AdventAI

THE “HEADS” OF REV. 17:8, SUCCESSIVE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 15., April 10, 1888

The angel who showed to John the wonderful things of the Revelation, said to him, “I will tell thee the mystery of the woman, and of the beast that carrieth her, which hath the seven heads and ten horns.” Rev. 17:7. This language identifies the beast here brought to view, with the beast of Rev. 13:1; and this again establishes its relation to the dragon of chapter 12.

The dragon is undoubtedly a symbol of pagan Rome; the beast of Rev. 13:1, to whom the dragon gave his seat and great authority, is, with equal certainty, a symbol of the papacy; and this latter beast is the same as the beast of Revelation 17. This distinction, however, is here to be noticed. In Rev. 13:1-10, both the civil and ecclesiastical powers are embodied in one symbol; while in Revelation 17, these powers are represented by separate symbols—the ecclesiastical, by the woman, and the civil, by the beast which carrieth her; and this representation shows the relation between the two—the woman riding upon the beast; the ecclesiastical or church authorities controlling the civil.

The dragon and both representations of the beast, have each seven heads and ten horns; and notwithstanding the angel told John that he would tell him the mystery of the heads and horns, it seems to be still a “mystery” to some how the dragon and the beast can both have seven heads and ten horns. If, they say, the dragon has seven heads, and the beast has also seven heads, would not this make fourteen heads in all—seven for pagan Rome, and seven for papal?

Before we adopt such a view, there is another feature to be looked at; and that is, the horns. The dragon had ten horns, and the beast had ten. Now, the same reasoning which would give us fourteen heads, would give us twenty horns—ten for pagan Rome, and ten for papal. But we have never yet heard the expression of any dissent from the view that the horns of the dragon and the leopard beast of Revelation 13, represent the same as the ten horns of the fourth beast of Daniel 7; and that is, the ten kingdoms of Western Europe. But these horns are all shown on the papal beast, as though belonging to it, though not one of them was developed from the papacy, but all were established before the papacy reached its supremacy.

Why, then, are the ten horns given to the papal beast, the same as to the dragon? Answer.—To signify that these two symbols belong to substantially one and the same system. When prophecy reached Rome, it reached a power diverse from all others. Symbolic capabilities were about exhausted to represent it. Sometimes it is treated in its entirety; sometimes, so as to represent its different phases. In Daniel 8 its whole history is represented by one horn, little at first, but springing forth, accomplishing a magnificent sweep around almost the whole horizon, and waxing exceeding great. In Daniel 7 two symbols are taken to represent it, its papal phase being set forth by a horn with eyes and a mouth arrogantly thrusting aside three of the ten to make way for itself. In Revelation 12 and 13, two symbols are used, representing its religious phases conjoined with the civil power; first, the dragon, representing Rome while dominated by paganism, and, secondly, the leopard beast of Revelation 13, representing Rome under the papacy. In Revelation 17, still another symbol is used, representing Rome under its papal phase, but distinguishing between the spiritual and temporal branches of the government; the spiritual, as already noticed, being symbolized by the woman upon the beast, and the temporal or civil, by the beast itself. But it is essentially one system throughout, two of its great symbolic features being the ten horns as set forth by both Daniel and John, and the seven heads as set forth by John alone.

Now, as the ten horns, though given to all the symbols, denote but one series of ten kingdoms, which arose during the transition of the religion of the Roman world from pagan to papal, but before events had so far transpired as to call for a change from the symbol of the dragon to that of the leopard beast, and yet are given alike to both these symbols, so the seven heads denote but seven of the things which they symbolize, not fourteen, though they are given alike to both symbols.

A “head” denotes a form of government. Seven heads must signify seven governments or forms of government. We do not meet with seven heads associated together in one symbol till we come to the dragon, which represents the fourth of the great prophetic empires; that is, Rome. The conclusion is that these heads, whatever they represent, do not exist till we reach Rome; for the head of a symbol could not represent a government which preceded that symbol. The four heads of the leopard, had nothing to do with Babylonian or Persian history. They were not developed till the Grecian Empire of Alexander was divided into four parts. These kingdoms, though independent of each other, are then treated in the prophecy, as constituting together a continuation of the Grecian Empire, or as four different forms of government under the leopard, till that beast was superseded by the great and terrible beast of Rome.

