While so much is being said about an impending religious revolution in Japan; and on the authority of the Japan Mail of Tokio, the government is actually considering the advisability of officially adopting Christianity as the national religion, it is interesting to notice the motives for such a step, which the discussion brings to light. It might be thought that a conviction of the divine truth of the Christian religion, and that alone, would constitute the mainspring of such an important move. But it seems that such is not the case. That motive which is all-powerful in leading the individual to accept Christianity,—that convicting power which operates upon the individual conscience—is wholly wanting to the movement said to be in progress on the part of the Japanese government. Should the step be made, it will be but a repetition of what history tells us has heretofore been done by governments where a State religion prevailed, and of which the celebrated act of Constantine in the fourth century is a noted example. Speaking of the position which the government and leading publicists of Japan are taking on the subject, the Christian at Work says:—
They do not indeed accept the doctrine of Christianity, holding as they do that educated men should be guided by pure reason; but they think the adoption of the civilized creed essential to the perfection of their own civilization, and to the maintenance of a moral standard among their people. The Japanese, they say, have lost their old faiths; and it is indispensable for the safety of society that they should have a new one. Without it they will never obtain that strong coherence and reliance on each other which is essential to a powerful State. Among other reasons advanced for adopting Christianity, M——, a well-known Japanese writer, insists that Japan should take up with Christianity “because it is the religion of the most highly civilized nations.” Professor Toyama, of the Imperial university, supports this view, and alleges that Christianity would “improve the Japanese music [1] and bring with it other advantages.” Others urge that religion is “good for the uneducated,” and that the want of faith in the old religion has lowered the moral tone of the masses. Such are some of the curious grounds upon which the encouragement of Christianity is supported in Japan.
The Christian at Work recognizes the similarity of the situation to that which existed in the days of Constantine, but endeavors to derive some encouragement therefrom by claiming to see in this act of Constantine’s, a proceeding which “was blessed, ultimately, to a receiving and spreading of gospel truth all down the ages.” This, however, is a very remarkable interpretation to place upon the act which changed the State religion of the Roman world from paganism to nominal Christianity, viewed in the light of the terrible centuries of darkness and moral degradation which followed. The simple truth which should be made prominent in the present discussion, is that the Christian religion is a matter which belongs to the individual conscience alone, and is nothing with which the State can have anything to do. As well might one talk of a State’s having a soul and a conscience, as of the State’s “accepting” or “rejecting” the Christian religion. It is by covering up and ignoring this distinction, as concerns religion, between the individual and the State, that the National Reform party of this country hope to succeed in their scheme for a State religion, based upon the compulsory observance of the first day of the week as the Christian Sabbath.
L. A. S.