If the time shall ever come when men will sit down and seriously think, and candidly weigh the evidence on the Sabbath question, they will be ashamed of the way they now treat it. Prompted by that spirit of inquiry that is abroad in the land, and entering into so many thousands of minds on this subject, a correspondent of the Golden Censer asks the editor of that paper what authority we have for saying that Sunday has been the Sabbath ever since Christ’s resurrection. We can hardly forbear noticing a few of the statements which the editor offers in reply. As wholesale, groundless assertions, they are seldom equaled, even on this subject. He says:—
The New Testament shows that, after the resurrection, the disciples had the first day of the week (our Sunday) for their regular meeting day.
If the New Testament shows this, the evidence can be pointed out, and others can find it too. How old is the editor of the Censer? and how long has it taken him to find this out? We have been searching for it thirty-five years, and have not found it yet. But does not this put the disciples in rather a bad light? The New Testament record covers a period of sixty-seven years after the resurrection of Christ. But it is a fact that the only record we have of a meeting on Sunday during all this time, is the record of one solitary, incidental, evening meeting, held by Paul and a few disciples at Troas, in Asia Minor, A. D. 60. Acts 20:7. Now, if this was their “regular meeting day,” and this is all the New Testament has to say about any meeting on that day, is not the conclusion inevitable that they had only one “regular” meeting for worship in sixty-seven years? Then he admits that for even this, they had no authority, which is the one redeeming statement of his article. He says:—
There is no authority for saying that Jesus, or God, or an inspired apostle ordained that after the resurrection, Sunday should be the Sabbath of Christians. This, like the very name Christian, grew up in the church gradually.
The Censer, and all zealous Sunday keepers, would be overjoyed to find some authority that “Jesus or God or an inspired apostle,” did ordain Sunday to be the Sabbath of Christians; and the acknowledgment that there is no such authority, is a confession of failure and defeat and dearth of ground to stand upon, sufficient, it would seem, to lead them to abandon so untenable a position. The spectacle they make, under these circumstances, in trying to bolster up the Sunday as a specially cherished and petted institution, is one to excite the pity of the ages. Here is another specimen:—
In Christ, the letter of the law is done away by observing its spirit.
Where does the New Testament tell us about this? How is it to be done? By the “letter of the law,” here, we are of course to understand the specific commandments of the law. This letter, we are told, is done away in Christ by observing its spirit. Take, for instance, the commandment, “Thou shalt not kill.” The letter is done away; that is, there is now no specific commandment, saying, “Thou shalt not kill”; but we are to keep its spirit. But we ask how in the world we are to find the “spirit” of a law, of which there is no “letter.” And can a man keep the spirit of a law, and break the letter? If not, why not let the letter remain? Take the commandment under consideration: if a person killed another, would he keep the spirit of the commandment?—By no means. And if he did not kill another, would he not keep the letter?—Most assuredly. Then why abolish the letter? The letter and the spirit cannot be separated. Those who are trying to satisfy themselves with such speculations, are simply feeding on the east wind.
The object of all this talk about the letter and the spirit, is simply to prepare the way for a grand twist on the Sabbath question, so as to shift the day over to Sunday. The Censer applies this principle to the Sabbath as follows:—
So, while the Jew must observe the Saturday, or seventh-day Sabbath, the freeman in Christ observes a seventh day, or one day in seven; for that was the purpose of the command, that we rest one day in seven.
What an oversight in the Lord, that he did not tell us what the purpose of the commandment was; for he has said no such thing; and the Censer admits that the letter of the law confines the Sabbath to the seventh day, or Saturday. And what a marvelous kind of law is this, the letter of which says, “Keep the specific seventh day,” but the spirit of which says, “You need not keep that day, but keep any seventh day you please”? And what wonderful discernment some men have, to be able to tell just what the Lord meant, when he has not expressed it. Rather, how dare they give to the law a meaning which contradicts the terms in which it is expressed, and then practice by that? Again:—
He who must cling to the seventh-day Sabbath is yet in bondage to the letter of the Mosaic law, which never was given to us Gentiles. Let no one put you in bondage to the letter of the Mosaic law, but keep its spirit.
This excites our wonder. Here is a law set forth as simply an old Mosaic law, never given to the Gentiles; and yet we must be very careful to keep its spirit. In the name of reason, what have we to do with the spirit of such a law, or anything else connected with it? If that law was never given to us, then let it go—letter, spirit, and all. The fact is, that men unconsciously betray their innate feeling of obligation to the law, in beating around to find so many excuses for changing it, or giving it up. They keep its spirit. But why keep its spirit, if it is not binding? They come as near to it as they can—one day in seven. But if the letter, which says the seventh day, is gone, how do they know that the “spirit” of it is one day in seven? Why not simply “rest” every two or six days, or at any time when it is desired? The commandment which fixes the proportion of time fixes also the particular day.
There is no sense in any of this talk for Sunday. It is a flimsy breastwork of sophistry, which will not shield one in the day of judgment. We would say to all men: Better follow the Lord’s instructions, as near to the letter as may be; and be assured that if the spirit of a law is binding on us, the letter of that law will hold us too.