The seven heads of the dragon of Revelation 12, and the leopard beast of Revelation 13, cannot denote division as the four heads of the leopard of Daniel 7, because all the divisions that were to exist in Rome are symbolized by the ten horns of the dragon and leopard beast; and as heads denote forms of government, it follows that we must look for seven different forms of government to be developed after the Roman beast comes upon the stage of action, and in connection with that symbol; which is the same as to say that we must look for them within the compass of and in connection with, Roman history; for Rome in its last or papal phase, continues to the end, and goes alive into the lake of fire.

In verses 9 and 10 of Revelation 17, John extends the explanation of the seven heads of the dragon and the beast: “The seven heads are seven mountains, on which the woman sitteth; and there are seven kings [or, these are seven kings]; five are fallen, and one is, and the other is not yet come.”

This is conclusive proof that these seven heads, or forms of government, are not contemporaneous, but are successive. These changes in the form of government come one after the other, but not all of them, nor any two of them, at a time. It is therefore evident that there is but one head in existence at a time, either under the dragon form or the beast form of that power. At no time in its history does the dragon have but one acting head; and at no time does the beast, which, as a symbol, takes the place of the dragon, have but one acting head. But each are said to have seven heads, because in the Roman system, covered by these two symbols, these seven changes were to occur.

We go to the beginning of the history of the dragon, pagan Rome, and we know that the first head, or the first form of government, was the kingly. Rome was first ruled by kings; and while that form continued there was no other. But the dragon from its very beginning is said to have seven heads, because there were six changes to come; there were six other heads which were prospective. And when we come to the last head, which we know is the papal head, the beast is still said to have seven heads. Why?—Because there had been six different forms of government before this in the history of Rome; in other words, there were six other heads which were then simply historical. While the first head was in existence, the six other heads were prospective; while the last head is in existence, the six other heads are historical. And hence though it is only the last or papal head that is wounded to death, it is said to be “one of its heads,” because the prophecy embraces within its circumference the other six, which had successively arisen in Rome since the opening of its history.

Respecting these heads, the angel said to John, “Five are fallen, and one is, and the other is not yet come.” This must have been spoken from the standpoint of the time then present; that is, the year 96, when the Revelation was given. Rome was then in its sixth change of government. Five preceding forms had passed away. We know what the form of government was, under which John lived—it was the imperial. Between the kingly form of government with which Rome began, and the imperial under which John lived, there had been four intervening forms. What these forms were, it is not our purpose here to discuss. The statements of the prophecy make it certain that such was the case, whether we may be able to find those forms or not. We refer to these facts only to call attention to the situation in John’s day. Five of the heads had then become historical; the imperial, the sixth, was the then reigning head; and one was still prospective. The next phase of Roman rule, of any importance, after the imperial, was the papal.

The short-lived government of Rome by the “Exarch of Ravenna” is alluded to in verse 10, but is immediately passed over, and the prophecy goes on to the next, or papal phase, which, though technically the eighth, is reckoned as the seventh. Though “he is the eighth,” yet when the exarch, which was, strictly speaking, the seventh, is dropped out as unimportant, the next head, though really “the eighth,” is “of,” that is to be reckoned as one of, “the seven.” So after the imperial head, we are to reckon only the papal. But it was not till after imperial Rome had fallen, that the symbol changed from the dragon to the leopard beast of Revelation 13; and it was not till after this change that the wounding of one of the heads is spoken of (Rev. 13:3); hence this wounding could be fulfilled in none but that which was the then dominant head, which was the papal. And in this head we find a wonderfully striking fulfillment in the overthrow of the papacy at the end of the 1260 years in 1798.

