DAY OF THE CRUCIFIXION AND RESURRECTION OF CHRIST.
HOW LONG DID CHRIST LIE IN THE GRAVE?
THE remarks on this subject last week closed with an examination of the 28th chapter of Matthew. It was shown not only that the language employed by Matthew in verse 1 is entirely in harmony with the idea that the Sabbath was fully past when the events which he records took place, but also that some, at least, of the circumstances were such that it is utterly absurd to suppose they could have transpired before the close of the Sabbath. But it is said that Matthew’s record does not agree with that of the other evangelists, in that he states a number of particulars which they do not mention; and therefore he must refer to a different visit to the sepulcher, from the ones which the others record. But this does not by any means follow. Several witnesses may describe the same scene, and neither of them record what the others mention; yet it cannot be said that there is any discrepancy or disagreement between them, unless what one says would make it impossible that what the others say could be true. And this is recognized as a legitimate principle in harmonizing the records of the evangelists. One writer may state particulars not mentioned by another; but that does not discredit his own testimony, nor prove the other untrue. Thus Matthew (chap. 28:1) says that the two Marys came to the sepulcher. Mark (chap. 16:1) says that Salome was with them. But the fact that Matthew did not see fit to mention her name, does not prove that she could not have been there at the time that he speaks of, and therefore does not prove that Matthew must have referred to a different occasion from that recorded by Mark. So Matthew speaks of the earthquake which had taken place before the Marys reached the sepulcher, the descent of the angel, the prostration of the soldiers who were guarding the tomb, their report to the priests, and the story which the latter invented to try to cover up the truth. But there is nothing in the records of the other evangelists to show that any or all these things might not have happened in close connection with what they relate, they simply choosing to dwell upon other particulars. Nothing further need be said on this point. We now come to what we offer as positive testimony that Christ did rise upon the first day of the week. It is the testimony of Mark 16:9: “Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene, out of whom he had cast seven devils.” On this point Eld. Wardner remarks: “Mark 16:9 is quoted to prove that Christ rose on first-day morning; but he says no such thing. He says that Christ ‘was risen’ at that time, without intimating when he rose.” We suppose Eld. W. is aware that the word “risen” is simply the second aorist participle, and would be properly rendered, “Now Jesus having risen,” instead of “Now when Jesus was risen.” His position here reminds us of that of the Sunday-keeper on Acts 20:7. That text reads, “And upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread,” etc. Here, says the Sunday-keeper, the expression, “when they came together,” denotes repeated and customary action. But the Greek has simply the noun and its participle—“the disciples having come together”—denoting only an incidental meeting. The construction of Mark 16:9 is similar; and if we read it, “Now Jesus having risen early the first day of the week,” there would hardly seem to be any room to question the meaning of the passage. Such is the reading; and such we believe to be the plain intent of the passage; namely, to declare explicitly that Jesus rose on the first day of the week; and no criticism that we have yet seen seems sufficient to overthrow it. Meyer, to be sure, endeavors to throw the passage away by making it apocryphal. He argues that the latter part of Mark 16, beginning with verse 9, is an interpolation by some other person, and was not written by Mark at all. But this is sufficiently refuted by Lange, on the authority of the great majority of eminent critics, who consider this portion of Mark’s gospel as genuine as any other part of it. In regard to the construction of verse 9, Meyer declares that it is impossible to tell whether the adverb proi (early) qualifies the participle anastas (having risen) or the verb, ephane (appeared) as found in the sentence, “he appeared first to Mary Magdalene.” This being so, and the construction admitting of either application, we are thrown back upon the sense of the whole passage to determine which it is. The adverb certainly qualifies one of those words, and it does not qualify them both. We must give it that application which will make the apostle’s statement most consistent and reasonable, and that will be the correct one. We have, then, before us on this point, two positions: one class hold that the adverb qualifies “appeared;” and they would read the passage thus: “Now when Jesus was risen [some time in the past], he appeared early the first day of the week to Mary Magdalene first.” This is the position of those who deny that Christ rose on the first day of the week. Thus Eld. Wardner says:— Mark’s statement is explained by what John says (chap. 20:1-18), who describes a second visit of Mary Magdalene in the morning, while yet dark, to whom Christ again appeared, before he did to any one else that day.
