ANOTHER VIEW

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 28, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 35.

Read the full edition

ANOTHER VIEW.

Since the four articles on “The Time of the Crucifixion and Resurrection of Christ,” were written, the last one of which appeared in last week’s Review, we have received from Mr. J. W. Morton, a pamphlet on the same subject, with a request that we examine and review the positions therein set forth. As supplementary to the aforesaid articles, we here offer a few thoughts on the view presented in the pamphlet.
It is here argued that Christ was crucified and put into the tomb on Friday, according to the common view. But then, hampered by the idea (which Mr. M. assumes as quietly as any other seventy-two hour theorist) that “the heart of the earth” means the grave, and that “three days and three nights” must mean just seventy-two hours, he carries the resurrection of Christ over to the hour of sunset on Monday, and makes the day following, that is, Tuesday, “the first day of the week” on which Christ appeared to Mary Magdalene, according to the record in Mark 16:9.
Anticipating the astonishment of the reader at such a position, we hasten to state Mr. M’s method of vindicating this view, not sure, however, that the aforesaid astonishment will be much relieved thereby. He contends that the phrase, “first day of the week,” found in the New Testament eight times, has no reference to the ordinary week, nor to Sunday, the first day of such week, but that the words, literally translated, would read, “the one of the sabbaths,” and that they mean, “The first day of one of the seven festival, or sabbatic, weeks. Lev. 23:15, 16.”
We hardly think Mr. M. will find a follower in such a view. Nor does it strike us that he is consistent with himself in his elucidation of the subject. Thus he says of the day which he sets down as “Monday, the 15th of Nisan”: “This was the first day of unleavened bread—a holy convocation—a strict sabbath. The Galilean women rested this ‘sabbath day,’ according to ‘the commandment’ in Lev. 23:7; Luke 23:56, last clause.” “Late in the afternoon” of this day, he says, “just at, or immediately before, sunset,” Jesus arose. Then, of the next day, he says: “Tuesday, the 16th of Nisan. This was the second day of unleavened bread—the day of ‘the wave-sheaf,’ or first-fruits. It was ‘the first day of the sabbath’—the beginning of the feast of sabbaths, or weeks.” Lev. 23:9, 21.
But to this it must be objected that the second day of unleavened bread, was not a sabbath, and hence the designation, “the one [or the first] of the sabbaths,” could not properly be applied to it. The first day of unleavened bread was a sabbath; and to that day, rather than the second, the phrase would apply, if it could apply to either. The time between the wave-sheaf and the Pentecost, was not sabbatical in character; and the latter is called “the feast of weeks,” simply because it came at the expiration of seven complete weeks, counting from the wave-sheaf. It is utterly inconceivable that the evangelists should take the Jewish festivals as the calendar by which to locate the resurrection of Christ, as in such expressions as the following: “And when the Sabbath was past, . . . very early in the morning, the first day of the week, they came unto the sepulcher at the rising of the sun.” Mark 16:1, 2.
Nor is it possible to apply Luke 23:56 to a festival Sabbath? As remarked in our previous articles, we marvel greatly how a Sabbath-keeper can make such an application. The declaration that they observed the Sabbath “according to the commandment,” certainly implies that the “commandment” was still in force; but every “commandment” (!) for every ceremonial sabbath, had then been nailed to the cross. Beyond all question, the phrase, “the first day of the week,” meaning the ordinary civil week, is the correct translation of the Greek in the passages where that expression occurs. And there is neither proof nor probability that Luke and Paul in the other two “first days” they mention (Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2) have any reference to the Jewish festivals.
Those who have read the previous articles, will perceive at once on what grounds we object to the position set forth in the pamphlet under consideration.
1. Mr. M. is misled in supposing that Matt. 28:1 confines the resurrection of Christ to the close of the day. Good testimony has been given from lexicographers, commentators, and historians, to show that the expression there used—“opse de sabbaton”—means “after the Sabbath was past.”
2. He is wrong in assuming that the “heart of the earth” means “the grave.” It has been shown that it means the dominion of wicked men, and the powers of darkness, to which Christ was subjected, from his betrayal to his resurrection.
3. He is wrong in supposing that the expression “three days and three nights” must mean just seventy-two hours. Scripture usage was referred to, to show that the period so designated expired on the third day before the seventy-two hours were completed.
4. He is wrong in the position that the phrase “the first day of the week,” used in the New Testament as late as A. D. 50, refers, not to the ordinary week, but to the Jewish annual sabbaths and feasts.
5. He is consequently wrong in the position that Christ arose Monday afternoon, and that Tuesday was the “first day of the week” mentioned by Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.
6. He must be wholly wrong in the position that the holy women, returning from the burial, rested a Jewish ceremonial sabbath day “according to the commandment,” when all ceremonial sabbaths and the laws for them, had just been nailed to the cross. It does not appear that they would be obliged, on a ceremonial sabbath, to desist from such work as they were then engaged in—the preparation for the embalming of the dead for permanent burial.
7. He is wrong in placing the crucifixion of Christ on the 12th of Nisan; whereas, as the true antitype of the passover lamb, he must have been slain on the 14th.
8. He is wrong in putting his resurrection on the 15th of Nisan; since the sheaf of first-fruits was offered on the 16th; and his resurrection, as the antitype of that wave-sheaf, must have occurred on the same day.
The argument from the types, as set forth last week, we regard as absolutely conclusive as to the time between the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ. Consequently, out of the essential positions set forth in the tract, the only one we find to indorse is, that Christ was crucified on Friday.