It is objected that this gives but six heads to the dragon, and only one to the beast; whereas the prophecy gives seven to each. Not by any means. It is not dividing the heads between the dragon and beast at all. It only shows how many of the heads were developed while the dragon was the representative symbol, and how many after the symbol was changed from the dragon to the beast. But all the heads are contemplated as belonging equally to both the dragon and beast, because these both belong to the same system to which, as a whole, the heads also belong. But notwithstanding this, we can tell readily which head was wounded to death. For whatever was accomplished by or done to Rome before the change of symbols, was accomplished by or done to the dragon. And if it was any form of government developed before the change of symbols, which was wounded to death, the prophecy must, of consistency, have spoken of it as a head of the dragon which was wounded. But as nothing of this kind is said till the dragon gives place to the beast, the head that is wounded must be one developed after that change, and that, as already shown, was the papal.

What is said about the heads also throws light upon the expression found in Rev. 17:8, “the beast that was, and is not, and yet is;” for verse 11 says, “And the beast that was, and is not, even he is the eighth, and is of the seven, and goeth into perdition.” The word “eighth” here refers to the eighth head, which, for the reasons already noticed, is to be reckoned as the seventh, and that, as before stated, is the papal head. Now, when is he the eighth?—Not, certainly, during that period covered by the term “was”—“the beast that was,” nor that period covered by the terms, “is not”—“the beast that was and is not;” it must therefore be the period covered by the terms, “and yet is”—“the beast that was, and is not, and yet is.”

But some attempt to apply this language, “the beast that was, and is not, and yet is,” wholly to the papal phase of the Roman power, the expression “that was” applying to it during its 1260 years of supremacy when it had power to persecute; the expression, “and is not,” applying to it at the present time, while its power to persecute is restrained; and the expression, “and yet is,” applying to the future, when it will be restored and have power to persecute again. If this is so, then we have not yet reached the seventh head as brought out in verse 11. On this view, it follows that the papacy is not the seventh head; and what the seventh head will be, no one can tell. But verse 10 positively assures us that John lived under the sixth head, and that, we know, was the imperial; and that ceased when the western empire was extinguished in A. D. 476. And now we are told that the seventh head has not yet come. But who can believe that a great gap of over fourteen hundred years is thrown in between the sixth and seventh heads? That would be utterly impossible.

In the language of verse 11, we see a clear intimation that the period allotted to “the beast that was, and is not, and yet is,” is the same period that is covered by the seven heads, commencing with pagan Rome; and from that time the application of thep. 233 language seems natural and easy: 1. “The beast that was;” that is, pagan Rome directing its persecutions against the people of God, first the Jews, and secondly Christians. 2. “And is not;” Rome undergoing a nominal conversion to Christianity, during which time the antagonism to Christianity is abated, and the disposition to persecute it is taken away. 3. “And yet is;” Rome, under apostate Christianity, during its papal career persecuting true Christians as before. But to say that at the present time the beast “is not,” that is, that we have before us now no beast, while Catholicism is stronger numerically than ever before, and has all the malignity and hate against the truth it ever had, and all the disposition and desire to wipe off the true children of God from the face of the earth by fire and sword, and is only prevented by surrounding circumstances from doing so,—to say under these circumstances that the beast “is not,” is certainly a wild departure from the facts in the case.

The “beast” is something more than an organization merely having power to persecute. It is a system of gross superstitions, corruptions, and errors giving the disposition and desire to persecute. Such a system it has been since its restoration from the overthrow which fell upon it in 1798. That deadly wound was healed when the papacy was re-established in 1800. If not, we are too early with our application of the two-horned beast; for that power makes no figure till the deadly wound of the preceding beast is healed.

It is said again, that Revelation 17 must apply mostly to the future, because it was one of the angels with the seven last plagues which showed him these things. It was appropriate that it should be so, seeing it was the “judgment” of the great harlot which was to be revealed to him. But in setting this forth, the angel gives an epitome of her history through the long distant past.

We had hoped to be able in this article to make some remarks upon the ten horns and the latter part of the chapter. But our present limits allow us only to say that we see as yet not one particle of reason for dissenting from the views of Revelation 17, which have been satisfactory to careful expositors in the past, were adopted by Adventists in 1841, and are embodied in “Thoughts on the Revelation.”