The other position is that the adverb “early” qualifies the participle “having risen;” and those who hold this view would read the passage substantially as it is in our common version, “Now Jesus having risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene;” not merely first on that early portion of the first day of the week, but first after his resurrection; that is, he rose early on the first day of the week, and first showed himself, after his resurrection, to Mary Magdalene. Now which of these is the more consistent view? The answer to this question we are willing to leave to the candid judgment of any reader, who will give the subject a little careful thought. We can easily see that some importance attaches to the fact of Christ’s first appearance, and that there is some reason why it should be expressly revealed to whom he first appeared. But where is there the least shadow of reason for stating to whom he appeared first on some particular portion of the day, as the early part of the first day of the week, especially since it is claimed that he had already appeared to the same party the evening before? If it is so important a matter to tell to whom he appeared first, on the different divisions of the day, why does the record not state to whom he appeared first, at the third or sixth or ninth hours of the day. It would be just as important to know these facts, as the one which, it is claimed, is so particularly revealed. We are referred to John 20, in explanation of Mark 16:9. But let us see how John’s record will tally with the interpretation given to Matthew 28, by the seventy-two-hour theorists. John says that Mary Magdalene came early the first day of the week to the sepulcher, and saw the stone taken away. She hastened back to Peter and John, and said unto them, “They have taken away the Lord out of the sepulcher, and we know not where they have laid him.” This is evidently the first intimation that Peter and John or any of the disciples had had of the matter. So Peter and John ran to the sepulcher. But she, it is claimed, remember, had been to the sepulcher the night before (according to Matthew’s account), and found the stone rolled away, had seen an angel, who told her plainly that the Lord had risen, and then had met Jesus himself and recognized him, and held him by the feet and worshiped him, knowing of course that he was the Lord; and yet, going to the sepulcher the next morning, and seeing the stone taken away, she runs and reports that some one has stolen the Lord out of the sepulcher, and she does not know where they have laid him! Eld. Wardner claims, as noticed last week, that Mary Magdalene went to the sepulcher on first-day morning, expecting to find Christ there, because the disciples had reasoned her out of her own senses respecting her visit to the sepulcher and her interview with the angel and Christ the night before. But it appears from this record in John that she, strangely, had said not a word to the disciples about the wonderful scenes of the night before; and the first announcement she made to them was, when she saw the stone taken away the next morning, that some one had stolen the Lord out of the sepulcher! So she had not been reasoned with at all on the subject, and we must attribute her singular conduct to her own obliviousness. Strange that she should have forgotten that she had seen the stone rolled away the night before; had seen and talked with an angel; had met the Saviour and held him by the feet and worshiped him! If this is so, although Christ had cast seven devils out of her, there was still another left—the devil of forgetfulness! But we will not defame the fair memory of the devoted Mary, by any such unsupportable supposition. To return from this digression, the record in John 20, does indeed agree with Mark 16:9. It shows that Mary Magdalene had not seen him before the first day of the week, and that she was the first one who did see him; and at that first revelation he could permit no one to touch him, because he had not then ascended to his Father. But in his then resumed, exalted, immortal nature, he could go and return more quickly than the angels, whose movements seemed to the prophet like a flash of lightning (Eze. 1:14); and we may suppose that he ascended to his Father, to receive his approval of his sacrifice, and was almost immediately again present on earth to receive the worship of the women (Matt. 28:9), who could now approach him freely, to show himself to all the other disciples, and talk to them more fully “of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God.” Acts 1:3. And as we go back in imagination to that first day morning, and consider what a morning it was to them of multiplying wonders, and joyful surprises; how they must have gone many times back and forth, singly and in groups, to the sepulcher, and iterated and re-iterated to each other the wonderful tale, while they could scarcely believe their own senses,—it is easy to account for all that all the evangelists have written, and find a place for all which they have individually and collectively described, and even more. And it is certain that Mark declares that the rising of Jesus from the tomb was early on the first day of the week. Any other construction spoils the sense of the narrative.