Adventism and Our Answer to “Which Day Do You Keep?”

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 10, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 15.

Read the full edition

Adventism and Our Answer to “Which Day Do You Keep?”

“ADVENTISM AND OUR ANSWER TO THE QUESTIONS, ‘WHICH DAY DO YOU KEEP? AND WHY?’”

BY A. SMITH.
Such is the title of a pamphlet of sixty-five pages, published by Rev. Prof. S. Hemkes, of Grand Rapids, Mich. On the fifth page is the following:—
This title [Adventism] expresses the name of a religious society which has some good points in agreement with the Holy Scriptures. We have met some of its adherents and followers, and esteem them personally. They are earnest and friendly, and mean what they say. In earnest language they warn against the soul-misleading doctrine of Rome, against the dark and soul-destroying power of the increasing Spiritualism, and against all infidelity in general. Then, too, they are zealous for the Bible as the only source of truth, and they urge the necessity of conversion.
A people possessing such excellent characteristics are certainly entitled to a candid hearing, even on questions wherein they differ from the popular views. For it is possible that with an open Bible and “earnest language” they may be able to give light which teachers and people bound by ancient creeds have been unable to discern. Beliefs that have been cherished from generation to generation, which have been instilled into the plastic minds of children, and have become solidified with increasing years, are about as hard to eradicate as are abnormal physical habits, or deformities in person. In either case, a father’s weight in favor will frequently more than equiponderate any amount of Bible proof against.
On page 6, under the heading “The Sleep of the Dead,” are these words:—
“Do they [Adventists] not know the opinions of all those philosophers who taught that the soul of man is an individual, immaterial substance?”
Yes, we know what they teach, but we do not believe it, because the Bible does not sustain the doctrine. Further on in the work he names as believers in the immortality of the soul, “the old Egyptians (heathen), . . . The Grecians (also heathen), . . . Socrates (a heathen without the Bible), . . . Plutarch, a learned Greek, . . . our heathen ancients (Frisians, Batavarians, and Germans).” Why did not Mr. H. go on with his list, and name the holy prophets, and Jesus, Peter, Paul, John, or at least one New Testament writer, in proof of the immortality of the soul? Think you that he would have failed to do so had they, like heathen philosophers, taught it? But Mr. H. adds just one Bible text without comment, to his list of heathen evidence (Eccl. 12:7), and then says:—
Notwithstanding such clear and positive expressions from heathen and the Ecclesiastes and many other sacred writers [Who are they?], the Adventists maintain that God withholds the assertion from man concerning immortality.
Seventh-day Adventists believe that independent immortality belongs to God alone (1 Tim. 6:14-16); that like immortality was given to Christ (John 5:26); that immortality is to be sought for by man (Rom. 2:7; Titus 3:7; Rom. 8:24); and put on at the resurrection. 1 Cor. 15:53, 54.
Mr. H. asks concerning the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, “Was the soul of the rich man dead, or that of Lazarus or Abraham?” The Bible says nothing about their souls. It deals with persons. The rich man died. Lazarus also died. But by the figure of personification, allowable in a parable, they are represented speaking as if alive. Compare Luke 16:23-25, with Isa. 14:4-11; Judg. 9:8; Hab. 2:11; Ps. 35:10. In this parable the rich man was in hades, the grave (Luke 16:23), which condition Abraham contrasts with his life-time. Verse 25. As the dead are unconscious, the whole time between the death and resurrection of the respective parties in the parable will, to them, be only instantaneous; the experience of torment on the part of the rich man will then seem to follow quickly the moment of his death. See Rev. 20:15. The righteous will then be in the city, the New Jerusalem, called “the camp of the saints” (verses 9, 10), and will see the destruction of the wicked. See Ps. 37:34; Isa. 33:14-16; Ps. 11:6; 149:4-9. So if any one insists upon its being a literal transaction, the scene is laid beyond the resurrection.
On Phil. 1:23, Mr. H. says that “Paul’s body would be interred, but his personality, his soul, should be with Jesus.” Paul, indeed, had a desire to depart and be with Christ, but his being with Christ does not necessarily immediately follow his departure, though it was the next event in order to him. He did not expect to be with Christ till he should come the second time in glory. See 2 Tim. 4:6-8.
On pp. 14-18, Mr. H. endeavors to show the error of Adventism concerning the end of the wicked, and concludes with these words addressed to the reader:—
And after you read the Bible, read also true worthy Bible interpreters freely, because they searched the Scriptures during nearly all their life-time.
That is just the position Roman Catholics take. The common people must not understand the Bible except as the priest interprets it to them. How are we to determine who “true, worthy, Bible interpreters” are? If the reader would like to examine for himself more than one hundred Bible texts on this subject, send to the REVIEW Office for a one-cent tract, entitled “The Sinner’s Fate.” Rev. Mr. H. could not, of course, object if you should afterward consult some “true, worthy Bible interpreter.”
Reader, do you think that God would destroy the Devil, and torment man, who is less wicked than the Devil, in hell fire to all eternity? See Heb. 2:14; Rev. 20:12; Ps. 145:20. On the question of the Sabbath, Mr. H. admits that the Jewish Christians in the first ages kept the Sabbath, but says (on page 21) that “in the heathen Christian congregations, the latter [Sunday-keeping] soon became universal.”
Yes, that is it exactly. When heathenism and Christianity became amalgamated, the former gave up the worship of Baal, or the sun, and the latter met them half way by giving up the Bible Sabbath and worshiping with them on the “venerable day of the sun.”
On Rev. 1:10, Mr. H. has the following:—
