord, good Devil,” for she said she did not know into which one’s hands she would fall when she died, and she therefore desired to be on good terms with both. It is evidently a desperate case, and as many “ways of escape,” must be conjectured as possible, so that “some one of the six” may prove the highway to emancipation from that terrible “yoke of bondage,”—the Sabbath. But obstacles are met on every hand. Taking the first position, its supporters would hardly like to concede, that by the omission of the fourth commandment, the Saviour meant to teach the Jew that he could be saved without keeping the Sabbath; and taking the second, if it be admitted that the fourth commandment, though omitted, was implied, then that most grievous duty of keeping the Sabbath is laid upon Christians! But I wish to notice briefly Eld. Painter’s second answer, upon its own merits. “But the party addressed asked ‘which’ commandments he should keep, to which Jesus replied, without saying, ‘Keep the Sabbath.’” Yes, he replied without saying, “Thou shalt have no other gods before me;” without saying, “Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image;” without saying, “Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain;” and without saying, “Thou shalt not covet,”—the very commandment the young man was breaking. Shall we therefore conclude that the Saviour sanctioned idolatry, image-worship, blasphemy, and covetousness? Such must be the inevitable conclusion, if by omitting to mention the fourth commandment, he meant to teach the abolition of the Sabbath. Some people seem to have the idea that the Sabbath commandment is the only one of the ten that Jesus did not mention on this occasion, when the fact is, he quoted only five out of the ten. Not until our Sunday friends are ready to argue the abolition of the four other unquoted commandments, can they consistently urge the omission of the fourth as an evidence of its abolition. To his second answer, Eld. Painter added the following, “Jesus was not a Seventh-day Adventist, or he would have put in the Sabbath, without fail, to which we might with equal propriety reply that he was not a Baptist or a Disciple, or he would have put in ‘Repent, and be baptized,’ without fail. Did not the Saviour believe in repentance and baptism? Did he not know that these were essential to salvation? And yet when asked that most important of all questions, what should he do to inherit eternal life, he omitted them. What shall we conclude, then? that these are not obligatory?—No; but that some things may have been implied that were not definitely expressed. Those who choose to reason otherwise, we leave to revel in their folly. The Saviour told that young man just what he must do to become a true Christian and obtain eternal life,—‘Keep the commandments,’ and ‘Come, follow me.’ And when he said, ‘The commandments,’ he meant all of them, fourth included; and when he said, ‘Follow me,’ he meant all that those words, in the nature of the case, could imply. O for a breadth of soul that will allow the Scriptures their full and evident meaning, and a heart that will gladly live that meaning out!