The apostle affirms that if Christ was not raised from the dead, “then they also which are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.” 1 Cor. 15:16-18. But if it be true that man, by virtue of an undying nature, simply passes at death to another state of conscious ease, and that the good go directly to heaven at the hour of dissolution, how can it be also true, as stated by Paul, that unless Christ had risen from the dead, all who had fallen asleep in hope of him were perished? Is it not plain that if good men in the old dispensation went immediately to heaven at death, some of them were safe in heaven hundreds of years before the death of the Saviour? How, then, could his failure to rise from the dead deprive them of what they had already obtained through an inherent property of immortality?
If men live in the “hereafter” by virtue of that which is contained within themselves, how could it be truly said they would perish, even though Christ had never been manifested? If one lives at all, even though he be in constant misery, it cannot be maintained that he has “perished.” It therefore follows that if one lives, that is, does not perish, after the life that now exists, it will be only by the power of Jesus Christ. With this agrees the word of truth: “The wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.” Rom. 6:23.
The penalty for transgression was the loss of life, and all that was included in that state. But the gift of God, through Christ (not by any inherent property in us), is the restoration of that which was lost through transgression. Life was lost; but if it be true that death is only a transition from one condition of life to that of another, then there is no loss of life in it, and it cannot be true that Christ gives life to the sinner. For how can Christ give to any man that which he possesses by nature, and never loses?
But if we accept what the Bible says on this point, and believe that when the sentence of death was passed upon man, he would eternally bear that sentence, unless redeemed (John 3:16; 1 Cor. 15:22), and that the redemption from death was to come through a resurrection (1 Thess. 4:16), then the words of the apostle first quoted in this article will carry with them some significance; otherwise, they have none whatever.
A seemingly small error may develop grave consequences. The theory of inherent immortality was first taught for the purpose of deceiving and ruining the human race, and this it has well-nigh done. When our first parents were placed in Eden, with particular instructions regarding their conduct, and were threatened with death in case of their disobedience, the wily tempter came to the woman with the insinuating question: “Hath God said, Ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden?” The answer was, that they were privileged to eat of every tree but one, and that one they were forbidden even to touch, under the threat of death. And now is launched forth from man's subtle enemy, the fatal words: “Ye shall not surely die: for God doth know that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened and ye shall be as gods [literally, like God], knowing good and evil.” Gen. 3:1-5.
This was the same as saying: “It is not certain, as you suppose, that such a dire calamity will follow the forbidden act. True, God has said it; but you cannot think he really means it. He simply said it to keep you in awe, and from becoming like himself—full of wisdom, and having the power of immortal life.” The woman was charmed; she listened, believed, ate of the forbidden fruit, and by her disobedience entailed death upon all the race.
Had man retained his integrity when under the seductions of the enemy, he could never have been robbed of the boon of life then in his possession. By continued obedience, his hold on life would be retained. But through sin, death entered (Rom. 5:12), and man lost all. To redeem man, Christ must come and die, and be raised to life, and thus abolish death, and bring “life and immortality to light through the gospel.” 2 Tim. 1:10. Since the fall, man can have life perpetuated only through the Lord Jesus Christ. 1 John 5:12. And with the exception of those who are translated, this life must invariably come by a resurrection from the grave. Otherwise, why the resurrection? If one can fly to heaven at death, and enjoy bliss in the presence of God for a thousand years, without any body, why ever restore the body at all?
And yet the old falsehood first uttered by Satan in Eden—“Ye shall not surely die”—has been iterated and reiterated, until if one deny it, he is now branded by many as an infidel, notwithstanding to believe it is to rob Christ of the honor of giving life to his people—the very object for which he died. But let us for a moment look at the effect of such a belief upon the morals of society. Here is a man who asserts that it makes little difference how life is spent, as after death, purgatory will receive and cleanse the soul of all defilements, so that it may finally be received into the bosom of the Father. In this case, who could maintain that a holy life is a necessity, inasmuch as it is possible in purgatory to be relieved from all moral disability?
But those who have masses said for souls in purgatory, are not the only ones who teach a probation after death. If after what we call death, man still exists as a conscious, intelligent being, why not admit the Andover theory, and since God is full of love and mercy, and unwilling that any should perish, give to that man who had no time to serve God in the flesh, an opportunity to repent, after leaving these earthly scenes? The objector may say that he does not like that theory, because it cultivates lax morals here, with the thought that there will be ample opportunity for reform in the vast beyond. That is true, and yet the entire foundation of the theory is the presumption of man's consciousness in death; or in other words, that he does not really die, but simply changes his sphere. How utterly untenable is the Andover belief, to those who reject the natural immortality of man.
Another outgrowth of Satan's first falsehood, is the doctrine of universal salvation. Its advocates say: “Man must live forever; and as God is too good and benevolent to torment him forever for the few sins he commits in this life, it follows that after he has been punished as much as his sins merit, God must, in justice, restore him to favor.” With such a view, what is there to induce one to restrain his passions? What matters it, if he does become a notorious sinner, so long as he is to be saved any way? He can endure a little punishment preparatory to his final salvation, much better than to hold himself in restraint here. And what produces such a low state of morals?—Simply a belief in the satanic story, “Ye shall not surely die.”
If these pernicious doctrines are the outgrowth of the sentiment taught our first parents by the enemy of our souls, it ought, by all means, to be discarded, and the true theory accepted. God says of man: “His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” Ps. 146:4. Again: “The living know that they shall die; but the dead know not anything.” Eccl. 9:5. Once more: “Thou changest his countenance, and sendest him away. His sons come to honor, and he knoweth it not;p. 554 and they are brought low, but he perceiveth it not of them.” Job 14:20, 21.
But notwithstanding this clear-cut testimony from Job, he had a hope of immortality. In the strongest confidence, he says: “For I know that my Redeemer liveth, and that he shall stand at the latter day upon the earth; and though after my skin worms destroy this body, yet in my flesh shall I see God.” Chap. 19:25, 26. With all other Bible characters, Job believed that he would wait for the appearing of the Saviour, and the attendant resurrection, for his reward of eternal life. After speaking of the Lord's descent, and of the righteous dead and living saints' being caught up together to meet the Lord in the air, the apostle says: “And so [in this manner] shall we ever be with the Lord. Wherefore comfort one another with these words.” 1 Thess. 4:16-18.
And there is comfort in such words, because they tell us that though we do “surely die,” we may live again through Christ, when he comes the second time. One derives comfort also from believing them, because they show that if we wait till Christ's coming, to be with him, then the words of Satan to the woman, and the conflicting theories that have grown from them, are frauds of the grossest character, and only calculated to lead those who believe them to ruin, if possible. J. O. C.