The early Christians called the first day of the week, commonly, Lord’s day. The seventh day always is named Sabbath in the New Testament. . . . The English interpreters say concerning Rev. 1:10: “We cannot say which day John means except out of the books of the early Christians, who called the Sunday, generally, by that name.”
Let the reader examine the following Bible proof that the Lord’s day of Rev. 1:10, was the Sabbath; Ex. 20:10, where the seventh day is called “the Sabbath of the Lord;” Isa. 58:13, where God calls it “my holy day;” and Mark 2:28, where Jesus declares himself to be Lord of the Sabbath. And therefore the Sabbath is the Lord’s day.
Eld. J. N. Andrews, in the preface to his “Complete Testimony of the Fathers,” says:—
Nearly one hundred years elapsed after John was in vision on Patmos, before the term “Lord’s day” was applied to the first day. During this time, it was called “the day of the sun,” “the first day of the week,” and “the eighth day.” . . . No one of those who give this title [Lord’s day] to Sunday ever assign as a reason for so doing that it was thus called by John.
Mr. H. admits that the seventh day is always called Sabbath in the New Testament. A singular fact, indeed, if it was no longer the Sabbath. Did the apostles give it the proper title, or did they not? On Acts 20:7, Mr. H. endeavors to show that the preaching of Paul at Troas, and his departure to Assos, did not occur on the same day of the week. He says:—
Now, Paul preached on the first day of the week, ready to depart on the morrow, . . . the first day to preach, and the other (not the same day) to depart. For he says the following day.
The record shows that Paul by the term “the morrow,” referred to the light part of the same day of the week upon which he was preaching in the dark part, or night. The night in which Paul preached, certainly belonged to the first day of the week. When daylight came, it was Sunday morning. (See a similar use of the terms “night” and “morrow,” in Josh. 5:10, 11, compared with Ex. 12:6, 11, 12). But Mr. H. continues:—
The first evening of that day is that Saturday night, which the Adventists add to the first day, saying, it was a Saturday night service, and the night belongs to the first day of the week, thus the evening at the beginning of that day. The second evening is that of the evangelists, at the end of each day, because they say, Jesus appeared to his disciples at the evening of the first day of the week, thus the evening at the end of the day passed. One day with two evenings! Strange, indeed, and that alone to obtain a victory for their beloved system in the opinion of the people!
Does not Mr. H. know that there were two evenings recognized at that time? The following testimony shows it to be a fact:—
The Hebrews reckoned two evenings. . . . The Pharisees and rabbinists, according to the Mishnah (Pesach 5:3), held the first evening to commence with the declining of the sun, and the second evening with the setting sun. This latter view [as compared with that of the Karaites and others who believed the evening to be between sunset and dark] was the prevailing one in the time of our Lord, the hour of evening sacrifice and prayer being then the ninth hour, or 3 P. M. . . . A like distinction of two evenings was made by the Greeks.—Robinson’s Greek Lexicon to the New Testament, p. 588.
Concerning the days of the week, and the time of beginning the day, Wm. Mead Jones, missionary to Palestine, has the following:—
Not any of the nations, whether Jew or Arab, name the days of the week Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, etc.; nor do they call the first day of the week “Lord’s day,” nor do they ever give to the seventh day the name Saturday. . . . Never do they count the day from midnight to midnight, but always from sundown to sundown. . . . When an evening appointment is made for a meeting or business, the language used is “night of the first,” “night of the second,” etc.; the only exception is where the appointment or event is soon after sundown, or in the early part of the evening, when the language is “such a day at evening;” but the former mode of speech is the general one; yet in no case do they understand the expression, “the same day at evening,” to mean that that evening belongs to that day, but to the day following.
Concerning the ten commandments, Mr. H. says that “literally they need not be repeated in the New Testament, and really [except the fourth] all of the other nine are repeated several times in the New Testament.” (Italics ours.) I will give Mr. A. five dollars for one complete literal repetition of the nine in the New Testament.
On Col. 2:16, Mr. H. claims that the weekly Sabbath is intended, and quotes a former Sabbath-keeper as saying, “Here the Sabbath is just as plainly named among the things done away, as are the other things; that it is the Jewish weekly Sabbath, is proved beyond a doubt. . . . That the Sabbath was a type or shadow, is directly stated by Paul in Col. 2:16 and in Heb. 4:1-11.” Yet the same author in “Critical Notes,” published by him before he left the Adventists, says on Col. 2:14-17, that “the seventh day is not a shadow but a memorial;” that “there is no intimation here that the Sabbath was done away.”—Dr. Clarke; and that “the passage does not refer to the Sabbath of the moral law.”—American Tract Society N. T., with notes.
The days referred to in the text are such as are ceremonial, and have no reference to the weekly Sabbath. With reference to such days, Paul gives us the meaning of the term “let no man judge you,” in Rom. 14:4-6. Here, if the weekly Sabbath is referred to, it would include Sunday as well. Every man should be fully persuaded, not according to his own mind, but in his own mind; and that persuasion to be right must agree with the teachings of the Bible. In conclusion, Mr. H. says:—
How much better would it be, we said to them [the Adventists], that we Christians all agree upon Sunday. . . . Our Government points out the first day according to Scripture [!] and history. Let us all go side by side, and beseech the Government to cause the Sunday law to be observed.
Yes, that is just it. Sunday-keepers are striving for stringent Sunday laws to be rigidly enforced. Said a California Methodist preacher:—
What we want is law in this matter, and we will have it, too; and when we get the power in our hands, we will show these men [Adventists] what their end will be.
They will succeed all too well, as appears from Rev. 13:15-17. But may the reader and writer be found among the victors in that day. See Rev. 15:2.